Written answers

Thursday, 5 November 2009

10:00 am

Photo of Joan BurtonJoan Burton (Dublin West, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context

Question 63: To ask the Minister for Finance the number of recipients of each of the personal tax credits; the PAYE tax credit for the years 2007, 2008, 2009; the number of recipients of each of these tax credits in the pay brackets, less than €10,000, less than €20,000, less than €30,000, less than the average industrial wage, less than €40,000, less than €50,000, less than €60,000, less than €70,000, less than €80,000, less than €90,000, less than €100,000, over €100,000; the extra revenue which would be generated for the Exchequer by limiting each of the personal tax credits and the PAYE credit respectively to those in each of the pay brackets set out above. [39714/09]

Photo of Brian Lenihan JnrBrian Lenihan Jnr (Dublin West, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I am informed by the Revenue Commissioners that the relevant information available relates to numbers of claimants for the personal and PAYE credits, excluding claimants for lone parents and the widowed persons top up, in the specified income ranges which are set out in the table below.

Claimants for the lone parents and the widowed persons top up credits are included in the table numbers within the numbers shown for the appropriate personal status.

Numbers of claimants for income tax credits
200720082009
Range of Gross IncomePersonal*PAYEPersonal*PAYEPersonal*PAYE
0 - 10,000Single415,445396,240407,479384,476388,234360,794
Married51,18443,70650,97242,10850,26739,612
Widowed5,5154,6675,0664,0215,4154,109
Range Total472,144444,613463,517430,606443,916404,515
10,001 - 20,000Single360,567333,380350,244320,372335,085302,632
Married73,60660,55672,54656,03175,05854,311
Widowed30,71629,03030,29228,11529,31626,397
Range Total464,891422,966453,081404,517439,459383,340
20,001 - 30,000Single326,631305,290321,208300,210298,580278,204
Married112,69092,856111,06988,465108,84283,697
Widowed18,38415,66418,91115,96017,28614,484
Range Total457,706413,811451,188404,635424,709376,386
30,001 - A I W**Single67,89463,193106,70199,55882,58577,072
Married30,76825,04448,70039,14339,28930,646
Widowed3,3292,6765,0954,2283,9593,260
Range Total101,99090,913160,496142,929125,833110,978
A I W** - 40,000Single143,815132,973106,22598,925110,275103,023
Married82,30067,76261,18849,65166,01652,773
Widowed6,6635,3854,8633,9795,1014,160
Range Total232,777206,119172,277152,554181,391159,956
40,001 - 50,000Single114,212105,113118,386110,429103,89497,230
Married103,43585,134100,45382,31594,59076,388
Widowed5,9684,7176,0724,9205,3724,360
Range Total223,614194,964224,911197,664203,856177,978
50,001 - 60,000Single57,49952,12260,42855,72652,22648,271
Married86,25670,34284,15868,42277,61662,923
Widowed3,2782,4423,2922,5652,8992,243
Range Total147,034124,906147,878126,713132,741113,437
60,001 - 70,000Single30,39026,89931,80228,79827,42624,853
Married71,84957,21468,90655,86063,63951,168
Widowed1,9501,3531,9751,4391,7181,263
Range Total104,18985,467102,68486,09792,78477,285
70,001 - 80,000Single17,11714,76717,79815,72815,16213,598
Married54,79643,58754,69743,64148,21939,061
Widowed1,2358031,2198511,049747
Range Total73,14859,15773,71460,22164,43053,404
80,001 -90,000Single9,9358,22010,5699,2018,9077,714
Married40,43831,67940,17632,23135,38028,509
Widowed846529846571724497
Range Total51,21840,42751,59042,00245,01236,718
90,001 - 100,000Single5,6724,5355,9624,9845,0284,203
Married29,73122,91329,37023,25725,75920,592
Widowed535311533342448287
Range Total35,93827,75935,86528,58331,23525,082
Over 100,000Single15,93210,10316,11310,95713,7329,350
Married106,62167,448106,30070,52292,28861,070
Widowed1,9056621,7847231,512620
Range Total124,45878,214124,19782,202107,53271,040
TotalsSingle1,565,1091,452,8351,552,9131,439,3651,441,1351,326,944
Married843,675668,241828,535651,644776,963600,748
Widowed80,32468,24079,95167,71574,80262,426
Overall Total 2,489,1082,189,3162,461,3992,158,7232,292,8991,990,118
* "Personal" excludes lone parent and widowed persons top up
** Average Industrial Wage (AIW) :2007 €32,730
2008 €34,431
2009 €33,700 (estimate)

