Written answers

Wednesday, 28 May 2025

Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment

Departmental Contracts

Photo of Rose Conway-WalshRose Conway-Walsh (Mayo, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context

172. To ask the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment the awards made, both with and without a tender process, to management consultancy firms by his Department, and bodies under the aegis of his Department, classed by firm, for each of the years 2020 to 2025, in tabular form; the purpose and a brief description of the awards; the value of the awards and the total amounts paid; the timeline or timeframe of the contracts; and the desired or completed output. [28376/25]

Photo of Peter BurkePeter Burke (Longford-Westmeath, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context

My Department considers hiring external consultants in cases where there is not the necessary expertise to deliver the project in-house, in cases where an external assessment is deemed essential, or in cases where a project must be completed within a short time scale, and although the expertise or experience may be available in-house, performing the task would involve a prohibitive opportunity cost.

My Department complies with the Department of Public Expenditure, NDP Delivery and Reform's guidelines for engagements of consultants by the civil service, having regard to public procurement guidelines.

The detail requested by the Deputy in respect of awards made to management consultancy firms by my Department and its Offices is set out in tabular form attached. Procurement and contracts entered into by the agencies of my Department are a day-to-day matter for the Board and Chief Executive Officers of the agencies, and also subject to annual examination by the Comptroller and Auditor General. However, I have asked the agencies to respond to the Deputy directly on this matter.

Organisation/Firm Name Tender Process Yes/No Purpose & Description of Award Value of Award & Total amount paid (Excl VAT) Timeline of Contract Desired/Completed Output
2020
KPMG Yes Digital Content for Brexit 2020 Website. €9,000 Oct 2020- Dec 2020 Completed Digital content provided.
Crowe Advisory Yes Analysis of collaborative economy in Ireland from an Enterprise perspective Value and paid: €74,970 Feb 2020 – Dec 2020 Report to inform policy on collaborative economy
Implement Consulting Yes Economic and Sustainability impact assessment for Ireland of the EU-Mercosur Trade agreement Value: €200,000

€149,625 paid in 2021 €49,875 paid in 2021
April 2020 - April 2021 Assessment to inform Trade Policy
2021
Ernst & Young Yes External audit of COVID 19 Restart Grant Scheme to provide reasonable assurance as to the implementation, monitoring and control of the scheme; and appropriate administration, disbursement and reconciliation of the funding provided by the Exchequer for the scheme. €92,840 Dec 2021 - Oct 2022 Production of independent report on Administration of Restart Grant Scheme. Findings concluded that the Scheme was administered successfully.
KPMG Yes Digital Content for Brexit 2020 Website €9,000 Jan 2021 - Mar 2021 Completed Digital content provided.
KPMG Yes Retail Sector Study 2021 €39,900 Sep 2021-Oct 2022 Report Published with 14 Recommendations
Grant Thornton Yes Development of Connected Teams Project report €55,181 2021 An Action Plan to support effective blended team working in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, published on DETE website
Grant Thornton Yes Development of an Evidence Base to Support the Development of a National Clustering Policy and Framework €39,624 Sept 2021-Dec 2022 Research conducted and report provided to the Department for Enterprise, Trade and Employment.
Grant Thornton Yes To conduct an independent review of, and make recommendations on, the administrative processes of the Fund, and to make recommendations in relation to the processes required to embed and operationalise a programme logic model (PLM). €42,650 Oct 2021 to Feb 2022 A report to assist in identifying options to improve the operation of the Fund and to advise on a Program Logic Model setting out metrics for use in future evaluations of the Fund.
2022
Ernst & Young Yes Review of independent consumer advocacy in Ireland €49,000 Sep 2022 – Dec 2022 Report furnished
KPMG Yes Provision of consultancy services to complete an economic analysis of the Agri-food Section in the North-East Region (Cavan, Monaghan and Louth). [ In support of the Northeast Regional Enterprise Plan] €24,000 Nov 2022 – May 2023 The intended output of the report is to produce a high level economic assessment of the Agri Food sector in the region.
KPMG No Provision of consultancy services to complete a value Proposition of the Midland Region Smart Connected Technologies Cluster [in support of the Midlands Regional Enterprise] €6,477 June 2022 Oct 2022 A value Proposition for the smart connected Technologies Cluster in the Midland Region.
Deloitte Yes Single Supplier Framework Contract with the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform and Deloitte for the Provision of Robotic Process Automation Software - Training Support and Services. Consulting and Development costs- €91,005; Software Licence Cost €13,100 Aug 2022- Dec2022 Delivered and implemented Robotic Process Automation Software for processing initial complaint applications to WRC.
Indecon Yes Consultancy for EGFSN Report on International Financial Services Skills Needs Value €81,600; €48,960 in 2022 ; €32,640 in 2023 Sep 2022 – Nov 23 EGFSN report Skills for International Financial Services published
Deloitte Yes Implementation of Robotic Process Automation (RPA) phase 1 (IT project for WRC) €111,937.26 (by WRC) 6 weeks WRC complaint form automation implemented leading to improved service and cost saving.
Ernst & Young Yes To conduct a review of the Consumer Association of Ireland (CAI). The department wished to explore whether there was a feasible avenue to strengthen consumer related input to new policy measures and to better understand the space the CAI occupies in this regard. €49,060 Oct-Dec 2022 EY submitted its final report “Organisational Change and Transformation review of the Consumers’ Association Ireland (CAI)” on 6th December 2022.
2023
KPMG Yes Economic Analysis of the Agri-Food Sector in the North-East region Value €24,000; €9,250 paid in 2022; €9,250 paid in 2023 Nov 2022 – May 2023 Economic assessment of the Agri Food Sector in the region to inform the Regional Enterprise Plans
Bearing Point Yes Consultancy services in support of the North-West Regional Enterprise 2024 Data Repository Project Value €7,000, Paid €7,000 Feb – Oct 2023 Consultancy to inform the Regional Enterprise Plan for the North-West
Indecon Yes Assessment of Opportunities and Impacts of Digital Trade Value €80,500; €60,375 paid in 2023; €20,125 paid in 2024 May 2023 – Jul 2024 Report on the assessment to inform trade policy
Implement Consulting Yes Comparative analysis of Ireland’s utilisation of EU free trade agreements Value €65,040; €60,000 paid in 2023; €5,040 paid in 2024 Nov 2023 -May 2024 Report provided to inform trade policy.
Implement Consulting Yes Mapping Ireland's Trade Dependencies Value €118,000; €29,500 in 2023; €90,434 in 2024. Additional analysis in 2025 on US Trade €24,000. Dec 2023 – Dec 2024. Project extended for additional analysis to January 2025. Report provided to inform trade policy and support the implementation of Trade and Investment Strategy
Ernst & Young Yes Development of a Catalogue of Online Intermediary Service Providers in Ireland and the associated online intermediary services they provide in the EU Value €40,610; €28,427 paid to previous provider, €12,183 Paid to EY in 2023 Aug - Oct 23 Database of Online Intermediary Service Providers in Ireland and associated online intermediary services they provide in the EU to inform preparations of the Digital Services Coordinator
KPMG Yes Provision of research to review the labour market impacts of giving Health Care Assistants working in the nursing home and hospital sectors access to Employment Permits. €63,436.25 paid November 2023-May 2024 Report received on 31 May 2024.
Ernst & Young Yes Research and consultancy services to undertake research and a forecast on the skills required for Modern Methods of Construction. €109,834 paid September 2023-July 2024 Report received on 2 July 2024.
Authenticate Consultancy in relation to establishing service level agreement for operation of canteen in Lansdowne house (for the WRC) €4,305 (by WRC) 8 Weeks Report with recommendations and Service Level Agreement Template.
KPMG Yes Development of a dashboard of metrics to benchmark and track levels of MMC adoption in Ireland Value €74,720; €25,000 paid in 2023; €49,720.33 paid in 2024 Dec 2023 – Dec 2024 Output from the project be integrated into the Housing for All insights platform
2024
Ernst & Young Yes Strategic Review of Labour in the Meat Processing Sector (with DAFM) DETE portion €73,493 paid inc VAT May 2024 – Dec 2024 Report on labour in the Meat Processing Sector
RSM Ireland Business Advisory Limited Yes The Evaluation of IDA Ireland’s Regional Property Programme Value: €120,000 Paid: €93,520.33 in 2024 Ongoing from Feb 2024, due for completion Q3 2025 To assess the appropriateness, effectiveness, efficiency, and financial sustainability of the Regional Property Programme.
RSK ADAS Ltd Yes The Evaluation of Deadweight in the Economic Appraisal Model (EAM) (Cost-Benefit Analysis model used in the grant decision making process for projects supported by the State Enterprise Agencies (Enterprise Ireland, IDA) Value €70,000 (DETE portion – co-funded project)

