Written answers
Thursday, 14 May 2015
Department of Finance
Consultancy Contracts Data
Joanna Tuffy (Dublin Mid West, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
62. To ask the Minister for Finance the total expenditure on consultancy by his Department; the number of consultants engaged by his Department, in the years 2011 to 2014; the names of the consultancy companies awarded contracts; and the steps which have been taken to reduce the expenditure on consultancy, and the reliance on consultants by his Department, in these years, and for the future. [18949/15]
Michael Noonan (Limerick City, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
The information requested by the Deputy is contained in the table below and is taken from the information already published on my Department's website. The nature of my Department's work is such that, from time to time, reliance on specialist advice is the optimal route. In using such consultancies, my Department seeks not only to obtain value for money, but to target the best return possible for the State.
- | - | 2014 |
---|---|---|
Recipient | Description | Amount (€) |
A & L Goodbody | Provision of registered office facility and company secretarial work for Sealuchais Arachais Teoranta | 1,457 |
A & L Goodbody Solicitors | Provision of legal advice in relation to Irish Water | 53,283 |
Agency Assessments Ireland | Consult re tender | 1,230 |
Alexander Caffrey | Legal: Professional fees documentary counsel | 29,459 |
Aoife Goodman | Legal Services: State Aid. | 23,764 |
Arthur Cox | Legal advice on restructuring of Irish banking system, related litigation and further emerging issues. | 824,247 |
Byrne Wallace | Legal advice on the Strategic Banking Corporation of Ireland | 6,605 |
Deloitte | Advice in relation to Litigation | 97,935 |
Emma Doyle BL | Legal: Professional fees documentary counsel | 29,217 |
Ernst & Young | Agreed fee for tax research paper " The historical development and international context of the Irish corporate tax system." | 6,150 |
ESRI | Commissioned research on the importance of Tax Policy in the Location Choices of multinational companies | 18,428 |
ESRI | Research: 'Financing SMEs in Recovery: Evidence for Irish Policy Options | 122,834 |
Hayes Solicitors | Legal advice in relation to Banking Sector | 6,888 |
Hogan Lovells International Ltd. | Legal Services: State Aid | 3,936 |
Indecon | Professional fees - Agricultural Taxation Review | 103,689 |
Mary Walsh | Expert advice re Taxation | 3,075 |
Mason Hayes & Curran | Legal advice in relation to Credit Union issues | 10,455 |
Matheson | Legal advice in relation to the banking sector | 79,950 |
Matheson | Professional Fees - Secondment | 8,364 |
Maurice G. Collins | Legal Services: State Aid | 25,461 |
MKF Property | Provision of services to review the existing Facilities Management Processes | 28,721 |
NAMA | To cover incidental expenses of the Ministerial Advisory Group on NAMA. The members of the group operated on a pro bono basis | 26,632 |
Nick Reilly BL | Legal: Professional fees documentary counsel | 29,217 |
Philip Baker QC | Legal Services: State Aid | 56,271 |
Private contractor | Development of a Risk Database | 759 |
Red C | AIB and BOI Red C Surveys*2. Professional services in relation to the SME lending survey | 117,957 |
Ronald Brandon Davies | Consult on "Taxes and Location of FDI" | 2,250 |
Ronald Brandon Davies | Consult on spill over analysis project | 525 |
Seamus Coffey | Technical Paper on Effective Rates of Corporation Tax in Ireland | 4,900 |
Silvia Martinez | Legal: Professional fees documentary counsel | 29,217 |
Storm Technology Ltd | IT consultancy: Dept. of Finance contribution to cost | 75,121 |
Strata3 | IT consultancy: website development for the Medium-Term Economic Strategy (MTES) | 9,225 |
Strata3 | IT consultancy: Dept. of Finance website development | 16,167 |
Tandem Consulting | The facilitation of the executive development programme attended by MAC | 10,000 |
VMForensics Ltd | Legal Expert (Air Travel Tax - Discovery Order) | 14,804 |
William Fry | Legal advice in relation to Banking Sector | 20,664 |
Total | 1,898,858 |
- | - | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 |
---|---|---|---|---|
Recipient | Description | Amount (€) | Amount (€) | Amount (€) |
Aram | Advices in relation to Framework Development - Mortgage Arrears | 121,000 | ||
Charles River Assoiciates | Economic Advice to the Minister on competitions implications of the merger between AIB and EBS | 60,500 | ||
Niamh Hyland | Competition and State aid advices relating to AIB pursuant to section 9 of the Credit Institutions (Stabilisation) Act, 2010 | 24,657 | ||
David Barniville | Competition and State aid advices relating to AIB pursuant to section 9 of the Credit Institutions (Stabilisation) Act, 2010 | 36,402 | ||
Mazars | Professional services in relation to the SME Lending Survey | 52,454 | 60,885 | |
Thomas J Foley | Consultancy Services (Mortgage Arrears/Personal Insolvency Project) | 71,217 | ||
BDO | The BDO study, together with an inhouse examination resulted in an overhaul of the film relief scheme. Changes to the scheme were introduced in section 24 of Finance Act 2012. These changes essentially took private investors out of the loop and provided tax credits directly to the film producers. There was also a cost saving for the Exchequer. | 64,575 | ||
Deloitte | External review of General Government Debt statistical error. Report provided to the Department and used to inform management with their decision making process on the structure of the Government Financial Statistics Unit. | 61,553 | ||