2007 TM PERSCREDITS

2007
All Exempt CasesAll Taxpayers
Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)
NumberAmountNumberAmount
10,000 or lessSingle1,902,875,577413,7740Single15,785,4061,671178,936
Married235,312,98851,1840
Widowed33,141,9105,515010,000 or less
Range Total2,171,330,475470,4730Range Total15,785,4061,671178,936
10,001 - 20,000Single3,995,491,817280,334010,001 - 20,000Single1,438,089,42180,23332,018,605
Married1,117,654,40071,9860 Married30,815,0571,620329,217
Widowed446,495,13730,3830 Widowed5,594,468333216,896
Range Total5,559,641,355382,7040 Range Total1,474,498,94682,18732,564,718
20,001 - 30,000Single711,798,84930,391020,001 - 30,000Single7,370,934,523296,240393,676,087
Married2,130,240,54086,7370 Married691,326,71125,95320,102,152
Widowed128,828,2885,7550 Widowed320,695,36812,62911,267,335
Range Total2,970,867,676122,8840 Range Total8,382,956,602334,822425,045,574
30,001 - 32,730Single15,125,425484030,001 - 32,730Single2,112,036,95967,410165,644,970
Married457,058,73814,5820 Married507,959,45516,18617,775,221
Widowed4,741,7981520 Widowed99,463,8263,1776,174,211
Range Total476,925,96115,2170 Range Total2,719,460,24186,773189,594,403
32,731 - 40,000Single26,097,914724032,731 - 40,000Single5,171,870,462143,091538,015,558
Married1,016,387,04928,3970 Married1,976,420,65553,90386,819,932
Widowed10,119,2872810 Widowed230,575,6306,38219,840,796
Range Total1,052,604,24929,4020 Range Total7,378,866,747203,375644,676,286
40,001 - 50,000Single15,897,736359040,001 - 50,000Single5,059,113,473113,853788,597,625
Married222,922,1005,2190 Married4,417,042,62098,216275,848,503
Widowed8,233,7341860 Widowed257,140,1365,78235,128,295
Range Total247,053,5705,7640 Range Total9,733,296,229217,8501,099,574,423
50,001 - 60,000Single8,966,262163050,001 - 60,000Single3,122,143,01357,336623,960,832
Married51,968,8819580 Married4,678,562,46585,298461,751,654
Widowed4,253,248780 Widowed174,408,1213,20031,475,437
Range Total65,188,3901,2000 Range Total7,975,113,600145,8341,117,187,922
60,001 - 70,000Single7,164,276110060,001 - 70,000Single1,952,875,92630,280448,508,330
Married29,914,5054630 Married4,630,714,55571,386579,967,425
Widowed2,711,667420 Widowed123,282,6701,90825,945,615
Range Total39,790,4496150 Range Total6,706,873,151103,5741,054,421,370
70,001 - 80,000Single7,052,42894070,001 - 80,000Single1,269,949,07617,023319,130,859
Married31,280,1454170 Married4,064,848,17854,379612,735,919
Widowed1,409,266190 Widowed90,888,3511,21621,061,042
Range Total39,741,8395300 Range Total5,425,685,60572,618952,927,819
80,001 - 90,000Single6,760,10780080,001 - 90,000Single832,675,8759,855221,931,663
Married24,135,0512850 Married3,402,658,66740,153591,848,813
Widowed969,004110 Widowed70,627,87283517,675,197
Range Total31,864,1623760 Range Total4,305,962,41450,842831,455,674
90,001 - 100,000Single4,192,82444090,001 - 100,000Single532,550,2275,628148,028,523
Married25,825,4842720 Married2,791,381,10629,459538,480,482
Widowed835,96590 Widowed49,744,06252613,108,581
Range Total30,854,2723250 Range Total3,373,675,39435,613699,617,586
Over 100,000Single68,514,2292500Over 100,000Single2,978,246,06515,682948,669,829
Married491,062,7891,9690 Married20,513,907,106104,6525,686,398,525
Widowed11,168,405530 Widowed377,657,9541,852119,298,553
Range Total570,745,4242,2720 Range Total23,869,811,125122,1866,754,366,907
TotalsSingle6,769,937,444726,8080TotalsSingle31,856,270,427838,3014,628,361,818
Married5,833,762,669262,4690 Married47,705,636,575581,2068,872,057,842
Widowed652,907,70942,4850 Widowed1,800,078,45837,839301,191,958
Overall Total13,256,607,8221,031,7620Overall Total 81,361,985,4601,457,34613,801,611,619

