Written answers

Thursday, 28 May 2015

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Employment Appeals Tribunal

Photo of Clare DalyClare Daly (Dublin North, United Left)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

80. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the procedures with regard to the making of transcripts at the employment tribunal hearings; if stenographer's records are taken and maintained in all cases; the procedure for making these records available to participants in cases and to the general public; and the location where these records are maintained. [21089/15]

Photo of Richard BrutonRichard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

The Employment Appeals Tribunal is independent in the exercise of its quasi-judicial function and I have no direct involvement in its day to day operations.

I am informed by the Employment Appeals Tribunal that it does not engage the services of stenographers at its hearings. Parties to a hearing may, however, engage such services for the purpose of making transcripts and all costs in relation to this are borne by the party who engages the service providers. There are no provisions in relation to making such records available to participants or the general public. However, if a party seeks to introduce any part of a transcript in evidence, the ordinary rules which apply when a document is being used in cross examination apply and in such circumstances the Tribunal would normally request that the relevant extract be made available to the Tribunal and the parties concerned. In the event of transcripts being made available to the Tribunal, these records would normally be maintained by the Employment Appeals Tribunal, 65A Adelaide Road, Dublin, 2.

Photo of Clare DalyClare Daly (Dublin North, United Left)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

81. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation if he will provide a list of all of those who were employed by the Employment Appeals Tribunal in the past ten years; and the roles that they occupied. [21090/15]

Photo of Richard BrutonRichard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

The Employment Appeals Tribunal is independent in the exercise of its quasi-judicial function and I have no direct involvement in its day to day operations.

In relation to the personnel involved in the Tribunal, a secretariat carries out the administrative functions and Members are appointed to hear and decide on cases lodged with it under the various employment rights Acts that come under the Tribunal’s remit.

In accordance with the provisions of the Redundancy Payments Acts, I appoint the Members of the Tribunal. The Members include: the Chairman, Vice Chairmen, Employer Members and Employee Members. A list of the Members of the Tribunal for each of the years 2005 to date is set out in the Appendix below. I would like to point out that the list of Members is also contained in the Tribunal’s Annual Report each year. The Annual Report is available on the website from 2007 to date – see .

In addition to the Members of the Employment Appeals Tribunal, the Tribunal is supplemented by the assignment of an allocation of civil servants of my Department. Staffing numbers of both my Department overall, and assigned to the Tribunal, have changed over the period in line with changes to public sector numbers in general. The specific grades and numbers of these civil servants over the ten year period requested by the Deputy are set out in tabular format below.

DJEI staff assigned to the Employment Appeals Tribunal

YearTotalAssistant PrincipalHigher Executive OfficerExecutive OfficerStaff OfficerClerical Officer
end-201428.50.72.015.81.88.1
end-201337.30.73.018.61.813.1
end-201238.61.03.018.71.814.1
end-201144.61.03.020.71.818.1
end-201035.21.02.016.11.015.1
end-200935.41.02.016.11.015.3
end-200833.61.02.017.61.012.0
end-200729.01.02.015.01.010.0
end-200625.81.01.011.81.011.0
end-200527.91113112

Appendix

2015 Members of the Tribunal

VICE-CHAIRMEN continuedEMPLOYERS’ PANEL continuedEMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued
CHAIRMANJeremiah O’ConnorTadg O’SullivanMaire Mulcahy
Kate T O’Mahony B.L.Peter J O’Leary B.L.Neil OrmondHelen Murphy
VICE-CHAIRMENMoya QuinlanDermot PeakinPhil Ni Sheaghdha
Sinead Behan B.L.Joe Revington S.C.Pat PierceOwen Nulty
Kieran BuckleyNicholas Russell Peter J PiersonSeamus O’Donnell
Pamela ClancyTom RyanWilliam PowerMichael O’Reilly
Charles Corcoran B.L.Jeremiah SheedyJohn ReidCiaran Ryan
Eithne Coughlan (CR)Joseph Smith (CR)Máire SweeneyDave Thomas
Ann-Marie Courell B.L.Tony TaaffeLiam TobinPaddy Trehy
Fiona Crawford B.L.Patrick Wallace (CR)Jean WintersOwen Wills
Emile Daly B.L.EMPLOYERS’ PANELEMPLOYEES’ PANELPaddy Woods
Dorothy Donovan B.L.Gerry AndrewsFrank Barry
Catherine Egan B.L.Joe BrowneTom BradySecretary to the Tribunal
John Fahy B.L.Michael CarrEveta BrezinaMs Frances Gaynor
James Flanagan B.L.Frank CunneenAl Butler
Veronica Gates B.L.Moss Flood Finbarr Dorgan
Myles Gilvarry Angela GauleJames Dorney
Bernadette GlynnTom L GillNoel Dowling
Dara Hayes B.L.James Goulding Patsy Doyle
Graham HanlonEamon C HandleyJohn Flannery
Eamon HarringtonDon HegartyJohn Flavin
VICE-CHAIRMEN continuedEMPLOYERS’ PANEL continuedEMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued
David HerlihyJames HennessyTom J Gill
Patrick HurleyJohn HoranNoirin Greene
Elva Kearney B.L.Ben KealyHelen Henry
Margaret Levey B.L.J J KillianThomas A Hogan
James M LuceyCon LuceyJames Jordan
Dermot MacCarthy S.C.Gerry McAuliffeHilary Kelleher
Orna Madden B.L.Cyril McHughSuzanne Kelly
Roderick Maguire B.L.Finbar MoloneyFrank Keoghan
Sean MahonDon MooreRosabel Kerrigan
Mary McAveetyDesmond MorrisonSean Mackell
Jeananne McGovern B.L.Roger F MurphyMichael McGarry
Penelope McGrath B.L.Michael NooneAlice Moore
Saundra McNallyWilliam O’CarrollJoe Maher
Fintan J Murphy (CR)Tom O’GradyMary Maher
Eamonn MurrayAidan O’MaraDominic McEvoy
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.LJames O’NeillJim Moore