Grant Thornton | Professional fees in respect of the assessment of the Credit Review Office | 31,808 | ||
Arthur Cox | Legal advice in relation to the Bank Guarantee Scheme, advising on the recapitalisation of AIB , Bank of Ireland and IL&P (including advice in relation to obtaining various orders under the Credit Institutions (Stabilisation) Act 2010) and defending various legal proceedings relating to banking matters, the disposal of shares in Bank of Ireland to a consortium of private investors, the nationalisation of Anglo Irish Bank Corporation plc, the creation of the National Asset Management Agency (NAMA), the Eligible Liabilities Guarantee Scheme (ELG), the liquidation of IBRC, restructuring plans. The disposal by the State of Preference Shares and Contingent Capital Instruments in Bank of Ireland (combined deal value of over EURO 3.5 billion). | 1,373,060 | 2,879,427 | 1,728,407 |
A&L Goodbody | Provision of registered office facility and company secretarial work for Sealuchais Arachais Teoranta | 2,823 | 2,869 | 2,873 |
Mercer (Ireland) ltd | Review of Remuneration Practices & Frameworks at the Covered Institutions | 73,800 | 72,570 | |
Matheson | Legal advice regarding the acquisition by the Minister for Finnace of Irish Life and the subsequent disposal of Irish Life to Canada Life Limited (a Great West Lifeco subsidiary) and related matters. The acquisition and disposal transactions had a combined deal value of EURO 2.6 billion. | 289,604 | 717,923 | |
Red C | Professional services in relation to the SME Lending Survey | 61,439 | 118,572 | |
National Asset Management Agency | To cover incidental expenses of the Ministerial Advisory Group on NAMA. The members of a group operate on a pro bono basis. | 23,351 | ||
National Asset Management Agency | Contribution to third party legal costs following litigation | 358,144 | ||
Dr. Anil Shivdasani | Expert witness sevices provided in connection with Joan Collins V the Minister for Finance, Ireland and the Attorney General | 82,853 | ||
Economic & Social Research Institute | Economic modelling to serve as input to Medium Term Economic Strategy - spatial development principles(two projects) | 39,986 | ||
PMCA Economic Consultancy | Economic consulting analysis and assistance in support of the preparation of the Medium Term Economic Strategy 2014 - 2020 | 49,043 | ||
Crowe Howarth | Review of the R&D tax credit. The review and associated report informed 3 amendments to the R&D regime. These amendments were announced as part of Budget 2014 and legislated for in Finance No.2 Act 2013. | 36,851 | ||
Indecon | Living City Initiative - cost/benefit analysis | 28,290 | ||
Creative A.D. Limited | Graphic Design work for the covers of a number of publications | 7,472 | ||
Strata3 | Website development - In 2013 the Department of Finance undertook a project related to the design and development of a new high quality public website to replace the current version. The key objective of the new website was to enable the Department to effectively communicate and provide up to date information on our objectives, activities and achievements to our stakeholders. | 46,726 | ||
Brendan P Ryan | Prepared a paper on the public expenditure approval process in advance of the Hall v Minister for Finance court case in relation to Promissory Notes | 828 | ||
Total | 1,670,896 | 3,597,176 | 3,313,889 |
Joanna Tuffy (Dublin Mid West, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
63. To ask the Minister for Finance if he will provide the number and the names of external consultant companies engaged by his Department to undertake information technology related work for the Revenue Commissioners in the years 2011 to 2014; the number of persons supplied by these companies to work on such projects; the amount paid to each company for these services in each of these years; the invoicing contract payment mechanism used, if it was by hour, by project, by person or by a combination of these mechanisms; the verification mechanisms in place to ensure that the invoicing and contract payment mechanisms reflected work actually carried out; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [18954/15]
Michael Noonan (Limerick City, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
I am advised by the Revenue Commissioners that the details sought by the Deputy are set out in the following tables. Where the work was undertaken on a "per person per day" basis, details of the number of persons engaged are set out in the table.
Information regarding the number of persons engaged is not available where companies were engaged to deliver a specific body of work or project. It should also be noted that the amount paid may not relate to work done solely in that particular year i.e. work delivered in a particular year may not have been paid until the following year. Companies providing external resources were selected following a tendering process in 2010 and in 2013.
The work undertaken by external resources is supervised and authorised by Revenue management. Payments in respect of resources working on per diem rates are based on the work-days reported by Revenue managers. Payments in respect of project work are based on invoices certified by Revenue managers.
External resources working in Revenue are obliged to adhere to the Revenue Delivery Method (RDM) which is a comprehensive guide to the activities required to deliver high-value ICT solutions and services for Revenue. It provides Revenue ICT teams with proven processes, deliverables and techniques that enable them to define what to do and how to do it.
