Written answers

Tuesday, 27 November 2018

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation

Legal Costs

Photo of Maurice QuinlivanMaurice Quinlivan (Limerick City, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

329. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the legal service providers contracted by the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement in 2018; the hours worked by each legal service provider; the cost of each legal service provider; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [49229/18]

Photo of Heather HumphreysHeather Humphreys (Cavan-Monaghan, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

Legal service providers contracted in 2018 are set out in the following table.  The table does not include contracts already existing at the start of 2018, nor does it include contracts which have not yet given rise to Fee Notes (e.g. where a case is ongoing).  The hours worked are not relevant in many cases as some tasks are undertaken at a flat fee.

Service provider contracted in 2018Payments made to date
Beauchamps€43,421.63
Neil Steen S.C.€162,247.26
David Dodd B.L.€2,829.00
William Abrahamson B.L.€9,225.00
David Fennelly B.L.€430.50
Declan MurphyB.L.€3,075.00 

Photo of Maurice QuinlivanMaurice Quinlivan (Limerick City, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

330. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the legal service providers contracted by Enterprise Ireland in 2018; the hours worked by each legal service provider; the total cost of each legal service provider; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [49230/18]

Photo of Heather HumphreysHeather Humphreys (Cavan-Monaghan, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

Details of the legal service providers contracted by Enterprise Ireland from January to October 2018 are set out in the following table along with the total cost of each.

The number of hours worked has not been included as this would identify the cost per hour of each legal service provider, which is commercially sensitive information.

Legal Service Providers

Cost

A&L GOODBODY114,233.73
MATHESON ORMSBY PRENTICE2,326.55
MASON HAYES & CURRAN21,855.87
BAKER & MCKENZIE49,499.74
CROSKERRYS806.88
MCCANN FITZGERALD SOLICITORS12,300.00
BEAUCHAMPS, SOLICITORS195,865.78
Total:396,888.55

Photo of Maurice QuinlivanMaurice Quinlivan (Limerick City, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

331. To ask the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation the legal service providers contracted by IDA Ireland in 2018; the hours worked by each legal service provider; the cost of each legal service provider; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [49231/18]

Photo of Heather HumphreysHeather Humphreys (Cavan-Monaghan, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

The following table sets out a list of legal service providers utilised by the IDA from January to September 2018 and the cost of each particular service during that period. The professional fees referenced include a range of services, including land and building sales, land acquisition, lease transactions, grant recoveries and legal advice on various matters.

As to the number of hours, legal firms do submit billable hours where they are charging on a time - as opposed to set-fee - basis. When billed, IDA Ireland checks that the hourly rate charged is in accordance with the tenders submitted by the firms.

Legal Service ProviderDescription of ServiceCost
Gerard CarriggFees re Affidavit x 2 + Exhibits x 224.00
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee905.33
Denis McDonald SCProfessional Fee 3,531.30
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 899.58
Gore & GrimesProfessional Fee 861.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee19,562.23
Gore & GrimesProfessional Fee2,198.91
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee2,954.67
Eversheds SutherlandProfessional Fee 891.45
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 646.60
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 1,151.75
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 5,144.26
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee11,010.30
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee9,534.42
McDowell Purcell Professional Fee368.47
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee2,138.29
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee1,288.48
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee1,168.79
Lavelle SolicitorsProfessional Fee771.99
Matheson SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,158.55
Lavelle SolicitorsProfessional Fee 133.07
Lavelle SolicitorsProfessional Fee 6,031.07
Matheson SolicitorsProfessional Fee 3,827.29
Matheson SolicitorsProfessional Fee 3,344.14
Eversheds SutherlandProfessional Fee 845.50
Eversheds SutherlandProfessional Fee 7,725.90
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee11,740.86
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee3,326.60
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee28,332.04
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee12,810.02
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee410.01
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee8,310.17
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,540.00
Reddy Charlton SolicitorsProfessional Fee 1,000.00
Gallagher ShatterProfessional Fee 65.83
Gallagher ShatterProfessional Fee 1,100.00
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee4,126.55
Reddy CharltonProfessional Fee 1,000.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee2,225.60
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee5,412.00
Reddy Charlton SolicitorsProfessional Fee2,382.50
Gallagher ShatterProfessional Fee4,662.31
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,525.00
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,045.00
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,544.43
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee2,320.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee2,162.50
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee814.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee905.94
Reddy Charlton SolicitorsProfessional Fee1,000.00
Mullin & Treacy SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,755.98
Philip LeeProfessional Fee3,635.50
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee3,154.32
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee 3,500.00
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee 2,890.64
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee1,040.00
Lavelle SolicitorsProfessional Fee 1,389.20
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 792.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 308.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 1,604.40
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 6,140.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 6,029.42
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee  1,122.80
Gallagher ShatterProfessional Fee 10,175.36
Philip LeeProfessional Fee 1,293.48
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee 7,275.00
Reddy Charlton SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,800.00
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 4,896.32
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 4,140.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 547.52
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,540.00
Philip LeeProfessional Fee3,744.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee1,191.16
A & L Goodbody Consulting LtdProfessional Fee2,200.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee 1,706.10
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee1,040.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee3,450.47
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 10,196.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee21,068.73
Reddy Charlton SolicitorsProfessional Fee25,658.00
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee2,037.80
Lavelle SolicitorsProfessional Fee 350.00
Gallagher ShatterProfessional Fee675.00
Beauchamps SolicitorsProfessional Fee 20,777.40
Hayes SolicitorsProfessional Fee 2,448.50
Philip LeeProfessional Fee 2,648.50
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 420.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee 88.00
Byrne WallaceProfessional Fee2661.32
Mason Hayes & CurranProfessional Fee563.30
Total 363,832.92

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.