2007 PAYE CREDIT

2007
All Exempt CasesAll Taxpayers
Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)Range of Gross Income and Personal Status Gross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)
NumberAmount NumberAmount
10,000 or lessSingle1,812,308,602396,2400
Married196,763,12443,7060
Widowed28,315,4324,6670
Range Total2,037,387,159444,6130
10,001 - 20,000Single3,896,178,037273,4110Single1,131,187,05959,96913,055,137
Married946,575,56260,5560
Widowed426,476,53729,030010,001 - 20,000
Range Total5,269,230,135362,9970 Range Total1,131,187,05959,96913,055,137
20,001 - 30,000Single677,862,46828,948020,001 - 30,000Single6,878,379,692276,342347,763,564
Married2,013,024,19481,9250 Married310,155,66010,9313,389,177
Widowed121,052,1055,4330 Widowed260,610,15610,2317,032,617
Range Total2,811,938,767116,3060 Range Total7,449,145,508297,505358,185,358
30,001 - 32,730Single10,364,538332030,001 - 32,730Single1,969,373,71062,861149,514,744
Married426,289,87213,5990 Married359,147,54411,4458,188,318
Widowed3,646,2481170 Widowed80,116,2862,5594,218,608
Range Total440,300,65714,0480 Range Total2,408,637,53976,865161,921,670
32,731 - 40,000Single17,570,545488032,731 - 40,000Single4,789,329,388132,485489,695,708
Married925,465,93425,9000 Married1,539,134,86441,86253,080,991
Widowed7,624,2022130 Widowed186,820,2655,17214,716,506
Range Total950,660,68126,6000 Range Total6,515,284,517179,519557,493,206
40,001 - 50,000Single7,074,701161040,001 - 50,000Single4,662,276,175104,952727,916,050
Married157,891,1083,7330 Married3,660,900,58681,401208,223,160
Widowed4,931,1321130 Widowed204,634,0654,60427,099,255
Range Total169,896,9404,0070 Range Total8,527,810,825190,957963,238,466
50,001 - 60,000Single3,041,44555050,001 - 60,000Single2,834,322,99052,067572,093,664
Married22,142,9054140 Married3,834,646,42369,928367,022,213
Widowed2,411,190450 Widowed130,474,4902,39723,399,902
Range Total27,595,5405140 Range Total6,799,443,903124,392962,515,779
60,001 - 70,000Single2,239,61834060,001 - 70,000Single1,731,935,86526,865404,119,371
Married9,983,8971540 Married3,698,970,80957,060457,269,734
Widowed1,533,616240 Widowed85,821,1921,32918,143,219
Range Total13,757,1302130 Range Total5,516,727,86685,254879,532,323
70,001 - 80,000Single1,725,00923070,001 - 80,000Single1,099,780,87014,744281,754,356
Married8,762,6771170 Married3,249,163,05543,470491,261,624
Widowed311,13140 Widowed59,691,19679914,085,524
Range Total10,798,8161440 Range Total4,408,635,12159,013787,101,504
80,001 - 90,000Single1,794,64621080,001 - 90,000Single692,449,7528,199188,901,775
Married9,131,3961070 Married2,674,559,92531,572469,612,674
Widowed173,08320 Widowed44,531,87552711,296,740
Range Total11,099,1251300 Range Total3,411,541,55240,297669,811,189
90,001 - 100,000Single490,4255090,001 - 100,000Single428,404,6494,530122,388,508
Married9,008,936950 Married2,161,715,48622,818423,342,607
Widowed198,03220 Widowed29,299,6843097,896,590
Range Total9,697,3931020 Range Total2,619,419,81927,657553,627,705
Over 100,000Single6,115,857430Over 100,000Single1,564,138,61310,060512,080,830
Married75,642,3384700 Married10,506,844,82966,9782,858,168,117
Widowed1,497,692110 Widowed100,652,36165131,460,239
Range Total83,255,8875240 Range Total12,171,635,80377,6903,401,709,185
TotalsSingle6,436,765,889699,7620TotalsSingle27,781,578,762753,0733,809,283,706
Married4,800,681,942230,7750 Married31,995,239,179437,4665,339,558,617
Widowed598,170,39939,6610 Widowed1,182,651,57128,579159,349,201
Overall Total11,835,618,231970,1980Overall Total 60,959,469,5121,219,1189,308,191,524

