Written answers
Wednesday, 17 December 2008
Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment
Consultancy Contracts
8:00 pm
Leo Varadkar (Dublin West, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context
Question 161: To ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment the external consultants hired by her Department in 2007 and 2008; the work carried out and the cost of such work in each case; the reason it was not possible to carry out such work internally within her Department or an agency of her Department in each case; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [46782/08]
Mary Coughlan (Donegal South West, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context
The information requested by the Deputy insofar as my Department is concerned is set out in the tabular statement below.
The figures provided relate to consultancies as defined in the Department of Finance December 2006 "Guidelines for the Engagement of Consultants and Other External Support by the Civil Service".
My Department continues to seek greater efficiencies, effectiveness and value for money in the administration of its financial resources. My Department's requirements for consultancy only arise where appropriate skills, knowledge or expertise are not available within the Department, or where a particular need arises that cannot be addressed within the resources available. When it becomes necessary to engage consultants, Government tendering procedures are followed, which ensures that contracts are awarded to the most suitable and cost effective tenderer. Where possible, my Department utilises the expertise available in other Government Departments and Offices, such as obtaining legal advice from the Chief State Solicitors Office in preference to engaging external consultants.
A feature of the Department's procedures for approving funding for consultancies under the Consultancy Subhead (Subhead A07) or, indeed, the Research Subhead (Subhead U), is that before any funding is approved by the Management Board of my Department, the Line Section requesting such funding must make a strong business case, outlining the anticipated benefits, the value-added nature of the consultancy, and the argument for engaging outside consultants in preference to undertaking the work using the internal resources of the Section.
I would point out to the Deputy that, even on occasions where consultants are engaged, significant skills transfers occur. Additionally, training and development resources are allocated to encourage participation in appropriate third level and postgraduate courses, designed to meet the business goals of the Department. During the period in question (i.e. 2007 & 2008), thirty-one staff participated in courses designed to enhance their competencies in the areas of policy analysis, economic policy studies and project management. This training will contribute towards reducing dependency on consultants in future years. Furthermore, a number of officers in my Department have undertaken training courses provided through the Department of Finance's Expenditure Reviewers Network, to provide them with the appropriate skills sets and techniques to undertake work which may otherwise have needed to be undertaken by external consultants. Although the input of consultants is still sometimes required in some expenditure reviews, the level of input and the associated expenditure is considerably reduced.
In light of the need to pursue greater efficiencies and value for money, my Department will continue to endeavour to ensure that any funding provided for consultancies is necessary, and results in the optimal use of the Department's financial and human resources.
2007 | ||
Name of Consultants | Purpose | Cost |
€ | ||
Leo Burnett | Advertising increase in National Minimum Wage | 50,163 |
Corporate Risk Strategies Ltd (CRS) | Prepare a Health and Safety report on each of the Department's buildings together with the appropriate Safety Statements. | 24,200 |
ESRI | National Survey on Workplace Bullying | 84,232 |
Tom Walsh | To provide advice to the Department on the development of occupational health and safety policy and legislation | 81,493 |
Arup Consulting Engineers | To support the Department in its review of Review of Dangerous Substances legislation | 28,814 |
Indecon Economic Consultants | To prepare a report on the EU Emissions Trading Scheme. | 30,000 |
Indecon Consultants | Prepare a Report — Value for Money Review of Science Foundation Ireland (SFI) | 111,244 |
The Media Group | To devise, implement and manage a national promotion and advertising campaign across a range of media for the ICT Audits Programme for Small Business in Ireland | 135,000 |
Noel J. Travers BL | Drafted a legal instrument. | 8,440 |
RITS | To prepare a series of reports re IT Security | 118,928 |
Version 1 | To prepare a report on the Insolvency Payments Section BPR (Business Process Re-engineering) | 7,187 |
