Written answers

Wednesday, 17 October 2012

Department of Public Expenditure and Reform

Departmental Legal Costs

Photo of Mary Lou McDonaldMary Lou McDonald (Dublin Central, Sinn Fein)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

To ask the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform if he will provide details in tabular form for the years 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 and to date in 2012 inclusive, of the arrangements entered into by him, any body under his aegis or State agency for which he has responsibility for the obtaining of advice from a senior or junior counsel and or a firm of solicitors; the subject matter for which advice was sought; the names of the barristers' and solicitors' firms concerned and the fees paid; the nature of the work concerned; if in each case the matter was advertised for competitive tender; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [45319/12]

Photo of Brendan HowlinBrendan Howlin (Wexford, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

My Department was established in 2011. Expenditure in relation to any legal advice sought from 2008 to December 2010 is covered by material provided by the Department of Finance. In respect of 2011 and to date in 2012 the following is the position:

YearNameFees paid Nature of the workIf Advertised
2012Richard Humphries,
Senior Counsel
43,404.55 Legal ConsultancyYes
2012Ciara Kennedy,
Junior Counsel
8,058.40 Legal Consultancy.Yes

The position in respect of the offices and agencies under the aegis of my Department is as follows:

Valuation Office

The Valuation Office do not directly engage counsel or solicitors. Legal advices relating to valuation cases are requested from the Chief State Solicitor’s Office. The CSSO makes the arrangements to obtain and provide the advices. Requests for legal advices relating to administrative matters are requested from the Attorney General’s Office. The legal advices are provided by the staff of the Attorney General’s Office.

Public Appointments Service

YearName Fees paid Nature of the workIf Advertised
2008Matheson Ormsby Prentice€17,000Legal advice on a commercial contract of a particularly complex natureNo (emergency situation)
2010Mason Hayes and Curran€990 + VATLegal advice on drafting of disciplinary process for dealing with absenteeism.Yes

Office of the Information Commissioner/Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information

2011Mason, Hayes & Curran70,843See belowY
Year NameFees PaidAdvice SoughtTender Y/N
2011Emily Egan1,119N*
2011Catherine Donnelly11,096N*
2011Niamh Hyland1,725N*
2011Nuala Butler4,007N*
2011Brian O’Moore SC6,500N*
2012Mason, Hayes & Curran27,660Y
2012Barry Doyle & Co Solicitors7,380N*

Year NameFees PaidAdvice SoughtTender Y/N
2011Mason, Hayes & Curran70,843See belowY
2011Emily Egan1,119N*
2011Catherine Donnelly11,096N*
2011Niamh Hyland1,725N*
2011Nuala Butler4,007N*
2011Brian O’Moore SC6,500N*
2012Mason, Hayes & Curran27,660Y
2012Barry Doyle & Co Solicitors7,380N*

The Office of the Information Commissioner engages legal advisors to act for the Commissioner in relation to appeals to the High Court of review decisions of the Commissioner, and in relation to any subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court, to advise generally on procedural matters arising under the FOI Acts, to provide legal advice on the interpretation of the FOI Acts or of other statutes, or on other legal questions, to assist, where appropriate, in the drafting of decisions by the Information Commissioner or her staff under the FOI Acts; and to advise, where appropriate, on referring questions of law to the High Court under subsection 42(5) of the FOI Acts.

The Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information engages legal advisors to act for the Commissioner in relation to appeals to the High Court, made under Article 13 of the Regulations and in relation to any subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court, to advise generally on matters arising from the Commissioner's role in the Regulation or the Directive, including matters of European law, to assist, where appropriate, in the drafting of decisions by the Commissioner or her staff; and to advise, where appropriate, on referring questions of law to the High Court under Article 11(9) of the Regulations.

Office of the Ombudsman

Year NameFees PaidAdvice SoughtTender Y/N
2011Berna Grist2,500See belowN*
2011Eamonn Galligan2,359N*
2011Nuala Butler2,783N*
2011Siobhan Phelan, BL907N*
2012Mason, Hayes & Curran4,339Y
2012Ita Mangan615N*
2012Francis Kieran1,750N*

The Office of the Ombudsman engages legal advisors to provide legal advice on the interpretation of the Ombudsman Act, other statutes, statutory instruments, regulations etc. as applying to bodies within remit or on other legal questions and to represent the Ombudsman in any legal proceedings in which the Office is involved.