2014 Members of the Tribunal

VICE-CHAIRMEN continued EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continuedEMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued
CHAIRMANJeremiah O’ConnorJames O’NeillMary Maher
Kate T O’Mahony B.L.Peter J O’Leary B.L.Tadg O’SullivanDominic McEvoy
VICE-CHAIRMEN continuedEMPLOYERS’ PANEL continuedEMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued
VICE-CHAIRMENMoya QuinlanNeil OrmondJim Moore
Sinead Behan B.L.Joe Revington S.C.Dermot PeakinMaire Mulcahy
Kieran BuckleyNicholas Russell Pat PierceHelen Murphy
Pamela ClancyTom RyanPeter J PiersonPhil Ni Sheaghdha
Charles Corcoran B.L.Jeremiah SheedyWilliam PowerOwen Nulty
Eithne Coughlan (CR)Joseph Smith (CR)Robert D E ProleSeamus O’Donnell
Ann-Marie Courell B.L.Tony TaaffeJohn ReidMichael O’Reilly
Fiona Crawford B.L.Patrick Wallace (CR)Máire SweeneyCiaran Ryan
Emile Daly B.L.EMPLOYERS’ PANELLiam TobinDave Thomas
Dorothy Donovan B.L.Gerry AndrewsDeclan F WinstonPaddy Trehy
Catherine Egan B.L.Joe BrowneJean WintersOwen Wills
John Fahy B.L.Michael CarrEMPLOYEES’ PANELPaddy Woods
James Flanagan B.L.Pat CaseyFrank Barry
Veronica Gates B.L.Frank CunneenTom Brady
Myles Gilvarry Moss Flood Eveta BrezinaSecretary to the Tribunal
Bernadette GlynnAngela GauleAl ButlerMs Frances Gaynor
Dara Hayes B.L.Tom L GillFinbarr Dorgan
Graham HanlonJames Goulding James Dorney
Eamon HarringtonEamon C HandleyNoel Dowling
David HerlihyDon HegartyPatsy Doyle
Patrick HurleyJames HennessyJohn Flannery
Elva Kearney B.L.John HoranJohn Flavin
Margaret Levey B.L.Ben KealyTom J Gill
James M LuceyJ J KillianNoirin Greene
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued
Dermot MacCarthy S.C.Con LuceyHelen Henry
Orna Madden B.L.Gerry McAuliffeThomas A Hogan
Roderick Maguire B.L.Cyril McHughJames Jordan
Sean MahonFinbar MoloneyHilary Kelleher
Mary McAveetyDon MooreSuzanne Kelly
Jeananne McGovern B.L.Desmond MorrisonFrank Keoghan
Penelope McGrath B.L.Roger F MurphyRosabel Kerrigan
Saundra McNallyMichael NooneSean Mackell
Fintan J Murphy (CR)William O’CarrollMichael McGarry
Eamonn MurrayTom O’GradyAlice Moore
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.LAidan O’MaraJoe Maher