Paid: €71,156.10
June 2024 - June 2025 This review will improve the accuracy and effectiveness of the model and ensure that the Department is achieving the best value for money on the expenditure allocated through its Agencies.
Ernst & Young Yes Delivery of research on the Changing Nature of Trade on the island of Ireland (InterTrade Ireland Report).

Note: ITI is a North South body and reports to the North South Ministerial Council.
€52,529 Mar-Jul 2024 Research Report on the Changing Nature of Trade on the island of Ireland – challenges and opportunities (for InterTrade Ireland)
Indecon Yes Stakeholder consultation review to determine enterprise and research sector perspectives on the Disruptive Technologies Innovation Fund Value: €97,570

€62,960 paid in 2024
Nov 2024 – May 2025 Findings will inform future direction of the fund
Indecon Yes Economic Impact Study of Changes to Sub-minimum Rates of the National Minimum Wage Value €70,000

€24,969 paid in 2024
Nine months

Sept 2024 – June 2025
Economic impact assessment to examine potential changes to the “sub-minimum” (youth) rates of the NMW
2025
Indecon Yes Review of the Regional Enterprise Plan initiative Value €121,950

€36,125 paid so far in 2025
19 weeks An assessment of the impact, effectiveness, relevance, and coherence of the Regional Enterprise Plan initiative
SQW Yes Assessing and quantifying the market supply and demand for scaling finance in Ireland Value €147,600

€31,667 paid so far in 2025
November 2024 – May 2025 Quantitative Assessment of Gaps in Irish Equity for Scaling Investment Market
Deloitte Yes RPA Project phase 2 (IT project for the WRC) €86,782.65 paid (by WRC) 8 Weeks Additional Functionality included on robot to further enhance service levels through digitisation.
KPMG Yes Strategy Review for the WRC €49,695 value – not yet paid (by WRC) 12 Weeks Provision of Organisation Capability, Capacity and Efficiency Review for the WRC
KPMG Yes Study on the economic and societal impacts of data centres in Ireland and the scenarios for developing the data centre landscape beyond 2030 with a view to optimising the future benefits to Ireland Value €99,938

€24,984.50 paid so far in 2025
April 2025 – December 2025 Report to be provided on the economic and societal benefits of data centres

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.