2008 TM PER CREDITS

All Exempt CasesAll Taxpayers
Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)
NumberAmountNumberAmount
0-10,000Single1,880,280,048406,4760Single9,640,3161,00379,848
Married235,572,57450,9720
Widowed28,788,8305,06600-10,000
Range Total2,144,641,453462,5140Range Total9,640,3161,00379,848
10,001-20,000Single4,251,462,626292,914010,001-20,000Single1,021,938,56257,33022,974,388
Married1,109,649,00771,4880 Married20,349,3691,058138,923
Widowed442,451,26129,9120 Widowed6,644,269380304,071
Range Total5,803,562,894394,3130 Range Total1,048,932,20058,76823,417,382
20,001-30,000Single908,490,46238,596020,001-30,000Single7,044,340,517282,612340,717,746
Married2,216,199,18689,8350 Married562,802,11521,23415,284,456
Widowed192,044,4638,5440 Widowed269,502,18210,3678,322,840
Range Total3,316,734,111136,9750 Range Total7,876,644,815314,213364,325,042
30,001-34,431Single36,350,3461,143030,001-34,431Single3,390,998,380105,558257,747,279
Married809,969,30625,2130 Married758,110,71223,48725,150,101
Widowed9,594,9473010 Widowed154,079,5404,7948,754,247
Range Total855,914,59926,6570 Range Total4,303,188,632133,839291,651,628
34,432-40,000Single27,238,319736034,432-40,000Single3,910,104,804105,489386,497,885
Married893,914,58524,2160 Married1,382,915,55136,97258,814,213
Widowed9,539,9972590 Widowed170,688,8794,60413,530,291
Range Total930,692,90225,2110 Range Total5,463,709,234147,066458,842,389
40,001-50,000Single26,032,899594040,001-50,000Single5,231,631,640117,792758,916,945
Married471,415,58911,0010 Married4,035,074,57689,452225,013,357
Widowed10,539,6662390 Widowed259,985,0645,83332,375,542
Range Total507,988,15411,8340 Range Total9,526,691,280213,0771,016,305,843
50,001-60,000Single13,478,498246050,001-60,000Single3,276,152,61360,182625,905,259
Married98,709,3291,8190 Married4,515,449,40882,339408,312,502
Widowed5,209,423960 Widowed174,247,9993,19629,526,087
Range Total117,397,2502,1610 Range Total7,965,850,020145,7171,063,743,848
60,001-70,000Single11,013,912170060,001-70,000Single2,039,876,96331,632453,709,359
Married55,411,6448550 Married4,413,058,68368,051517,204,514
Widowed3,823,905590 Widowed123,733,5191,91625,065,999
Range Total70,249,4611,0840 Range Total6,576,669,165101,600995,979,872
70,001-80,000Single10,166,800137070,001-80,000Single1,316,506,83917,661322,994,193
Married38,891,9215210 Married4,047,154,94454,176570,544,840
Widowed1,933,739260 Widowed89,041,1381,19319,866,222
Range Total50,992,4596840 Range Total5,452,702,92173,030913,405,254
80,001-90,000Single6,207,56673080,001-90,000Single886,474,97510,496232,240,893
Married36,923,8274350 Married3,367,775,56339,741555,634,603
Widowed1,047,055120 Widowed70,605,19183417,342,990
Range Total44,178,4485200 Range Total4,324,855,72951,070805,218,486
90,001-100,000Single5,929,32563090,001-100,000Single557,679,5325,899152,513,269
Married30,931,9973250 Married2,752,388,43229,045507,925,372
Widowed965,120100 Widowed49,603,99852312,730,415
Range Total37,826,4423980 Range Total3,359,671,96335,467673,169,056
over 100,000Single83,205,4213100over 100,000Single2,896,955,78915,803910,204,301
Married631,123,6532,4720 Married19,747,278,169103,8285,326,878,573
Widowed13,097,732700 Widowed339,514,7241,714104,649,029
Range Total727,426,8062,8520 Range Total22,983,748,683121,3456,341,731,903
TotalsSingle7,259,856,223741,4570TotalsSingle31,582,300,930811,4564,464,501,366
Married6,628,712,618279,1520 Married45,602,357,523549,3838,210,901,453
Widowed719,036,13944,5940 Widowed1,707,646,50435,357272,467,732
Overall Total14,607,604,9801,065,2030Overall Total 78,892,304,9561,396,19612,947,870,551