Expenditure on external IT resources is required by Revenue to engage computer experts to develop, support and maintain critical IT projects, such as Integrated Taxpayer Processing and Revenue On-Line Services. The software developments that result from such expenditure are tangible assets and are recognised as such in Revenue's Annual Appropriation Account.
Total number of companies | Names of the companies | Amount paid (€) | Payment Mechanism | Number of external resources |
---|---|---|---|---|
16 | Year 2011 | |||
Accenture | 11,690,379 | Per person per day | 119 | |
Deloitte | 3,824,320 | Per person per day | 50 | |
Ergo Services Ltd | 788,607 | Per person per day | 11 | |
Fujitsu (Ireland) Limited | 993,011 | Per person per day | 31 | |
SQS Software Quality Systems (Ireland) Limited | 714,848 | Per person per day | 15 | |
Version 1 Software Limited | 2,667,121 | Per person per day | 27 | |
Advance Business Solutions | 17,584 | Per project | ||
Bull Information Systems Ireland | 44,757 | Per project | ||
Computer Associates Plc | 13,310 | Per project | ||
Gartner Group Ireland | 30,967 | Per project | ||
IBM Ireland Ltd | 46,658 | Per project | ||
Innovative Systems Inc. | 21,772 | Per project | ||
Janacon Solutions Ltd | 2,541 | Per project | ||
Luminary Solutions | 13,510 | Per project | ||
Microsoft | 66,908 | Per project | ||
National University of Ireland Maynooth | 12,100 | Per project | ||
TOTAL | 20,948,393 |
Total number of companies | Names of the companies | Amount paid (€) | Payment Mechanism | Number of external resources |
---|---|---|---|---|
15 | Year 2012 | |||
Accenture | 11,921,757 | Per person per day | 83 | |
Deloitte | 8,020,558 | Per person per day | 48 | |
Ergo Services | 629,789 | Per person per day | 7 | |
Fujitsu | 1,197,328 | Per person per day | 17 | |
SQS Software | 1,014,403 | Per person per day | 9 | |
Version 1 | 2,121,787 | Per person per day | 14 | |
Actian | 9,932 | Per project | ||
Advanced Business Solutions | 3,386 | Per project | ||
Bull Information Systems | 104,690 | Per project | ||
Detica | 374,172 | Per project | ||
Gartner Ireland | 19,680 | Per project | ||
Jacacon Solutions | 1,968 | Per project | ||
Microsoft | 53,136 | Per project | ||
Service Solutions | 3,444 | Per project | ||
WCC Services | 4,275 | Per project | ||
TOTAL | 25,480,305 |
Total number of companies | Names of the companies | Amount paid (€) | Payment Mechanism | Number of external resources |
---|---|---|---|---|
16 | Year 2013 | |||
Accenture | 15,757,847 | Per person per day | 83 | |
Deloitte | 5,335,294 | Per person per day | 51 | |
Ergo Services | 966,324 | Per person per day | 11 | |
Fujitsu | 2,236,034 | Per person per day | 23 | |
SQS Software | 1,218,442 | Per person per day | 12 | |
Version 1 | 3,238,608 | Per person per day | 23 | |
Actian | 3,137 | Per project | ||
Advanced Business Solutions | 1,372 | Per project | ||
Autoaddress | 218,761 | Per project | ||
Bull Information Systems | 423,035 | Per project | ||
Cloudera | 18,134 | Per project | ||
Detica | 298,946 | Per project | ||
Gartner Ireland | 47,601 | Per project | ||
Innovative Systems | 216,718 | Per project | ||
SAS Institute | 17,417 | Per project | ||
WCC Services | 15,744 | Per project | ||
TOTAL | 30,013,414 |
Total number of companies | Names of the companies | Amount paid (€) | Payment Mechanism | Number of external resources |
---|---|---|---|---|
19 | Year 2014 | |||
Accenture | 10,040,711 | Per person per day | 69 | |
Deloitte | 5,031,841 | Per person per day | 32 | |
Ergo Services | 1,323,432 | Per person per day | 13 | |
Fujitsu | 1,708,641 | Per person per day | 17 | |
SQS Software | 379,653 | Per person per day | 5 | |
System Dynamics | 1,433,419 | Per person per day | 19 | |
Version 1 | 4,501,681 | Per person per day | 31 | |
Advanced Business Solutions | 8,715 | Per project | ||
Autoaddress | 39,668 | Per project | ||
BAE Systems | 1,605 | Per project | ||
Bull Information Systems | 269,546 | Per project | ||
Cloudera | 31,915 | Per project | ||
Gartner Ireland | 16,714 | Per project | ||
Innovative Systems | 47,721 | Per project | ||
Intrasoft | 57,761 | Per project | ||
SAS Institute | 10,775 | Per project | ||
Verizon Ireland | 39,252 | Per project | ||
WCC Services | 7,995 | Per project | ||
Zinopy | 23,862 | Per project | ||
TOTAL | 24,974,907 |
No comments