Written answers

Tuesday, 16 April 2013

Photo of Pearse DohertyPearse Doherty (Donegal South West, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

To ask the Minister for Finance further to Parliamentary Question No. 230 of 13 November 2012, if he will provide a breakdown of the legal fees paid by the National Asset Management Agency for 2012, and to date in 2013, including the amount each recipient received from NAMA [16534/13]

Photo of Michael NoonanMichael Noonan (Limerick City, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

A breakdown of legal fees paid by NAMA in 2012 is set out below. I am advised by NAMA that information on the breakdown of legal fees in 2013 will be published on its website, www.nama.ie, alongside publication of its Section 55 Quarterly Reports and Accounts for each quarter during 2013. Legal fees paid by NAMA in 2012 amount to €3.28 million in relation to the management of its acquired portfolio of loans.

NAMA has paid further legal fees of €18.4 million which are recoverable as outlined below:

- €0.68 million in legal due diligence expenses in connection with the acquisition of residual loans being acquired from the Participating Institutions.

- €17.7 million in borrower recoverable costs (principally legal fees) which NAMA has incurred on behalf of NAMA borrowers. Such costs have been taken as an impairment charge as necessary in NAMA's financial statements.

The breakdown of the 2012 fees by recipient is provided below. The amounts paid include VAT.

1. 2012 Legal Costs

Legal2012
€'000
Arthur Cox473
Matheson Ormsby Prentice403
Simmons & Simmons320
A&L Goodbody Solicitors301
McCann Fitzgerald273
Eugene F Collins272
Paul Sreenan169
Cian Ferriter129
Byrne Wallace116
Maples And Calder60
Eversheds O'Donnell Sweeney48
Allen & Overy 46
Parker, Hudson, Rainer & Dobbs 46
Olswang44
Linklaters44
Arthur Cox Northern Ireland38
Private Security (Ireland) Limited34
Beauchamps Solicitors34
Vieira De Almeida & Associados32
Mary Fay BL28
Hayes Solicitors25
LK Shields Solicitors24
Ciaran Lewis21
Hibernian Legal International Ltd19
James Doherty BL19
Taylor Wessing LLP19
Quarles & Brady LLP18
Nathy Dunleavy18
Garrigues17
Owen Hickey Senior Counsel17
Elvinger, Hoss & Prussen14
Knight Frank (Dublin)12
Ogier12
Tods Murray10
William Abrahamson, BL10
Malone O Regan Environmental Services Ltd10
Tughans Solicitors8
Mc Dowell Purcell Solicitors8
Simmons & Simmons Llp (Amsterdam)7
William Fry Solicitors7
Vision Net6
A & L Goodbody Northern Ireland6
J.W. ODonovan Solicitors6
Shook Lin & Bok Llp6
McGill Planning Ltd6
Sanderson Weatherall Llp5
Wragge & Co5
Barry C. Galvin & Son Solicitors5
Carey Olsen3
Miley & Miley Solicitors3
ICSA Software International3
Appleby (St Helier- Jersey)3
Snr Denton Uk Llp2
John Redmond2
DLA Piper UK2
Burges Salmon Llp2
Taylor Wessing (Paris)2
Hogan Lovells International Llp1
Walsh Associates1
Garcia-Torrent & Garcia Cueto1
Appleby (Isle Of Man)1
DLA Piper UK LLP (Germany)1
Cassels Brock & Blackwell Llp1
Marston Book Services Ltd 1
3,279

2. 2012 Legal Due Diligence Costs – Recoverable from Participation Institutions

Legal due diligence costs are costs that NAMA has incurred in connection with acquiring the portfolio of loans from the Participating Institutions. Legal due diligence costs are recovered from the Participating Institutions through a reduction in the acquisition value.

Due Diligence2012
€'000
Hogan Lovells International Llp144
Arthur Cox96
Arthur Cox Northern Ireland91
Beauchamps Solicitors77
Andrew Crean-Lynch Solicitors64
Matheson Ormsby Prentice63
Mason Hayes + Curran34
A&L Goodbody Solicitors28
McCann Fitzgerald26
Eversheds O'Donnell Sweeney20
Snr Denton Uk Llp15
Allen & Overy Llp12
Gore & Grimes Solicitors7
Dillon Eustace5
Byrne Wallace2
684

3. 2012 Borrower Recoverable Costs

Borrower recoverable costs are principally legal fees which NAMA has incurred on behalf of NAMA borrowers. Where the borrower is in a position to repay such costs NAMA will seek the repayment in cash. To the extent the borrower is not in a position to repay those costs, NAMA will add these costs to the borrower's debt obligations to NAMA. Such costs have been taken as an impairment charge as necessary in NAMA's financial statements.