2008 PAYE CREDIT

exempt2008
PAYE (Non Proprietor/Directors)All Taxpayers
Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)Range of Gross Income and Personal StatusGross Income (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Income or Agregated case Income)IncomeTax&DIRT (M+2E cases: Either summed Major+Minor Tax or Agregated case Tax)
NumberAmountNumberAmount
0-10,000Single1,760,215,134384,4760
Married188,714,99442,1080
Widowed22,707,1664,0210
Range Total1,971,637,294430,6060
10,001-20,000Single4,101,751,256282,4190Single727,715,53837,9536,089,472
Married873,748,17256,0310
Widowed415,312,36628,115010,001-20,000
Range Total5,390,811,794366,5640Range Total727,715,53837,9536,089,472
20,001-30,000Single847,403,30835,987020,001-30,000Single6,588,452,030264,223300,480,557
Married2,024,176,66281,9120Married188,843,9536,5531,456,445
Widowed172,660,2937,6880Widowed216,325,0468,2725,103,691
Range Total3,044,240,262125,5860Range Total6,993,621,029279,049307,040,693
30,001-34,431Single24,470,064773030,001-34,431Single3,173,150,54998,785234,218,264
Married732,299,68922,8030 Married527,970,39916,34011,577,566
Widowed6,875,7682160 Widowed128,895,6374,0126,372,706
Range Total763,645,52023,7920 Range Total3,830,016,585119,137252,168,537
34,432-40,000Single15,709,774425034,432-40,000Single3,652,176,20498,500355,906,387
Married791,631,18721,4620 Married1,056,439,11528,18935,198,483
Widowed6,649,4111810 Widowed140,778,2613,79810,304,112
Range Total813,990,37122,0670 Range Total4,849,393,580130,487401,408,982
40,001-50,000Single11,245,169259040,001-50,000Single4,892,114,259110,170711,468,830
Married351,846,6328,2770 Married3,341,221,71974,038167,113,733
Widowed6,308,5191440 Widowed212,759,9424,77625,781,121
Range Total369,400,3208,6800 Range Total8,446,095,920188,984904,363,685
50,001-60,000Single4,128,09076050,001-60,000Single3,028,808,50855,650584,710,240
Married39,087,4207240 Married3,712,311,50567,698326,281,125
Widowed3,098,347570 Widowed136,607,8712,50823,255,005
Range Total46,313,8568560 Range Total6,877,727,884125,857934,246,370
60,001-70,000Single2,255,06035060,001-70,000Single1,854,472,49028,763418,623,367
Married12,933,1721990 Married3,608,386,67155,661419,837,205
Widowed1,933,909300 Widowed91,007,4201,40918,631,909
Range Total17,122,1402640 Range Total5,553,866,58185,833857,092,481
70,001-80,000Single2,037,75227070,001-80,000Single1,170,132,56615,701292,106,270
Married9,915,2671330 Married3,251,397,74643,508461,700,018
Widowed621,85180 Widowed62,940,00184314,301,756
Range Total12,574,8691690 Range Total4,484,470,31360,052768,108,044
80,001-90,000Single1,524,26518080,001-90,000Single775,240,6439,183207,048,374
Married9,367,8921100 Married2,721,621,05532,121455,875,140
Widowed263,17830 Widowed48,069,53356811,957,513
Range Total11,155,3341310 Range Total3,544,931,23141,871674,881,027
90,001-100,000Single1,417,00815090,001-100,000Single469,538,9864,969131,763,838
Married9,103,515960 Married2,194,484,25023,161411,894,889
Widowed195,32920 Widowed32,253,5243408,456,507
