Written answers

Tuesday, 11 July 2017

Department of Finance

Departmental Expenditure

Photo of Brendan HowlinBrendan Howlin (Wexford, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

162. To ask the Minister for Finance the level of expenditure by his Department or organisations under the aegis of his Department for each of the past five years on photography, advertising, communications advice, public relations, website development, media interview training and preparation; the events, campaigns or policies to which this expenditure related; the company or person to which such payments were made, in tabular form; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [32651/17]

Photo of Paschal DonohoePaschal Donohoe (Dublin Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

The total costs for my department, and the details of the events, campaigns, or policies to which the expenditure related are outlined in a table:

Photography
YearSupplierExpenditure €Event, Campaign, or Policy
2017Sherwood photography758Department of Finance graduation ceremony for in-house Diplomas and the Refund of Fees attended by Minister Noonan
2016Brendan Lyon Photography105Irish Institute of Training and Development (IITD) award photo
2015Maxwell Photography Ltd463Department of Finance Learning and Development Recognition of Awards Ceremony, attended by Minister Noonan
2015Events Portraits Ltd96Irish Institute of Training and Development (IITD) award to Department of Finance for "Best Learning and Development Organisation"
2014Maxwell Photography Ltd511Department of Finance graduation ceremony for the Diploma in Taxation Policy and Practice, the Diploma in Project Management, and the Refund of Fees attended by Minister Noonan
2012Maxwell Photography Ltd285Signing ceremony for Double Taxation Agreement with Switzerland: Minister of State Hayes and the Swiss Ambassador
2012Maxwell Photography Ltd148Signing ceremony for Double Taxation Agreement with Uzbekistan
Advertising
YearSupplierExpenditure €Event, Campaign, or Policy
2017The Irish Times922To communicate the new beneficial ownership obligations of S.I. 560 of 2016 to companies, particularly those companies who were not on the Company Registration Office’s mailing list
2017Independent Newspapers marketing1,111To communicate the new beneficial ownership obligations of S.I. 560 of 2016 to companies, particularly those companies who were not on the Company Registration Office’s mailing list
2017The Irish Examiner375To communicate the new beneficial ownership obligations of S.I. 560 of 2016 to companies, particularly those companies who were not on the Company Registration Office’s mailing list
2015Mediavest7,182Local Property Tax Review advertisements in Irish Times, Irish Independent and Irish Examiner
2015Financial Times12,300Advertisement for the position of Governor of the Central Bank
2014Mediavest130Notice re winding up of SAT/ICAROM (Insurance Corporation of Ireland) in Irish Daily Mail
2014Public Appointments Service2,787Recruitment for the position of Head of International & EU Division in the Sunday Business Post and Sunday Times online
2013Public Appointments Service5,206Recruitment of Chief Finance and Operations Officer in Sunday Times, Sunday Business Post, ACCA and ACA e-zine
2013Public Appointments Service3,796Recruitment for position of Economist – advert in the Irish Times
2013Brindley Advertising687Notices of the Official Languages Act and Scheme in Foinse
2012Public Appointments Service33,168Recruitment of Chief Economist, Head of Banking Policy and Secretary General of the Department of Finance in the Sunday Times, Sunday Business Post, Irish Times and Financial Times
2012Brindley Advertising14,255Notices/Advertisements re Anglo, INBS and Credit Institutions Stabilisation Act as required by EU Directive in Irish media (Irish Times and Irish Examiner)
Communications advicePublic Relations, Media interview trainingand preparation
YearSupplierExpenditure €Event, Campaign, or Policy
2017 & 2016Language Communications LtdNet cost zero as costs being refunded by the banks.As part of a range of competition measures agreed with the European Commission under their respective EU-Restructuring plans, AIB and Permanent TSB are required to provide funding to a public awareness campaign (such campaign to be facilitated by Ireland through an appropriate state body) to raise awareness and promote customer switching. As such the department is currently managing a contract for the provision of Research, Design and Media Buy Services (Public awareness and customer switching campaign) in retail banking markets. This is being refunded in its entirety by the two banks.
2016Carr Communications63,224Following the Government decision of 13 May 2015 on mortgage arrears, the department was asked to coordinate the development and implementation of a communications strategy around the Government-funded and other available supports for borrowers in arrears. The duration of the contract was from October 2015 until June 2016. Responsibility for the mortgage arrears publicity campaign now rests with the Abhaile Mortgage Arrears Resolution Service.
2015ICAN Ltd50,519Under the Action Plan for Jobs 2015, action 110 required an "advertising campaign to leverage support for and drive utilisation of the Supporting SMEs Online Tool and increase awareness of the existence of State supports for business." This advertising campaign was co-ordinated by the SME Communications Group a sub-group of the SME State Bodies Group which is chaired by the department.
2015Carr Communications35,038Following the Government decision of 13 May 2015 on mortgage arrears, the department was asked to coordinate the development and implementation of a communications strategy around the Government-funded and other available supports for borrowers in arrears. The duration of the contract was from October 2015 until June 2016. Responsibility for the mortgage arrears publicity campaign now rests with the Abhaile Mortgage Arrears Resolution Service.
2014ICAN Ltd27,684Creative strategy, production and burst 1 of campaign to increase awareness of the Supporting SME online tool on social media
Website Development
YearSupplierExpenditure €Event, Campaign, or Policy
2015Strata 33,690Testing and review of website
2014Strata 39,255MTES Placeholder site
2014Strata 316,167Live implementation of website
2013Strata 324,823Design of Website and CMS

