Written answers
Wednesday, 14 October 2009
Department of Defence
Ministerial Travel
Lucinda Creighton (Dublin South East, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context
Question 261: To ask the Minister for Defence if Air Corps helicopters are used for ministerial transport; the circumstances under which such travel is approved; the person by whom it is approved; the guidelines or policies that regulate such use; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [36352/09]
Lucinda Creighton (Dublin South East, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context
Question 262: To ask the Minister for Defence the number of times in the past five years that Air Corps helicopters have been used for ministerial or related transport; the name of the Minister in each case; the reason for the use in each case; the cost to the taxpayer of each such use; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [36357/09]
Willie O'Dea (Limerick East, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context
I propose to take Questions Nos. 261 and 262 together.
The Air Corps helicopter fleet comprises two light utility EC135 helicopters and six utility AW139 helicopters. The Dauphin helicopters were withdrawn from Air Corps service in January 2006, and the Alouette fleet was withdrawn in September 2007. The helicopters are operated by the Air Corps in a general purpose military operational and training role. Primary taskings include security, aid to the civil power, military exercises, infantry interoperability training and limited troop transport. They are also used to perform air ambulance, non-maritime search and rescue, aid to the civil authorities, community support and ministerial and VIP air transport tasks.
Helicopters are used from time to time for ministerial air transport in situations where, for operational reasons, fixed wing aircraft may not be available, the point of destination may not be close to an airport and in circumstances where there is a requirement for greater flexibility than can be delivered by fixed wing aircraft. In 2008, ministerial transport represented approximately 5% of total helicopter flying hours.
Approval for the use of Air Corps helicopters for ministerial transport is a matter for the Taoiseach, providing the helicopters are available and have not been otherwise tasked in their military role. Guidelines regarding the use of the Ministerial Air Transport Service are set out in the Cabinet Handbook. The guidelines specify that requests for the use of the service should be made to the Taoiseach in respect of every mission, giving details of the justifying need, the destination, route, timings, passenger details and purpose of travel.
Details regarding the number of times Air Corps helicopters have been used for ministerial or related transport in the past five years are listed in the following tabular statements, including the date of each trip, the helicopter type tasked, the ministerial time on board and the requesting Minister. Each trip was in the conduct of official engagements and had the prior approval of the Taoiseach.
I have availed of Air Corps helicopters for transport in connection with my ministerial duties, most recently in November 2008. With regard to the cost, the Department of Defence follows the normal practice in the aviation business of costing aircraft by reference to the cost per flying hour under either of two headings: the direct cost, i.e. the costs which are additional to those associated with having the aircraft and which only arise when the aircraft is flown including maintenance, fuel and support services; and the total cost, i.e. the direct cost plus the costs associated with having the aircraft, i.e. depreciation and personnel costs.
The Deputy should note that the costs associated with having the aircraft, which are costs arising for having aircraft available for their primary taskings in their military operational and training roles, arise regardless of whether or not the aircraft is tasked with ministerial transport. The current rates per hour used to establish these costs in relation to helicopters are also set out in the following tabular statements. The costs are an approximation to actual costs.
Ministerial use of Air Corps helicopters
Date | Aircraft | Ministerial Time on Board (minutes) | Minister |
18 Feb 05 | Dauphin | 85 | Taoiseach |
15 Apr 05 | Dauphin | 140 | Tánaiste (Health and Children) |
22 Apr 05 | Dauphin | 95 | Taoiseach |
28 Apr 05 | Dauphin | 110 | Justice |
21 Jun 05 | Dauphin | 95 | Arts, Sports and Tourism |
24 Jun 05 | Dauphin | 40 | Tánaiste (Health and Children) |
27 Jun 05 | Dauphin | 50 | Taoiseach |
21 Jul 05 | Dauphin | 195 | Communications, Marine and Natural Resources |
04 Aug 05 | Dauphin | 215 | Communications, Marine and Natural Resources |
08 Sep 05 | Alouette | 60 | Taoiseach |
27 Sep 05 | Dauphin | 20 | Taoiseach |
18 Nov 05 | Dauphin | 50 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
16 Dec 05 | Dauphin | 80 | Defence |
26 Jan 06 | EC 135 | 90 | Justice, Equality Law Reform |
23 Feb 06 | Alouette | 110 | Arts, Sports and Tourism |
15 Mar 06 | EC 135 | 100 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
06 Apr 06 | EC 135 | 105 | Taoiseach |
07 Apr 06 | EC 135 | 60 | Taoiseach |
25 Apr 06 | EC 135 | 100 | Defence |