Range Total10,715,8521130 Range Total2,696,276,76028,470552,115,234
over 100,000Single6,473,738440over 100,000Single1,683,916,99910,913544,507,244
Married85,324,5895220 Married10,974,725,73470,0002,922,837,165
Widowed1,505,963110 Widowed109,203,83571233,556,289
Range Total93,304,2905770 Range Total12,767,846,56981,6253,500,900,697
TotalsSingle6,778,630,616704,5550TotalsSingle28,015,718,772734,8103,786,922,844
Married5,128,149,190234,3750 Married31,577,402,148417,2695,213,771,771
Widowed638,132,09740,4760 Widowed1,178,841,07027,239157,720,608
Overall Total12,544,911,903979,4050Overall Total 60,771,961,9911,179,3189,158,415,223

Figures to indicate the breakdown over the income ranges of the numbers of claimants for lone parents and the widowed persons top up credits, and estimates of the yield to the Exchequer from limiting each of the personal tax credits and the PAYE credit respectively to those in each of the specified income ranges, are not readily available and could not be provided without undertaking an extensive development of the Revenue tax forecasting model.

The figures for 2007 are based on incomes data derived from income tax returns held on Revenue records and have been grossed-up to an overall expected level to adjust for incompleteness in the numbers of returns on record at the time the data were extracted for analytical purposes. For the years 2008 and 2009, the figures are estimates from the Revenue tax forecasting model using actual data for the year 2007, adjusted as necessary for income and employment growth for the years in question.

It should be noted that a married couple who has elected or has been deemed to have elected for joint assessment is counted as one tax unit.

Photo of Richard BrutonRichard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context

Question 64: To ask the Minister for Finance his views on allowing the construction of wind turbines on farms to be subject to the VAT reclamation scheme for farmers; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [39740/09]

Photo of Brian Lenihan JnrBrian Lenihan Jnr (Dublin West, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I am advised by the Revenue Commissioners that flat-rate farmers are not in the normal course entitled to credit for, or repayment of, VAT incurred by them on business inputs. The Value-Added Tax (Refund of Tax) (No 25) Order, 1993 provides for refunds to flat-rate farmers for VAT borne on the "construction, extension, alteration or reconstruction of any building or structure which is designed for use solely or mainly for the purposes of a farming business". However, while the installation of a wind turbine may be the construction of a structure, such a structure is not "designed for use solely or mainly for the purposes of a farming business". It is designed rather to generate electricity for wherever required. Consequently, the installation of wind turbines does not come within the scope of the refund order.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.