2013 Members of the Tribunal

ChairmanVice Chairmen continuedEmployers’ Panel continuedEmployees’ Panel continued
Leachlain S O CatháinAidan O’MaraAlice Moore
Kate T O’Mahony B.L.Jeremiah O’ConnorJames O’NeillJoe Maher
Vice ChairmenPeter J O’Leary B.L.Tadg O’SullivanMary Maher
Sinead Behan B.L.Moya QuinlanNeil OrmondDominic McEvoy
Kieran BuckleyJoe Revington S.C.Dermot PeakinJim Moore
Pamela ClancyNicholas Russell Pat PierceMaire Mulcahy
Charles Corcoran B.L.Tom RyanPeter J PiersonHelen Murphy
Eithne Coughlan (CR)Jeremiah SheedyWilliam PowerPhil Ni Sheaghdha
Ann-Marie Courell B.LJoseph Smith (CR)Robert D E ProleOwen Nulty
Vice Chairmen continuedVice Chairmen continuedEmployers’ Panel continuedEmployees’ Panel continued
Fiona Crawford B.L.Tony TaaffeJohn ReidSeamus O’Donnell
Emile Daly B.L.Patrick Wallace (CR)Máire SweeneyMichael O’Reilly
Dorothy Donovan B.L.Employers’ PanelLiam TobinCiaran Ryan
Catherine Egan B.L.Gerry AndrewsDeclan F WinstonDave Thomas
John Fahy B.L.Joe BrowneJean WintersPaddy Trehy
James Flanagan B.L.Michael CarrEmployees’ PanelOwen Wills
Veronica Gates B.L.Pat CaseyFrank BarryPaddy Woods
Myles Gilvarry Frank CunneenTom Brady
Bernadette GlynnMoss Flood Eveta Brezina
Dara Hayes B.L.Angela GauleAl ButlerSecretary to the Tribunal
Graham HanlonTom L GillFinbarr DorganMs Frances Gaynor
Eamon HarringtonJames Goulding James Dorney
David HerlihyEamon C HandleyNoel Dowling
Patrick HurleyDon HegartyPatsy Doyle
Elva Kearney B.L.James HennessyJohn Flannery
Margaret Levey B.L.John HoranJohn Flavin
James M LuceyBen KealyTom J Gill
Dermot MacCarthy S.C.J J KillianNoirin Greene
Orna Madden B.L.Con LuceyHelen Henry
Roderick Maguire B.L.Gerry McAuliffeThomas A Hogan
Sean MahonCyril McHughJames Jordan
Mary McAveetyFinbar MoloneyHilary Kelleher
Suzanne Kelly

2013 Members of the Tribunal

Vice Chairmen continuedEmployers’ Panel continuedEmployees’ Panel continued
Penelope McGrath B.LDesmond MorrisonTony Kelly
Saundra McNallyRoger F MurphyFrank Keoghan
Fintan J Murphy (CR)Michael NooneRosabel Kerrigan
Eamonn MurrayWilliam O’CarrollSean Mackell
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.LTom O’GradyMichael McGarry

2012 Members of the Tribunal

ChairmanVice Chairmen continuedEmployers Panel continuedEmployees Panel continued
Leachlain S O CatháinAidan O’MaraAlice Moore
Kate T O’Mahony B.L.Jeremiah O’ConnorJames O’NeillJoe Maher
Vice ChairmenPeter J O’Leary B.L.Tadg O’SullivanMary Maher
Sinead Behan B.L.Moya QuinlanNeil OrmondDominic McEvoy
Kieran BuckleyJoe Revington S.C.Dermot PeakinJim Moore
Pamela ClancyNicholas Russell Pat PierceMaire Mulcahy
Charles Corcoran B.L.Tom RyanPeter J PiersonHelen Murphy
Eithne Coughlan (CR)Jeremiah SheedyWilliam PowerPhil Ni Sheaghdha
Ann-Marie Courell B.L.Joseph Smith (CR)Robert D E ProleOwen Nulty
Fiona Crawford B.L.Tony TaaffeJohn ReidSeamus O’Donnell
Emile Daly B.L.Patrick Wallace (CR)Máire SweeneyMichael O’Reilly
ViceChairmen continuedEmployers PanelEmployers Panel continuedEmployees Panel continued
Dorothy Donovan B.L.Liam TobinCiaran Ryan
Catherine Egan B.L.Gerry AndrewsDeclan F WinstonDave Thomas
John Fahy B.L.Joe BrowneJean WintersPaddy Trehy
James Flanagan B.L.Michael CarrEmployees PanelGerry Whyte
Veronica Gates B.L.Pat CaseyFrank BarryOwen Wills
Myles Gilvarry Frank CunneenTom BradyPaddy Woods
Bernadette GlynnMoss Flood Eveta Brezina
Dara Hayes B.L.Angela GauleAl ButlerSecretary to the Tribunal
Graham HanlonTom L GillFinbarr DorganMr David Small
Eamon HarringtonJames Goulding James Dorney
David HerlihyEamon C HandleyNoel DowlingCR – County Registrars
Patrick HurleyDon HegartyPatsy Doyle
Elva Kearney B.L.James HennessyMary Finnerty
Margaret Levey B.L.John HoranJohn Flannery
James M LuceyBen KealyJohn Flavin
Dermot MacCarthy S.C.J J KillianTom J Gill
Orna Madden B.L.Con LuceyNoirin Greene
Roderick Maguire B.L.Gerry McAuliffeHelen Henry
Sean MahonCyril McHughThomas A Hogan
Mary McAveetyFinbar MoloneyJames Jordan
Jeananne McGovern B.L.Don MooreHilary Kelleher

2012 Members of the Tribunal

Vice Chairmen continuedEmployers Panel continuedEmployees Panel continued
Penelope McGrath B.L.Desmond MorrisonSuzanne Kelly
Saundra McNallyMichael J MurphyTony Kelly
Patrick Meghen (CR)Roger F MurphyFrank Keoghan
Fintan J Murphy (CR)Michael NooneRosabel Kerrigan
Eamonn MurrayWilliam O’CarrollSean Mackell
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.LTom O’GradyMichael McGarry

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.