05 May 06 | EC 135 | 195 | Education and Science/Minister of State Transport |
18 May 06 | EC 135 | 120 | Environment, Heritage and Local Government |
08 Jun 06 | EC 135 | 150 | Social and Family Affairs |
21 Jun 06 | EC 135 | 160 | Education and Science/Minister of State Transport |
23 Jun 06 | EC 135 | 65 | Taoiseach |
28 Jun 06 | Alouette | 160 | Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs |
07 Jul 06 | EC 135 | 45 | Taoiseach |
11 Jul 06 | Alouette | 210 | Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs |
30 Jul 06 | EC 135 | 120 | Defence |
31 Jul 06 | EC 135 | 60 | Taoiseach |
15 Aug 06 | EC 135 | 140 | Communications, Marine and Natural Resources |
06 Sep 06 | EC 135 | 165 | Defence |
08 Sep 06 | EC 135 | 30 | Taoiseach |
29 Sep 06 | EC 135 | 50 | Taoiseach |
02 Oct 06 | Alouette | 45 | Taoiseach |
08 Oct 06 | Alouette | 120 | Taoiseach |
16 Oct 06 | EC 135 | 100 | Taoiseach |
27 Oct 06 | EC 135 | 50 | Taoiseach |
09 Nov 06 | EC 135 | 50 | Taoiseach |
10 Nov 06 | EC 135 | 50 | Taoiseach |
11 Dec 06 | Alouette | 25 | Tánaiste (Justice, Equality and Law Reform) |
15 Dec 06 | EC 135 | 80 | Tánaiste (Justice, Equality and Law Reform) |
25 Jan 07 | EC 135 | 110 | Tánaiste (Justice, Equality and Law Reform) |
02 Feb 07 | Alouette | 120 | Tánaiste (Justice, Equality and Law Reform) |
02 Feb 07 | EC 135 | 35 | Taoiseach |
16 Feb 07 | EC 135 | 45 | Taoiseach |
01 Mar 07 | EC 135 | 110 | Environment, Heritage and Local Government/ Agriculture |
30 Mar 07 | EC 135 | 150 | Environment, Heritage and Local Government |
05 Apr 07 | EC 135 | 80 | Arts, Sports and Tourism |
19 Apr 07 | EC 135 | 135 | Health |
23 Apr 07 | EC 135 | 70 | Taoiseach |
26 Apr 07 | EC 135 | 100 | Tánaiste (Justice, Equality and Law Reform) |
27 Apr 07 | EC 135 | 95 | Taoiseach |
16 May 07 | EC 135 | 90 | Transport |
03 Jul 07 | AW 139 | 80 | Agriculture |
04 Jul 07 | AW 139 | 90 | Taoiseach |
09 Jul 07 | AW 139 | 90 | Taoiseach |
17 Jul 07 | AW 139 | 80 | Taoiseach |
06 Sep 07 | EC 135 | 130 | Defence |
13 Sep 07 | AW 139 | 140 | Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs |
25 Sep 07 | AW 139 | 60 | Agriculture |
27 Sep 07 | AW 139 | 80 | Taoiseach |
02 Nov 07 | AW 139 | 100 | Transport |
16 Nov 07 | AW 139 | 80 | Taoiseach |
17 Dec 07 | AW 139 | 60 | Health |
17 Dec 07 | AW 139 | 45 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
31 Jan 08 | EC 135 | 80 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
01 Feb 08 | AW 139 | 90 | Taoiseach |
08 Feb 08 | AW 139 | 40 | Taoiseach |
23 Mar 08 | EC 135 | 100 | Defence |
25 Mar 08 | EC 135 | 60 | Education and Science |
26 Mar 08 | EC 135 | 120 | Education and Science |
04 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 30 | Taoiseach |
11 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 100 | Taoiseach |
11 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 45 | Health and Children |
14 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 50 | Defence |
09 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 55 | Health and Children |
17 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 30 | Agriculture, Fisheries and Food |
18 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 70 | Agriculture, Fisheries and Food |
29 Apr 08 | EC 135 | 20 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
01 May 08 | AW 139 | 115 | Defence |
01 May 08 | AW 139 | 60 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
30 May 08 | AW 139 | 100 | Defence |
29 May 08 | EC 135 | 120 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
30 May 08 | AW 139 | 90 | Health and Children |
10 Jun 08 | EC 135 | 70 | Defence |
19 Jun 08 | EC 135 | 100 | Defence |
15 Aug 08 | AW 139 | 80 | Taoiseach |
26 Aug 08 | AW 139 | 100 | Defence |
05 Sep 08 | EC 135 | 55 | Arts, Sports and Tourism |
10 Sep 08 | EC 135 | 40 | Defence |
12 Sep 08 | EC 135 | 80 | Defence |
13 Sep 08 | AW 139 | 60 | Tánaiste (Enterprise Trade and Employment) |
23 Sep 08 | AW 139 | 45 | Taoiseach |
23 Sep 08 | AW 139 | 45 | Tánaiste (Enterprise, Trade and Employment) |
03 Oct 08 | AW 139 | 85 | Taoiseach |
31 Oct 08 | EC 135 | 100 | Transport |
04 Nov 08 | AW 139 | 70 | Justice |
08 Nov 08 | AW 139 | 100 | Taoiseach/Defence |
30 Nov 08 | EC 135 | 65 | Taoiseach |
05 Dec 08 | AW 139 | 120 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
04 Dec 08 | AW 139 | 60 | Tánaiste (Enterprise, Trade and Employment) |
09 Dec 08 | AW 139 | 100 | Education and Science |
30 Jan 09 | AW 139 | 120 | Justice, Equality and Law Reform |
29 Jan 09 | AW 139 | 45 | Foreign Affairs |
06 Feb 09 | AW 139 | 90 | Transport |
23 Feb 09 | AW 139 | 45 | Transport |
02 Mar 09 | AW 139 | 110 | Arts, Sports and Tourism |
30 Mar 09 | AW 139 | 60 | Tánaiste (Enterprise, Trade and Employment) |
13 Apr 09 | EC 135 | 100 | Education and Science |
14 Apr 09 | AW 139 | 95 | Education and Science |
20 Apr 09 | EC 135 | 110 | Finance |
17 Jul 09 | AW 139 | 205 | Community, Rural and Gaeltacht Affairs |
16 Jul 09 | EC 135 | 120 | Agriculture, Fisheries and Food |
23 Sep 09 | EC 135 | 130 | Tánaiste (Enterprise, Trade and Employment) |
Costs associated with Air Corps helicopters used in the provision of Ministerial Air Transport Service
Aircraft | Average Direct Cost Per Hour € | Average Total Cost Per Hour € |
Alouette | 1,150 | 1,880 |
Dauphin | 1,650 | 3,100 |
EC 135 | 430 | 1,590 |
AW 139 | 1,470 | 3,130 |
No comments