Dáil debates

Thursday, 9 April 2009

Adjournment Debate

Hospital Services.

3:00 pm

Photo of John PerryJohn Perry (Sligo-North Leitrim, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context

The issue of cancer care services for the north west will not go away. The HSE has established what it calls a transition team to plan for the removal of cancer care services from Sligo General Hospital, while at the same time oncology professionals in the hospital are refusing to co-operate with the transition proposals. This is a matter of serious concern to the people of the north west and one to which the Minister must give immediate attention.

To anybody who has taken even a most cursory interest in the strategy to transfer cancer services out of Sligo General Hospital, the current position will not come as a surprise. The original decision to propose the transfer of cancer care from Sligo Hospital was wrong. It ranks among the worst decisions taken by the Fianna Fáil-led Government and its Minister for Health and Children whose legacy as a public representative it will tarnish.

The strategy being implemented means there will be no comprehensive cancer care service north of a line extending from Galway to Dublin. Equity of access cannot be delivered by ignoring geography. It is unacceptable to the people of the region that the present strategy ignores the breast cancer care needs of the population north of this line.

The case for transferring cancer care services from hospitals with a small workload does not apply to Sligo, as the facts show. It is validated, for instance, by the current volume of breast cancer cases treated at the hospital. Sligo General Hospital expects to report more than 110 new breast cancer cases and more than 90 breast cancer surgical procedures in 2009. The hospital has a dedicated clinical team with top class breast cancer expertise. The results prove the hospital is already achieving outcomes to match world class standards. The argument for closing down cancer care centres with a small caseload clearly does not apply to Sligo Hospital. This is an important issue for Sligo and a huge protest is planned in the town tomorrow.

Since the strategy was first announced, I have called on the Minister to provide specific scientific references to justify the transfer of cancer care services from Sligo. On each occasion I have issued this call, she has referred me to a list of articles on the Internet. This is not acceptable. The Minister cannot provide precise scientific references to justify the removal of cancer care services from Sligo Hospital because such references do not exist.

The people of the region are completely opposed to the proposed transfer. Several weeks ago I personally delivered, on behalf of the team doing effective work on the issue, a petition of 50,000 signatures to Government Buildings, providing clear evidence of the outrage felt by people in the region. Since the announcement of the strategy to consolidate cancer care services, I have argued the case for the retention and development of cancer care services at Sligo General Hospital.

The oncology medical personnel are still fully committed to keeping breast cancer services in Sligo. They have also confirmed that they are not, and will not form, part of the transition team. I compliment the medical team at the hospital on its dedication and commitment. This is not a political argument as the medical team has justified the retention of the excellent service it provides. Oncology professionals at Sligo General Hospital are taking practical action to oppose the transfer of cancer care services from the hospital because they believe the development of the present service is the strategy that is in the best interests of patients in the region. Their action has not been initiated lightly, nor is it motivated by professional territorial protection considerations. It is clear to anybody who speaks or listens to the oncology professionals in Sligo that their sole interest is what is in the best interests of the patients. They know an excellent service is being provided in a cost-effective manner by Sligo hospital and that it should be retained. They understand the resources and facilities to ensure patients receive access to the best possible care are already in place in Sligo.

As the Fine Gael TD for the constituency which is impacted most by the proposed transfer of services, I fully support the view that retaining breast cancer services at Sligo hospital is in the best interests of patients and I applaud the oncology professionals on their principled and dedicated commitment and the courageous stance they are taking in not supporting the transition team.

The proposed plan to transfer these services is opposed by the people of this region, as shown in 50,000 signatures delivered to the Taoiseach, by most public representatives and, most important, by the oncology professionals in the hospital and the more than 75 family doctors living in the catchment area of Sligo hospital. I again call on the Government to take decisive action in support of the retention and development of breast cancer services in Sligo hospital.