Standards in Public Office Commission (SIPO)

Year

NameFees PaidAdvice SoughtTender Y/N
2011A & L Goodbody54,562Y
2011Berna Grist2,500N*
2011Oliver P.Morahan & Sons14,074N*
2012A & L Goodbody72,175Y

The Standards in Public Office Commission engages legal advisors to advise on matters arising relating to the functions of the Standards Commission under the Ethics in Public Office Acts 1995 and 2001, the Electoral Act 1997, as amended, and the Oireachtas (Ministerial and Parliamentary Offices) (Amendment) Act 2001, including procedural matters, interpretation of the legislation, specific requests for advice received under the legislation, investigations under the Ethics in Public Office Acts 1995 and 2001, enquiries conducted under the Electoral Acts 1997, as amended, and the Oireachtas (Ministerial and Parliamentary Offices) (Amendment) Act 2001.

Commission for Public Service Appointments (CPSA)

Year NameFees PaidAdvice SoughtTender Y/N
2011Matheson, Ormsby, Prentice22,098See below.Y
2012Matheson, Ormsby, Prentice1309Y

The Commission for Public Service Appointments engages legal advisors to advise on matters arising relating to the functions of the Commission under the Public Service Management (Recruitment & Appointment) Act (2004), including procedural matters, interpretation of the legislation and specific requests for advice received under the legislation

* The Offices of the Ombudsman/Information Commissioner/Commissioner for Environmental Information and the Standards in Public Office Commission engage legal advisors following the completion of formal tender processes. On occasion, Counsel is required to represent one of the Offices in the Courts. In such cases, Counsel is generally engaged on the recommendation of the relevant Office’s legal advisors, having regard to the nature of the court case, the relevant expertise required and the availability of Counsel.

Furthermore, the Offices are approved bodies under the Direct Professional Access (DPA) Scheme of the Bar Council. Occasionally, legal advice is urgently required from a person who is known to have expertise in a particular area and is familiar with the work of the Office. In such cases, Counsel is directly engaged under the DPA arrangements.

Office of Public Works (OPW)

The Office of Public Works uses the services of the Office of the Attorney General and the Office of the Chief State Solicitor (CSSO) for legal advice. I would further advise that all procurement of external counsel by the CSSO, on behalf of the OPW, was handled by that Office, upon the nomination of the Attorney General.

For areas which the CSSO did not have the necessary expertise, OPW entered into a service level agreement with the CSSO in 2005, which negotiates rates with a number of legal firms for the provision of legal advice. Eight panels were formed in areas where such specialised legal expertise was identified as being required, and a panel of solicitors created for each area.

The costs associated with the provision of advice to the OPW by the Office of the Attorney General and the office of the Chief State Solicitor are borne by their respective Votes.

The table below outlines the legal services procured by OPW in the period 2008-to date in 2012.

Advisor20082009201020112012Reason


McCann Fitzgerald  Solrs















175,195.28





14,860.20      







605.00



18,266.56





133,571.89





112,403.18

   





  2,673.00

  

  27,975.37

   


   5,638.60





65,710.66











39,494.82





51,456.88











12,411.02





21,832.57





26,301.99











9,098.62



9,069.33


Decentralisation Programme





National Conference Centre



Engineering Services



Project Advice



Property Maintenance Advice


Beauchamp Solrs




 2,398.22









2,590.61


















4,963.32








3,450.59







16,184.76




Procurement Advice



Personnel Advice



Historic Properties



Property Maintenance Advice



William Fry Solrs


11,885.40








Project & Property Advice


A&L Goodbody


   2,390.96



   4,553.82












18,877.56


Framework Agreement & Project Advice



Project Advice


Arthur Cox





2,879.55 





 9,890.25








10,901.64


Procurement & Property Advice



Engineering Services
Senior & Junior

Counsel
103,722.936,436.00External Counsel


McKeever Rowan Solrs


    4,152.72


Property Advice



L.K. Shields Solrs




  47,364.64




Property Advice


Patrick F O’Reilly & Co Solrs






  32,972.50






12,221.00


Property Advice



Engineering Services


Maxwells







   7,584.22


Property Advice


Clifford Chance LLP






 27,503.44


Property Advice
Mulcahy McDonagh13,721.40Engineering Services
Nael G Bunni6,670.129,829.58Engineering Services
O’Keeffe Moore & Woodstock2,258.50Property Management Advice
Simon J Kelly Ltd1,283.21Property Maintenance Advice
J F Goold & Co1,078.50National Monuments Advice
Kieran T Flynn1,109.52Ministers Office Advice

State Laboratory

YearNames Fees paidNature of the workIf Advertised
2008N/ANILN/AN/A
2009N/ANILN/AN/A
2010Kieran Fleck SC€1000Legal Advice was sought by the State Claims Agency on behalf of the State Laboratory in relation to a claim for compensation as a consequence of incorrect test results being issued.N/A
2011N/ANILN/AN/A
2012N/ANILN/AN/A

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.