Written answers
Thursday, 28 May 2015
Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation
Employment Appeals Tribunal
Clare Daly (Dublin North, United Left)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
80. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the procedures with regard to the making of transcripts at the employment tribunal hearings; if stenographer's records are taken and maintained in all cases; the procedure for making these records available to participants in cases and to the general public; and the location where these records are maintained. [21089/15]
Richard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
The Employment Appeals Tribunal is independent in the exercise of its quasi-judicial function and I have no direct involvement in its day to day operations.
I am informed by the Employment Appeals Tribunal that it does not engage the services of stenographers at its hearings. Parties to a hearing may, however, engage such services for the purpose of making transcripts and all costs in relation to this are borne by the party who engages the service providers. There are no provisions in relation to making such records available to participants or the general public. However, if a party seeks to introduce any part of a transcript in evidence, the ordinary rules which apply when a document is being used in cross examination apply and in such circumstances the Tribunal would normally request that the relevant extract be made available to the Tribunal and the parties concerned. In the event of transcripts being made available to the Tribunal, these records would normally be maintained by the Employment Appeals Tribunal, 65A Adelaide Road, Dublin, 2.
Clare Daly (Dublin North, United Left)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
81. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation if he will provide a list of all of those who were employed by the Employment Appeals Tribunal in the past ten years; and the roles that they occupied. [21090/15]
Richard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
The Employment Appeals Tribunal is independent in the exercise of its quasi-judicial function and I have no direct involvement in its day to day operations.
In relation to the personnel involved in the Tribunal, a secretariat carries out the administrative functions and Members are appointed to hear and decide on cases lodged with it under the various employment rights Acts that come under the Tribunal’s remit.
In accordance with the provisions of the Redundancy Payments Acts, I appoint the Members of the Tribunal. The Members include: the Chairman, Vice Chairmen, Employer Members and Employee Members. A list of the Members of the Tribunal for each of the years 2005 to date is set out in the Appendix below. I would like to point out that the list of Members is also contained in the Tribunal’s Annual Report each year. The Annual Report is available on the website from 2007 to date – see .
In addition to the Members of the Employment Appeals Tribunal, the Tribunal is supplemented by the assignment of an allocation of civil servants of my Department. Staffing numbers of both my Department overall, and assigned to the Tribunal, have changed over the period in line with changes to public sector numbers in general. The specific grades and numbers of these civil servants over the ten year period requested by the Deputy are set out in tabular format below.
DJEI staff assigned to the Employment Appeals Tribunal
