Written answers
Thursday, 18 December 2008
Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform
Court Awards
5:00 pm
Emmet Stagg (Kildare North, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context
Question 27: To ask the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform the amount paid out in compensation or legal costs arising from claims against members of the Gardaí in respect of assault, illegal arrest and other reasons for each year from 2002 to date in 2008; and if he will make a statement on the matter. [46766/08]
Dermot Ahern (Louth, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context
The information requested by the Deputy concerning the amounts paid out in Court awards and out of court settlements in relation to actions taken against members of An Garda Síochána relating to assault, unlawful arrest or other breaches of citizens' rights is set out in the table below.
Actions taken by Civilians against Gardai | |||||
The number of cases settled/or awards made by the Courts are shown in brackets | |||||
Year | Category of payment | Assault | UnlawfulArrest | Other | Overall Total |
2002 | Awards | €1,270(1) | €3,809.21(1) | €56,500(2) | |
Settlements | €166,924.48(6) | €106,835.58(10) | €185,078.82(11) | ||
Costs | €230,769.67 | €148,714.19 | €340,486.45 | ||
Total | €398,964.15 | €259,358.98 | €582,065.27 | €1,240,388.40 | |
2003 | Awards | €11,000(1) | €10,000(2) | €4,870(2) | |
Settlements | €75,000(4) | €303,011(5) | €112,814.84(4) | ||
Costs | €145,561.70 | €71,794.28 | €542,075.73 | ||
Total | €231,561.70 | €384,805.28 | €659,760.57 | €1,276,127.55 | |
2004 | Awards | €15,000(1) | Nil | €3,215.06(1) | |
Settlements | €198,697.48(5) | €73,007(5) | €50,500(3) | ||
Costs | €231,646.62 | €100,019.36 | €266,713.57 | ||
Total | €445,344.10 | €173,026.36 | €320,428.63 | €938,799.09 | |
2005 | Awards | €1,000.00(1) | €2,025,321.00(3) | €85,125.00(2) | |
Settlements | €130,250.00(7) | €1,569,114.00(9) | €58,000(2) | ||
Costs | €137,447.90(10) | €658,508.78(10) | €205,466.85(15) | ||
Total | €268,697.90 | €4,252,943.78 | €348,591.85 | €4,870,233.53 | |
2006 | Awards | €18,076.32(1) | €41,443.80(3) | Nil | |
Settlements | €386,200.00(17) | €622,000(15) | €606,500.00(8) | ||
Costs | €187,797.28(11) | €60,983.61(10) | €28,983.93(3) | ||
Total | €592,073.60 | €724,427.41 | €635,483.93 | €1,951,984.94 | |
2007 (Provisional) | Awards | €97,500.00(2) | Nil | €5,246,047.00(4) | |
Settlements | €238,000.00(8) | €1,297,000.00(10) | €4,451,000.00(34) | ||
Costs | €485,944.95(10) | €1,488,193.20(9) | €1,125,597.19(29) | ||
Total | €821,444.95 | €2,785,193.20 | €10,822,644.19 | €14,429,282.34 | |
2008 (Provisional) to 08/12/08 | Awards | €12,500(1) | €5,500(1) | €12,500(1) | |
Settlements | €505,000(15) | €56,024.34(6) | €273,157.58(18) | ||
Costs | €816,847.70(15) | €650,968.42(14) | €1,943,853.08(27) | ||
Total | €1,334,347.70 | €712,492.76 | €2,229,510.66 | €4,276,351.12 |
No comments