With respect to the eighteen bodies under the aegis of my Department, I have been advised that four have not incurred any expenditure for each of the past five years on items identified by the Deputy. These are the Credit Union Advisory Committee, the Disabled Drivers Medical Board of Appeal, the Financial Services Ombudsman Council and the Irish Financial Services Appeals Tribunal.

It was not possible for the Central Bank of Ireland and the National Treasury Management Agency to provide the information sought in the time available and therefore I will make arrangements to provide the outstanding information in line with Standing Orders.

The remaining twelve bodies have provided the information sought and this is set out in a further table.

Table ctg.

BodyExpenditure, events, campaigns, policies Company/person
Comptroller & Auditor GeneralAdvertising:

2012:

€2,245.36 Senior Auditor competition



2013:

€3,095.01 Job advertisement



2014:

€600.00 Job advertisement



2017: (to end of June)

€4,305 Advertising budget



Website development:

2017: (to end of June)

€5,305.91 Website Development
Public Appointments Service





Educate Limited

Irish Jobs.ie



Educate Limited





Linked in







Ptools software
Credit Review OfficeAdvertising Communications Advice:

2013:

€5,123

€1,599

€170,771



2014:

€3,690

€1,599

€235,048

€685



2015:

€1,224

€1,599

€275,104

€3,695

€1,666



2016:

€15,363

€3,198

€132,121

€178



2017:

€2,460

€1,599

€116,841



None of these costs are related to a specific campaign, but in raising awareness of the Credit Review Office to target audience through the media.
Ashville

The Phoenix

iCan





Ashville

The Phoenix

iCan

Snap 30





Ashville

The Phoenix

iCan

Small Firms Association

RGDATA





Ashville

The Phoenix

iCan

Image Solutions





Ashville

The Phoenix

iCan
Credit Union Restructuring Board (ReBo)Photography:

(Photography was in virtually all cases coinciding with the completion of a formal merger process)



2013:

€ 590.40



2014:

€ 1,266.90



2015:

€ 3,868.35



2016:

€442.80

€440



2017:

€150



Public Relations: (training)

(PR advice / training concerned the initial launch of the organisation and also some further general assistance / advice on matters within the remit of ReBo – there was no campaign as such.)