Year | Total | Assistant Principal | Higher Executive Officer | Executive Officer | Staff Officer | Clerical Officer |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
end-2014 | 28.5 | 0.7 | 2.0 | 15.8 | 1.8 | 8.1 |
end-2013 | 37.3 | 0.7 | 3.0 | 18.6 | 1.8 | 13.1 |
end-2012 | 38.6 | 1.0 | 3.0 | 18.7 | 1.8 | 14.1 |
end-2011 | 44.6 | 1.0 | 3.0 | 20.7 | 1.8 | 18.1 |
end-2010 | 35.2 | 1.0 | 2.0 | 16.1 | 1.0 | 15.1 |
end-2009 | 35.4 | 1.0 | 2.0 | 16.1 | 1.0 | 15.3 |
end-2008 | 33.6 | 1.0 | 2.0 | 17.6 | 1.0 | 12.0 |
end-2007 | 29.0 | 1.0 | 2.0 | 15.0 | 1.0 | 10.0 |
end-2006 | 25.8 | 1.0 | 1.0 | 11.8 | 1.0 | 11.0 |
end-2005 | 27.9 | 1 | 1 | 13 | 1 | 12 |
Appendix
2015 Members of the Tribunal
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued | |
---|---|---|---|
CHAIRMAN | Jeremiah O’Connor | Tadg O’Sullivan | Maire Mulcahy |
Kate T O’Mahony B.L. | Peter J O’Leary B.L. | Neil Ormond | Helen Murphy |
VICE-CHAIRMEN | Moya Quinlan | Dermot Peakin | Phil Ni Sheaghdha |
Sinead Behan B.L. | Joe Revington S.C. | Pat Pierce | Owen Nulty |
Kieran Buckley | Nicholas Russell | Peter J Pierson | Seamus O’Donnell |
Pamela Clancy | Tom Ryan | William Power | Michael O’Reilly |
Charles Corcoran B.L. | Jeremiah Sheedy | John Reid | Ciaran Ryan |
Eithne Coughlan (CR) | Joseph Smith (CR) | Máire Sweeney | Dave Thomas |
Ann-Marie Courell B.L. | Tony Taaffe | Liam Tobin | Paddy Trehy |
Fiona Crawford B.L. | Patrick Wallace (CR) | Jean Winters | Owen Wills |
Emile Daly B.L. | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL | Paddy Woods |
Dorothy Donovan B.L. | Gerry Andrews | Frank Barry | |
Catherine Egan B.L. | Joe Browne | Tom Brady | Secretary to the Tribunal |
John Fahy B.L. | Michael Carr | Eveta Brezina | Ms Frances Gaynor |
James Flanagan B.L. | Frank Cunneen | Al Butler | |
Veronica Gates B.L. | Moss Flood | Finbarr Dorgan | |
Myles Gilvarry | Angela Gaule | James Dorney | |
Bernadette Glynn | Tom L Gill | Noel Dowling | |
Dara Hayes B.L. | James Goulding | Patsy Doyle | |
Graham Hanlon | Eamon C Handley | John Flannery | |
Eamon Harrington | Don Hegarty | John Flavin | |
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued | |
David Herlihy | James Hennessy | Tom J Gill | |
Patrick Hurley | John Horan | Noirin Greene | |
Elva Kearney B.L. | Ben Kealy | Helen Henry | |
Margaret Levey B.L. | J J Killian | Thomas A Hogan | |
James M Lucey | Con Lucey | James Jordan | |
Dermot MacCarthy S.C. | Gerry McAuliffe | Hilary Kelleher | |
Orna Madden B.L. | Cyril McHugh | Suzanne Kelly | |
Roderick Maguire B.L. | Finbar Moloney | Frank Keoghan | |
Sean Mahon | Don Moore | Rosabel Kerrigan | |
Mary McAveety | Desmond Morrison | Sean Mackell | |
Jeananne McGovern B.L. | Roger F Murphy | Michael McGarry | |
Penelope McGrath B.L. | Michael Noone | Alice Moore | |
Saundra McNally | William O’Carroll | Joe Maher | |
Fintan J Murphy (CR) | Tom O’Grady | Mary Maher | |
Eamonn Murray | Aidan O’Mara | Dominic McEvoy | |
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.L | James O’Neill | Jim Moore |
2014 Members of the Tribunal
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued | |
---|---|---|---|
CHAIRMAN | Jeremiah O’Connor | James O’Neill | Mary Maher |
Kate T O’Mahony B.L. | Peter J O’Leary B.L. | Tadg O’Sullivan | Dominic McEvoy |
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued | |
VICE-CHAIRMEN | Moya Quinlan | Neil Ormond | Jim Moore |
Sinead Behan B.L. | Joe Revington S.C. | Dermot Peakin | Maire Mulcahy |
Kieran Buckley | Nicholas Russell | Pat Pierce | Helen Murphy |
Pamela Clancy | Tom Ryan | Peter J Pierson | Phil Ni Sheaghdha |
Charles Corcoran B.L. | Jeremiah Sheedy | William Power | Owen Nulty |
