Written answers
Tuesday, 20 October 2015
Department of Health
State Claims Agency
Michael McGrath (Cork South Central, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
559. To ask the Minister for Health the ten largest medical claim payouts and the ten largest non-medical claim payouts settled by the State Claims Agency in 2014, in tabular form; in each case, the nature of the claim; the personal injuries sustained; the agency's legal costs paid to firms; the amount paid in legal costs to claimants' lawyers; if claimant's legal costs were part of the overall claim sums paid out; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [36109/15]
Leo Varadkar (Dublin West, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
The State Claims Agency has supplied the information requested by the Deputy, as set out in the tables below.
Table 1: The largest 10 "payouts" on claims finalised in 2014 for the Clinical & General Claims portfolios
Damages Paid
- | Clinical Portfolio | General Portfolio |
---|---|---|
1 | €6,500,000 | €805,650 |
2 | €6,419,000 | €600,000 |
3 | €3,500,000 | €600,000 |
4 | €2,250,000 | €560,000 |
5 | €1,450,000 | €475,000 |
6 | €1,450,000 | €415,000 |
7 | €1,375,000 | €375,000 |
8 | €1,063,840 | €300,000 |
9 | €810,000 | €245,000 |
10 | €787,500 | €210,000 |
Table 2: The "Sub-Hazard Type" of the largest 10 "payouts" on claims finalised in 2014 for the Clinical & General Claims portfolios:
Sub-Hazard Type
- | Clinical Portfolio | General Portfolio |
---|---|---|
1 | Clinical Procedure | Slip/Trip/Fall |
2 | Birth Specific Procedure | Investigation of Abuse |
3 | Birth Specific Procedure | Investigation of Abuse |
4 | Birth Specific Procedure | Self-Injurious Behaviour |
5 | Medication fluids/Medical Gases | Slip/Trip/Fall |
6 | Birth Specific Procedure | Crash/Collision |
7 | Birth Specific Procedure | Crash/Collision |
8 | Birth Specific Procedure | Slip/Trip/Fall |
9 | Clinical Procedure | Abuse |
10 | Birth Specific Procedure | Exposure to Biological Hazard |
Table 3: Agency's legal fees paid on each of the largest 10 "payouts" on claims finalised in 2014 for the Clinical and General Claims portfolios
Agency Legal Fees Paid
- | Clinical Portfolio | General Portfolio |
---|---|---|
1 | €450,400 | €106,401 |
2 | €445,811 | €55,521 |
3 | €336,551 | €8,349 |
4 | €275,555 | €67,627 |
5 | €186,589 | €41,987 |
6 | €149,985 | €11,630 |
7 | €370,907 | €38,386 |
8 | €173,284 | €34,371 |
9 | €133,709 | €49,496 |
10 | €189,420 | €31,702 |
Table 4: Plaintiff legal fees paid on each of the largest 10 "payouts" on claims finalised in 2014 for the Clinical & General Claims portfolios
Plaintiff Legal Fees Paid
- | Clinical Portfolio | General Portfolio |
---|---|---|
1 | €1,115,657 | €232,559 |
2 | €868,506 | €94,000 |
3 | €735,000 | €93,093 |
4 | €565,214 | €122,684 |
5 | €462,474 | €91,354 |
6 | €289,520 | €32,956 |
7 | €248,983 | €86,585 |
8 | €233,969 | €74,228 |
9 | €331,464 | €78,966 |
10 | €127,287 | €62,896 |
Response notes:
The data above includes the following:
- The position as of 14/10/2015;
- Both the Clinical and General Claim portfolios;
- Claim Finalised between 01/01/2014 - 31/12/2014;
- None of the settlements were costs inclusive (claimant costs).
No comments