2015:

€ 12,547



2017:

€ 15,920
Maxwell





Maxwell





Maxwell





Maxwell

Bartlomiej Szyk





Bartlomiej Szyk













The Communications Clinic





The Communications Clinic
Financial Services Ombudsman BureauPhotography:

2012:

€150 Annual Report & Website



2013

€240 Annual Report & Website



2014:

€120 Annual Report & Website



2015:

€120 Annual Report & Website



2016

€418 Annual Report & Website



Advertising:

2012:

€394 IPA Diary

€8,710 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing



2013:

€394 IPA Diary

€8,105 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing



2014:

€8,104 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing



2015:

€394 IPA Diary

€8,104 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing

€1,830 Recruitment Advert



2016:

€197 IPA Diary

€10,086 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing

€ 3,019 Recruitment Advert

€ 1,622 Recruitment Advert



2017:

€134 IPA Diary

€7,789 Phonebook, State Directory, Internet Listing

€5,001 Recruitment Advert



Communications Advice:

2015:

€2,091 Communication Support & Advice



2016:

€7,232 Communication Support & Advice



2017:

€2,405 Communication Support & Advice



Public Relations:

2015:

€5,123 PR Consultancy



2017:

€3,137 PR Consultancy



Website Development:

2013:

€5,166 Redesign of website



2014:

€6,593 Design online complaint form
Des McMahon Photography





Des McMahon Photography





Des McMahon Photography





Des McMahon Photography





Fennell Photography







IPA

FCR Media Ltd







IPA

FCR Media Ltd







FCR Media Ltd







IPA

FCR Media Ltd

Media Vest





IPA

FCR Media Ltd



Media Vest

Media Vest





IPA



FCR Media Ltd



Media Vest







Keating & Associates





Keating & Associates





Keating & Associates







Keating & Associates





Keating & Associates







Fusio Ltd





Fusio Ltd
Investor Compensation Company Photography:



2012:

€273.52 Board director portrait(s) for annual report



2013:

€144.87 Board director portrait(s) for annual report



2014:

€289.74 Board director portrait(s) for annual report



2015:

€463.11 Board director portrait(s) for annual report



2016:

€307.50 Board director portrait(s) for annual report







Advertising:

2012:

€23,800.67 National Press adverts for the failures of Custom House Capital Limited and Bloxham Stockbrokers as required by s.32(1)(ii) of Investor Compensation Act, 1998



2013:

€8,237.33 National Press adverts for the failure of Irish Bank Resolution Corporation Limited as required by s.32(1)(ii) of Investor Compensation Act, 1998



2014:

€3,684.98 National Press adverts for the failure of Berehaven Credit Union Limited as required by s.32(1)(ii) of Investor Compensation Act, 1998



2016:

€3,836.26 National Press adverts for the failure of Asset Management Trust Limited as required by s.32(1)(ii) of Investor Compensation Act, 1998



2017:

€3,459.57 National Press adverts for the failure of Rush Credit Union as required by s.32(1)(ii) of Investor Compensation Act, 1998





Website Development:

2013:

€2,269.35 Online e-invoice and dd sign-up portal



2014:

€15,928.50 Redevelopment of website with customer account management portal



2015:

€1,353.00 Routine enhancements



2016:

€492.00 Companies Act, 2014 necessitated enhancements



2017:

€6,150.00 Enhancements to customer management portal of website (incl. for GDPR purposes)





Interview training and preparation:

2012:

€450.00 Media Training for new CEO
Fennell Photography









Fennell Photography







Fennell Photography







Fennell Photography









Fennell Photography













Brindley Advertising















Brindley Advertising















Brindley Advertising













Brindley Advertising













Brindley Advertising















Dragnet Systems Limited









Webtrade Limited









Webtrade Limited







Webtrade Limited









Webtrade Limited















Carr Communications Limited
Irish Bank Resolution CorporationCommunications advice:



2013:

€95,848.08 Media and Communications advisory services



€10,356.60 Design Layout for letterheads, customer letters etc.



€49,200 Marketing consultancy services



€21,830.04 Media monitoring



€7,150.13 Various



2014:

€109,662.50 Media and communications advisory services



€18,290.10 Design Layout for letterheads, customer letters etc



€25,298.45 Media monitoring



€13,132.03 Various



2015:

€94,513.20 Media and Communications advisory services



€4,956.90 Design Layout for letterheads, customer letters etc:



€6,294.58 Media monitoring:



€9,909.67 Various



2016:

€13,400 Media and Communications advisory services



2017 (to date):

€1,000 Media and Communications advisory services



Public Relations:



2014:

€25,496.60 Advices on reports, media queries etc



2015:

€45,775.46 Advices on reports, media queries etc:



2016:

€8,266.83 Advices on reports, media queries etc



2017 (to date):

€221.40 Advices on reports, media queries etc



Website Development:



2013:

€7,380 Website hosting and amendments to website



2014:

€10,682.55 Website hosting and amendments to website



€7,318.50 Software licences for website:



2015:

€1,537.50 Website hosting and amendments to website



€3,659.25 Software licences for website



2016:

€1,958.78 Website hosting and amendments to website



€10,977.75 Software licences for website



2017 (to date):

€1,958.78 Website hosting and amendments to website



Note: The information provided is for the period from 2013 (post liquidation) to date. Information prior to the appointment of the Special Liquidator in 2013 is not readily available and the compilation of this information would incur a significant expense given that all legacy systems are no longer operational.
FTI consulting Ireland





Designbank Limited





True Blue Communications Ltd



Kantar Media



Other





FTI consulting Ireland





Designbank Limited





Kantar Media



Other





FTI consulting Ireland





Designbank Limited





Kantar Media



Other





FTI Consulting







FTI Consulting











Drury Porter Novelli







Drury Porter Novelli







Drury Porter Novelli







Drury Porter Novelli











Continuum Tech







Continuum Tech





PT Tools





Continuum Tech





PT Tools





Continuum Tech





PT Tools





Continuum Tech

Irish Fiscal Advisory CouncilAdvertising:

2013:

€553.50 Job advertising



2015:

€1,160.99 Job advertising





2016:

€3,003.02 Job advertising





2017 (to end of June):

€349.00 Job advertising



Communications advice:

2015:

€2,429.48 (Peer Review)



GTI Media Ltd





Warwick University

GTI Media Ltd





Inomics

Irish Times





Inomics







Peer Review Group members:

Lars Jonung

Iain Begg

Michael G Tutty
National Asset Management Agency(NAMA’s communications team is supported by an external service provider, Gordon MRM, which provides a press office service to NAMA and to the NTMA. The costs for this external service will be included in the NTMA data. NAMA reimburses the NTMA in respect of the costs of these services attributable to NAMA.)



Advertising:

2012:

€4,200 Advertising Leaflets

€18,400 Advertising in the Irish Times and Irish Independent re expressions of interest for “Project Wave



2013:

€1,000 Advertising Leaflets



Public Relations:

2012:

€1,200 PR Consultancy





2016:

€1,300 SDZ/Residential delivery media briefing



2017:

€ 857 Annual report press release



Website Development:

2012:

€3,300 Provision of website servers & licenses



2014:

€4,800 Maintenance and development of NAMA website

€18,600 Maintenance and development of NAMA website



2015:

€1,400 Provision of website servers & licenses



€17,700 Maintenance and development of NAMA website



2016:

€4,700 Maintenance and development of NAMA website



2017:

€1,722 Maintenance of NAMA Website
One Productions (W1 Design)

Mediaworks









One Productions (W1 Design)







Stakeholders Communications







Aviva Stadium







Aviva Stadium







Tibus







Simply Zesty



Room Three Design







Tibus





Room Three Design







Room Three Design







Communicraft
Office of the Revenue CommissionersPhotography:

2012: €1,373.00 Photographic Services



2017 to 30th June:

€1,422 PHOTOGRAPHY SERVICES



Advertising

2012:

€960,453 Media Agency

€49,571 State Directory

€33,579 Leaflet Display Brochure Display



2013:

€1,421,645 Media Agency

€147,579 Advertising

€49,571 State Directory



2014:

€1,406,538 Media Agency

€49,571 State Directory

€35,068 Statutory Notices



2015:

€781,990 Media Agency

€49,571 State Directory

€39,356 Statutory Notices



2016:

€889,407 Media Agency

€47,025 State Directory

€42,804 Leaflet Display Brochure Display



2017 (to 30th June):

€519,643 Media Agency

€ 22,162 State Directory

€ 9,935 Media Agency





Website development:

2016:

€888,414 Revenue.ie Website redesign €114,240 Website Content Management

System software

€34,043 Website survey software

€24,700 Visible Thread



2017: to 30th June:

€ 29,292 Clarity Grader Software

€ 24,773 MicroSoft Azure Commitment

€364,244 Revenue.ie Website redesign - Information Architecture design, Search optimisation, screen template design & build, User experience & user interface design & build. Accessibility design & build. Software testing



Media interview training and preparation:

2013:

€10,100 Media Interview Training



2015:

€450 Media Interview Training



2016:

€22,632 Media Interview Training



2017 to 30th June :

€1,625 Media Interview Training

€492 Media Interview Training
PRESS 22





MAXWELL PHOTOGRAPHY LTD







Brindley Advertising Ltd

FCR media Ltd

Inform Display Systems Ltd





Brindley Advertising Ltd

Mediavest Ireland Ltd

FCR media Ltd





Mediavest Ireland Ltd

FCR media Ltd

Iris Oifigiúil





Mediavest Ireland Ltd

FCR media Ltd

Iris Oifigiuil





Mediavest Ireland Ltd

FCR media Ltd

Inform Display Systems Ltd





Mediavest Ireland Ltd

FCR media Ltd

Mediawatch Ltd









Deloitte & Version 1

Zengenti



Qualtrics

Clarity Grader Software





Deloitte, Accenture & Version 1

Visible Thread

CDW UK



















Carr Communications





Carr Communications





The Communications Clinic





Carr Communications

The Communications Clinic
Social Finance FoundationPhotography:

2013:

€159.90 Board Photo



2015:

€461.25 Photos at launch of ‘Credit not Debt’ report



2016:

€362.85 Board meeting with Minister Noonan





Communications advice:

2014:

€11,193.00 Development of Communications and Marketing Strategy



2015:

€3,690.00 Launch of Annual Report and ongoing communications support

€5,596.50 Development of Communications and Marketing Strategy





Public Relations:

2015:

€ 17,378.20 Support for Personal MicroCredit Project (PMC) and promotion of social finance



2016:

€34,255.50 Support for Personal MicroCredit Project (PMC) and promotion of social finance
Sherwood Photography





Tommy Clancy







Maxwells Photography













Montague PR





Q4 PR



Montague PR











John Gallagher









John Gallagher
Strategic Banking Corporation of IrelandPhotography:



2015:

€180 SBCI Breakfast Conference Sheraton Athlone



2016:

€ 1,845 Bibby On-Lender Launch

€ 430.50 2015 Annual Report Launch

€ 184.50 Bibby On-Lender Launch

€ 553.50 Fexco On-Lender Launch

€ 255.40 Event 25.02.16

€ 123.00 Tom McAleese

€ 698.20 SBCI event

€ 553.50 Bank briefing





Advertising:



2015:

€1,716 ISME Yearbook & Diary 2016

€3,075 Annual conference 2015



€9,225 Online portal - Guru Events





€ 372 Taking Care of Business Event 2015

€2,460 Conference sponsorship

€ 2,004.90 Ploughing Championship

€ 28,739.00 SBCI launch event

€ 19,807.00 SBCI launch campaign ATL

€ 818.00 SBCI business cards

€ 910.00 SBCI pull up banner

€ 5,993.00 Radio phase 2

€ 10,152.00 Launch campaign RTE

€ 10,762.00 SBCI research

€221,368.00 Media costs

€1,624.00 Infographic for results announcement



€ 2,041.80 SBCI DL leaflet

€ 2,933.60 SBCI spider banners

€ 4,647.90 Media costs - Google IRE

€ 18,500.00 RTE phase 2 media

€ 84,685.70 SBCI phase 2 media



€ 855 All Ireland Business Summit

€ 2,979 RGDATA annual

€ 2,500 Sales Institute event



2016:

€ 3,013.50 ISME Yearbook & Diary 2017

€ 4,858.50 Better Business

€ 3,628.50 Chambers

€ 2,460.00 First Citizen agri product launch

€ 922.50 SBCI 1 year anniversary video

€ 2,767.50 SBCI case study

€ 1,845.00 Fexco On-Lender Launch

€ 2,300.00 Services to May 31st 2016

€ 3,751.50 Business Plus – advert

€ 834.00 Hotel Hire and sponsorship

€ 2,290.00 Castletroy park event

€ 3,075.00 Chartered Accountants Ireland Sponsorship

€ 280.00 Conference Clarion Cork

€ 3,000.00 DCOC Business Breakfast

€ 1,500.00 Finance briefing 15.02.16

€11,070.00 Online portal - Guru Event



€ 1,296.20 Herizon Event in RDS

€ 2,189.40 Ploughing Championship

€ 3,121.00 SBCI phase 2 media

€ 1,605.20 Sunday business post

€ 25,101.80 2016 planning

€ 535.10 SBCI infographic A5 leaflet

€ 15,437.40 SBCI research groups

€ 2,214.00 Additional research analysis

€ 504.30 Dream Small release

€13,379.90 2016 Radio

€ 2,287.80 Radio re-record & new event

€ 3,078.10 Social Media Pilot

€ 5,676.50 Digital awareness campaign

€ 717.80 Media

€ 2,091.00 DL Brochure -copy update

€ 15,803.50 SBCI Media activity May - June

€ 68,711.00 May-June Activity - Media

€ 1,697.40 Waterford radio event

€ 695.80 SBCI keyrings

€ 15,034.30 Q4 Campaign Planning & Development

€ 3,025.00 SBCI key rings & pens

€ 371.00 Farbic display stand

€ 3,720.80 SBCI Key Rings & Pens Re-Order

€ 1,380.30 Digital & Social activity July & August

€ 1,613.00 SBCI Fabric Display Stand

€ 6,001.20 Digital & social activity Jul & Aug

€ 246.00 SBCI Chamber Diary Advert

€ 6,875.70 2017 Strategic Planning

€ 2,244.80 Q4 planning analysis

€ 66,094.20 Radio & Digital



€ 600.00 Kilashee House Hotel event

€ 2,000.00 Mid-West Funding for Business

€ 289.70 Burratty Castle venue



€ 1,599.00 ISME National Conference



€ 3,075.00 Conference sponsorship



€ 399.80 Seminars General Sponsorship



€ 4,821.60 AD in special SME supplement - Money Plus

€ 1,808.10 Annual conference report

€ 575.00 Wexford Business Expo 2016

€ 123.00 Finance expo

€ 132.30 Business Expo 2016

€ 1,230.00 BizExpo – Citiwest

€ 2,445.38 Ploughing Championship









Website Development:

2015:

€ 10,531 Web Development

€ 7,688 Web and content plan



2016:

€ 3,653.10 Website updates

€ 8,769.90 Design Concepts & Web Development
Molloy Photography







Ballywire Media

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography

Fennell Photography











Ashville Media Group

Chartered Accountants Ireland



Fund SME c/o Guru Expos & Events Ltd



Health & Safety Authority

IBEC LIMITED

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish International

Irish international





Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international



Mespil Solutions

RGDATA

The Sales Institute





ASHVILLE MEDIA GROUP LTD

ASHVILLE MEDIA GROUP LTD

ASHVILLE MEDIA GROUP LTD

Ballywire Media

Ballywire Media

Ballywire Media

Ballywire Media

Berkely Research Group

BUSINESS PLUS

Carlow Chamber of Commerce

Castletroy Hotel

CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS IRELAND



Clarion Hotel

Dublin Chamber of Commerce

Dublin Chamber of Commerce

Fund SME c/o Guru Expos & Events Limited

Herizon

Irish International

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international



Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international



Irish international

Irish international



Irish international

Irish international

Irish international

Irish international



Network Ireland

Shannon Chamber of Commerce

Shannon Chamber of Commerce



The Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association

The Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association

The Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association

The Sunday Business Post



The Sunday Business Post

Wexford Chamber of Commerce

Wexford Chamber of Commerce

Wexford Chamber of Commerce

Whatswhat.ie

WRC













Irish International

Irish International





Point Blank Digital

RED DOG DESIGN
Tax Appeals CommissionAdvertising:

2016:

€5,596.50 National Newspaper Adverts



Website Development:

2016:

€7,448.57 Developed a website
Mediavest







Webtrade Ltd.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.