Eithne Coughlan (CR) | Joseph Smith (CR) | Robert D E Prole | Seamus O’Donnell |
Ann-Marie Courell B.L. | Tony Taaffe | John Reid | Michael O’Reilly |
Fiona Crawford B.L. | Patrick Wallace (CR) | Máire Sweeney | Ciaran Ryan |
Emile Daly B.L. | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL | Liam Tobin | Dave Thomas |
Dorothy Donovan B.L. | Gerry Andrews | Declan F Winston | Paddy Trehy |
Catherine Egan B.L. | Joe Browne | Jean Winters | Owen Wills |
John Fahy B.L. | Michael Carr | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL | Paddy Woods |
James Flanagan B.L. | Pat Casey | Frank Barry | |
Veronica Gates B.L. | Frank Cunneen | Tom Brady | |
Myles Gilvarry | Moss Flood | Eveta Brezina | Secretary to the Tribunal |
Bernadette Glynn | Angela Gaule | Al Butler | Ms Frances Gaynor |
Dara Hayes B.L. | Tom L Gill | Finbarr Dorgan | |
Graham Hanlon | James Goulding | James Dorney | |
Eamon Harrington | Eamon C Handley | Noel Dowling | |
David Herlihy | Don Hegarty | Patsy Doyle | |
Patrick Hurley | James Hennessy | John Flannery | |
Elva Kearney B.L. | John Horan | John Flavin | |
Margaret Levey B.L. | Ben Kealy | Tom J Gill | |
James M Lucey | J J Killian | Noirin Greene | |
VICE-CHAIRMEN continued | EMPLOYERS’ PANEL continued | EMPLOYEES’ PANEL continued | |
Dermot MacCarthy S.C. | Con Lucey | Helen Henry | |
Orna Madden B.L. | Gerry McAuliffe | Thomas A Hogan | |
Roderick Maguire B.L. | Cyril McHugh | James Jordan | |
Sean Mahon | Finbar Moloney | Hilary Kelleher | |
Mary McAveety | Don Moore | Suzanne Kelly | |
Jeananne McGovern B.L. | Desmond Morrison | Frank Keoghan | |
Penelope McGrath B.L. | Roger F Murphy | Rosabel Kerrigan | |
Saundra McNally | Michael Noone | Sean Mackell | |
Fintan J Murphy (CR) | William O’Carroll | Michael McGarry | |
Eamonn Murray | Tom O’Grady | Alice Moore | |
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.L | Aidan O’Mara | Joe Maher |
2013 Members of the Tribunal
Chairman | Vice Chairmen continued | Employers’ Panel continued | Employees’ Panel continued |
---|---|---|---|
Leachlain S O Catháin | Aidan O’Mara | Alice Moore | |
Kate T O’Mahony B.L. | Jeremiah O’Connor | James O’Neill | Joe Maher |
Vice Chairmen | Peter J O’Leary B.L. | Tadg O’Sullivan | Mary Maher |
Sinead Behan B.L. | Moya Quinlan | Neil Ormond | Dominic McEvoy |
Kieran Buckley | Joe Revington S.C. | Dermot Peakin | Jim Moore |
Pamela Clancy | Nicholas Russell | Pat Pierce | Maire Mulcahy |
Charles Corcoran B.L. | Tom Ryan | Peter J Pierson | Helen Murphy |
Eithne Coughlan (CR) | Jeremiah Sheedy | William Power | Phil Ni Sheaghdha |
Ann-Marie Courell B.L | Joseph Smith (CR) | Robert D E Prole | Owen Nulty |
Vice Chairmen continued | Vice Chairmen continued | Employers’ Panel continued | Employees’ Panel continued |
Fiona Crawford B.L. | Tony Taaffe | John Reid | Seamus O’Donnell |
Emile Daly B.L. | Patrick Wallace (CR) | Máire Sweeney | Michael O’Reilly |
Dorothy Donovan B.L. | Employers’ Panel | Liam Tobin | Ciaran Ryan |
Catherine Egan B.L. | Gerry Andrews | Declan F Winston | Dave Thomas |
John Fahy B.L. | Joe Browne | Jean Winters | Paddy Trehy |
James Flanagan B.L. | Michael Carr | Employees’ Panel | Owen Wills |
Veronica Gates B.L. | Pat Casey | Frank Barry | Paddy Woods |
Myles Gilvarry | Frank Cunneen | Tom Brady | |
Bernadette Glynn | Moss Flood | Eveta Brezina | |
Dara Hayes B.L. | Angela Gaule | Al Butler | Secretary to the Tribunal |
Graham Hanlon | Tom L Gill | Finbarr Dorgan | Ms Frances Gaynor |
Eamon Harrington | James Goulding | James Dorney | |
David Herlihy | Eamon C Handley | Noel Dowling | |