Borrower Recoverable2012
€'000
McCann Fitzgerald1,708
William Fry Solicitors1,239
A&L Goodbody Solicitors1,166
Hogan Lovells International1,142
Eversheds O'Donnell Sweeney1,117
DLA Piper UK 1,019
Arthur Cox832
Byrne Wallace596
Maples And Calder563
Simmons & Simmons520
Taylor Wessing 446
Wragge & Co437
Ronan Daly Jermyn Solicitors414
Beauchamps Solicitors401
Servulo & Associados393
Gartlan Furey Solicitors382
Hayes Solicitors279
Stroock & Stroock & Lavan275
Whitney Moore Solicitors260
Cian Ferriter246
Paul Sreenan227
Quarles & Brady222
McCarter & English221
Matheson Ormsby Prentice196
Gordons Commercial Solicitors190
Lavelle Coleman Solicitors178
K & L Gates167
Addleshaw Goddard131
DLA Piper (Paris)125
Alfred Thornton & Company112
Eversheds 109
Snr Denton Uk108
Altana98
Taylor Wessing (Paris)98
Appleby (Isle Of Man)91
Mc Dowell Purcell Solicitors83
Allen & Overy 80
Mason Hayes + Curran80
A & L Goodbody Northern Ireland76
Cassels Brock & Blackwell 72
John McKee & Son Solicitors72
Arthur Cox Northern Ireland72
Bedell Cristin64
Tughans Solicitors63
Cms Cameron Mckenna60
Windels Marx Lane & Mittendorf 58
Graf Von Westphalen57
Ogier39
G O Nuallain & Co38
Wildgen38
Taylor Wessing (Munchen)37
DLA Piper UK (Manchester)36
Barry C. Galvin & Son Solicitors35
EC Harris Built Asset Consultancy32
Elvinger, Hoss & Prussen28
Mark Sanfey26
Appleby (British Virgin Islands)25
Michael McDowell S.C22
Allen & Gledhill 22
Taylor Wessing (Hamburg)21
James Doherty BL20
Andrew Fitzpatrick BL19
John Breslin BL19
Eoin Mccullough19
Deacy Gilligan Ltd.19
Eugene F Collins18
Landwell Pricewaterhousecoopers Tax&Legal Services18
Herbert Smith Paris18
Herrick Feinstein17
Rossa Fanning BL16
Carey Olsen15
Herbert Smith15
P.J. O Driscoll & Sons15
Jarlath Ryan15
J.W. ODonovan Solicitors15
Robert Fitzpatrick BL14
DLA Piper UK Llp (Germany)14
Allen & Overy (Aisa) Pte Ltd14
Control Solutions14
Boyanov & Co13
IFM Trust Limited13
Garcia-Torrent & Garcia Cueto13
A.C. Forde & Co Solicitors13
JLT Ireland13
Peden & Reid Solicitors12
O'Flynn Exhams Solicitors12
Arendt & Medernach12
DWF12
LK Shields Solicitors12
Carson Mcdowell11
Orpen Franks Solicitors10
Camilleri Preziosi10
Mckenna Durkan Solicitors10
Olswang Llp10
Cains10
JPA Brenson Lawlor Limited9
Clifford Chance9
Wierzbowski Eversheds9
Lopez Balina - Miras S.C.P.9
Karole Cuddihy BL9
Cort & Cort9
Uria Menedez8
Aon Risk Solutions8
Forgo, Damjanovic & Partners Law Firm8
Loyens & Loeff8
Gavin Ralston Senior Counsel7
DLA Piper (Poland)7
CB Richard Ellis (Gbp) Ltd7
Kelly Walsh Property Advisors & Agents7
C&H Jefferson Solicitors6
Tods Murray6
First Ireland Risk Management6
Kane Tuohy Solicitors6
Cyril Oneill6
Abacus II5
Bernadette Kirby5
Peter Fitzpatrick & Company5
DLA Piper UK LLP (Belgium)4
Knight Frank (Dublin)4
Triay & Triay4
Walkers4
Salans & Associes4
DMH Stallard Llp4
Stevens & Bolton Llp4
Carrroll Kelly & Oconnor Solicitors4
Woods Hogan Solicitors4
Aspect Consulting4
K Tech Security Ltd3
Loncar & Andric3
Dillon Eustace3
John Spain Associates3
Millar McCall Wylie Llp3
McGuire Desmond Solicitors3
Kromann Reumert3
Ronan Kennedy BL3
Cheeswrights Notories Public3
Eoin Clifford3
Corporate Access (Legal Services) Ltd2
Polish Properties Sp.Z.O.O2
Gaftarnik, Le Douarin & Associes2
Nabarro2
Davis Langdon2
John Redmond2
Lambert Smith Hampton2
Turley Associates Ltd2
MMP Project Management2
Kingsbury2
DLA Piper Prague Llp2
Gwen Malone1
Richard Kearney Engineering Ltd.1
BJ Associes Sarl1
Rochford Brady Legal Services Ltd1
BTW Shiells Commercial Property Consultants1
RB Legal Services Limited1
BTO Brechin Tidal Oatts Solicitors1
DLA Piper Uk LLP (Liverpool)1
TLT LLP1
MKB Russells Solicitors1
17,705

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.