Photo of Seán HaugheySeán Haughey (Dublin North Central, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I will be taking this Adjournment matter on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Mary Harney. I welcome the opportunity to set out the current position to the House regarding the restructuring of cancer services, with particular reference to Sligo General Hospital.

Although Ireland's cancer survival rates have been increasing faster than most other countries, they are still lower than those in other OECD countries and we must focus on improving them. The goals of the national cancer control programme are better cancer prevention, detection and survival through a national service based on evidence and best practice. This involves significant realignment of cancer services to move from a fragmented system of care to one which is consistent with international best practice in cancer control. There are eight hospitals in Ireland which have been designated by the HSE as cancer centres, in line with the recommendations of the 2006 cancer control strategy. These eight hospitals will operate within four managed cancer control networks, within which cancer diagnosis and surgery are to be located.

The designation of cancer centres aims to ensure that patients receive the highest quality care while at the same time allowing local access to services, where appropriate. Diagnosis and treatment planning is, or will be, directed and managed by multidisciplinary teams based at the cancer centres, but much of the treatment other than surgery may be delivered in local hospitals. In this context, chemotherapy and support services will continue to be delivered locally.

The HSE has designated University Hospital Galway and the Mid Western Regional Hospital as the two cancer centres in the managed cancer control network for the HSE western region, which includes Sligo. Recognising the particular and unique geographical circumstances applying to Donegal, and on a sole exception basis, an outreach service will also operate from University Hospital Galway to Letterkenny General Hospital.

As the House is aware, Professor Tom Keane was appointed in late 2007 to lead and manage the HSE national cancer control programme. Since then, he has made significant progress in implementing the programme. By the end of 2008, 50% of cancer diagnostic and surgical services were located in the eight designated centres. By the end of this year, 100% of breast cancer services and 80% to 90% of services for other cancers will be located in the designated centres.

The implementation of the national quality assurance standards for symptomatic breast disease is designed to ensure that every woman in Ireland who develops breast cancer has an equal opportunity to be managed in a centre which is capable of delivering the best possible results. While the standards provide that each specialist unit should manage a minimum number of 150 new breast cancer cases per annum, Sligo General Hospital carried out 79 procedures on women with a principal diagnosis of breast cancer in 2007.

Professor Keane met in March with representatives of management and the medical board at Sligo to discuss the transfer, which is expected to take place within the next three months. The necessary planning has the full co-operation of hospital management and the national cancer control programme very much wants to engage with clinicians to plan a smooth transition. This is absolutely in the best interests of patients. Following the meeting between Professor Keane and representatives from Sligo General Hospital in March, a transition team is being set up and University Hospital Galway and Sligo have been asked to nominate representatives for the team. I sincerely hope there will be full participation by clinicians in Sligo.

Medical oncology will continue to be delivered at Sligo General Hospital, as will outpatient radiation oncology clinics. Current arrangements to provide supportive or palliative care will not change. On accommodating breast cancer diagnosis and surgery for Sligo patients in University Hospital Galway, the symptomatic breast unit there has expanded considerably in recent years. Funding was provided in 2008 by the national cancer control programme for additional staff to support the expansion of the service, while funding was also provided for additional pathology equipment and for theatre equipping.

The current volume of breast cancer patients at Sligo has been assessed and can be accommodated in University Hospital Galway. In addition, the roll-out of BreastCheck in Sligo, which commenced in March, will further reduce the numbers of breast cancer patients requiring access to symptomatic breast disease services. It is important to note that the national cancer control programme has at all times stated that the service provided to women in Sligo will not transfer to Galway until it is satisfied that adequate resources are in place and GPs in Sligo will also have the option of referring patients to Dublin.

In conclusion, the Government is committed to making the full range of cancer services available and accessible to cancer patients throughout Ireland in accordance with best international standards. The restructuring of cancer services aims to improve outcomes for all cancer patients, through a national service based on evidence and best practice in Sligo as in all other parts of the country.