Patrick Hurley | Don Hegarty | Patsy Doyle | |
Elva Kearney B.L. | James Hennessy | John Flannery | |
Margaret Levey B.L. | John Horan | John Flavin | |
James M Lucey | Ben Kealy | Tom J Gill | |
Dermot MacCarthy S.C. | J J Killian | Noirin Greene | |
Orna Madden B.L. | Con Lucey | Helen Henry | |
Roderick Maguire B.L. | Gerry McAuliffe | Thomas A Hogan | |
Sean Mahon | Cyril McHugh | James Jordan | |
Mary McAveety | Finbar Moloney | Hilary Kelleher | |
Suzanne Kelly |
2013 Members of the Tribunal
Vice Chairmen continued | Employers’ Panel continued | Employees’ Panel continued | |
---|---|---|---|
Penelope McGrath B.L | Desmond Morrison | Tony Kelly | |
Saundra McNally | Roger F Murphy | Frank Keoghan | |
Fintan J Murphy (CR) | Michael Noone | Rosabel Kerrigan | |
Eamonn Murray | William O’Carroll | Sean Mackell | |
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.L | Tom O’Grady | Michael McGarry |
2012 Members of the Tribunal
Chairman | Vice Chairmen continued | Employers Panel continued | Employees Panel continued |
---|---|---|---|
Leachlain S O Catháin | Aidan O’Mara | Alice Moore | |
Kate T O’Mahony B.L. | Jeremiah O’Connor | James O’Neill | Joe Maher |
Vice Chairmen | Peter J O’Leary B.L. | Tadg O’Sullivan | Mary Maher |
Sinead Behan B.L. | Moya Quinlan | Neil Ormond | Dominic McEvoy |
Kieran Buckley | Joe Revington S.C. | Dermot Peakin | Jim Moore |
Pamela Clancy | Nicholas Russell | Pat Pierce | Maire Mulcahy |
Charles Corcoran B.L. | Tom Ryan | Peter J Pierson | Helen Murphy |
Eithne Coughlan (CR) | Jeremiah Sheedy | William Power | Phil Ni Sheaghdha |
Ann-Marie Courell B.L. | Joseph Smith (CR) | Robert D E Prole | Owen Nulty |
Fiona Crawford B.L. | Tony Taaffe | John Reid | Seamus O’Donnell |
Emile Daly B.L. | Patrick Wallace (CR) | Máire Sweeney | Michael O’Reilly |
ViceChairmen continued | Employers Panel | Employers Panel continued | Employees Panel continued |
Dorothy Donovan B.L. | Liam Tobin | Ciaran Ryan | |
Catherine Egan B.L. | Gerry Andrews | Declan F Winston | Dave Thomas |
John Fahy B.L. | Joe Browne | Jean Winters | Paddy Trehy |
James Flanagan B.L. | Michael Carr | Employees Panel | Gerry Whyte |
Veronica Gates B.L. | Pat Casey | Frank Barry | Owen Wills |
Myles Gilvarry | Frank Cunneen | Tom Brady | Paddy Woods |
Bernadette Glynn | Moss Flood | Eveta Brezina | |
Dara Hayes B.L. | Angela Gaule | Al Butler | Secretary to the Tribunal |
Graham Hanlon | Tom L Gill | Finbarr Dorgan | Mr David Small |
Eamon Harrington | James Goulding | James Dorney | |
David Herlihy | Eamon C Handley | Noel Dowling | CR – County Registrars |
Patrick Hurley | Don Hegarty | Patsy Doyle | |
Elva Kearney B.L. | James Hennessy | Mary Finnerty | |
Margaret Levey B.L. | John Horan | John Flannery | |
James M Lucey | Ben Kealy | John Flavin | |
Dermot MacCarthy S.C. | J J Killian | Tom J Gill | |
Orna Madden B.L. | Con Lucey | Noirin Greene | |
Roderick Maguire B.L. | Gerry McAuliffe | Helen Henry | |
Sean Mahon | Cyril McHugh | Thomas A Hogan | |
Mary McAveety | Finbar Moloney | James Jordan | |
Jeananne McGovern B.L. | Don Moore | Hilary Kelleher |
2012 Members of the Tribunal
Vice Chairmen continued | Employers Panel continued | Employees Panel continued | |
---|---|---|---|
Penelope McGrath B.L. | Desmond Morrison | Suzanne Kelly | |
Saundra McNally | Michael J Murphy | Tony Kelly | |
Patrick Meghen (CR) | Roger F Murphy | Frank Keoghan | |
Fintan J Murphy (CR) | Michael Noone | Rosabel Kerrigan | |
Eamonn Murray | William O’Carroll | Sean Mackell | |
Niamh O’Carroll Kelly B.L | Tom O’Grady | Michael McGarry |
No comments