Work Research Co-operative Social & Economic Consultants | Acquired Disability and Job retention report | 26,632 |
Goodbody Economic Consultants | Review of Wage SubsidyScheme | 23,595 |
Farrell Grant Sparks | Ex-ante evaluation of the Human Capital Investment OP 2007-2013 | 66,671 |
Indecon Economic Consultants | Study of efficiency and Effectiveness ofVocational Training Services | 5,087 |
DHR Communications | Dissemination of information etc, on the SEF co-funded "EQUAL" Community Initiative (CI) | 28,305 |
Tom Ferris | To carry out six case studies investigating the administrative burdens arising due to regulation and to prepare a report | 2,997 |
Dan Flinter | To facilitate two business workshops, examining the burdens of regulation on business, and make recommendations | 8,643 |
2007 — continued | ||
Name of Consultants | Purpose | Cost |
€ | ||
Nathan Reilly | Review of consumer legislation | 7,053 |
Keating and Associates | Communications Strategy for the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement (ODCE) | 32,670 |
Millward Brown IMS | Market Research for ODCE | 44,790 |
Cyril O'Neill | Legal Costs Assessment for ODCE | 13,273 |
Connolly Lowe | Legal Costs Assessment for ODCE | 2,588 |
Carr Communications | Effective communications with Companies Registration Office (CRO) clients | 45,372 |
Millward Browne | Carry out market research for the CRO | 27,062 |
Grant Thornton | Consultancy on Public Procurement and Business Solutions | 57,521 |
O' Mara, Geragthy, Mc Court | Provision of legal services and advices | 35,086 |
Q4 | Public relations services/advice | 18,150 |
Owens DDB | Advice on advertising and placing of same in various media | 128,566 |
DKM Economic Consultants | Research on multi-unit developments | 1,210 |
RPS Consultants | Research on energy policy | 9,575 |
Vision Consulting Ltd | Consultants were engaged to carry out a review of the operation of the National Employment Rights Authority (NERA) Information Services and to make recommendations on the structures, processes and systems that should operate in the Unit in order to achieve the highest possible standard of excellence in terms of meeting customer needs. | 95,711 |
Keating and Associates | To provide NERA with PR Consultancy Services | 46,462 |
Mason Hayes & Curran | NERA legal costs | 16,611 |
Ellard Browne | NERA Management Information Framework work | 7,550 |
PriceWaterhouseCoopers | NERA Management Consultancy | 30,189 |
Vision Consulting | NERA Communictions Strategy | 186,334 |
Cawley Nea Ltd | NERA Advertising Media | 181,335 |
Design Tactics | NERA Advertising Media | 6,285 |
McCann Fitzgerald | Provision of legal advice under the Industrial and Provident Societies Acts for the CRO | 18,184 |
Millward Browne | Market Research for CRO | 42,144 |
2007 — continued | ||
Name of Consultants | Purpose | Cost |
€ | ||
DNM Technology | VMWare advice on the use of software to run virtual PCs | 4,840 |
S.F.Hughes & Co | Legal Services/advice | 938 |
James W. Houlihan | Legal Services/advice | 1,210 |
James Dwyer | Legal Services/advice | 1,815 |
John Hennessy BL | Legal advice | 126,324 |
Matthias Kelly QC | Legal advice | 162,742 |
Form Creative Ltd | Advertising campaign for Work Life Balance Day 2007 | 52,398 |
Form Creative Ltd | Advertising for Panel of Consultants 2007 | 8,673 |
Helm Corporation Ltd | Consultancy Service Oracle Review –Finance Unit | 8,146 |
European Commission | Engagement of consultants to carry out National Evaluation of the impact of the European Employment Strategy in Ireland | 4,973 |
Mazars | Engagement of a consultant to undertake 2 audits from the Department's 2006 Audit Plan (Finance Unit and Personnel Unit) (continued from 2006) | 10,482 |
2008 | ||
Name of Consultants | Purpose | Cost |
€ | ||
DHR Communications | Dissemination of information on the ESF co-funded "EQUAL" Community Initiative (CI) | 9,547 |
Social and Market Research | Conduct an "EQUAL" Survey | 23,850 |
Farrell Grant Sparks | Ex-ante evaluation of the Human Capital Investment Operational Programme 2007-2013 | 7,025 |
Work Research Co-operative WRC | Job Retention and return to work | 26,632 |
Keating Consulting Ltd | NERA PR | 63,189 |
Ellard Browne Ltd | NERA Advertising | 605 |
Cawley Nea Ltd | NERA Advertising | 27,410 |
2008 — continued | ||
Name of Consultants | Purpose | Cost |
€ | ||
Tom Walsh | To provide advice to the Department on the development of occupational health and safety policy and legislation | 63,422 |
Arup Consulting Engineers | To support the Department in its review of Review of Dangerous Substances legislation | 35,930 |
Kilroy Solicitors | Legal Advice | 16,263 |
Version 1 | To prepare a report on the Insolvency Payments Section Business Process Re-engineering (BPR) | 13,177 |
RITS | Security Advice | 38,535 |
IQ Content Ltd | Review of Department's Website | 20,604 |
Goodbody Economic Consultants | Review of the Wage Subsidy Scheme | 23,595 |
IPA | Quality Assessment of Science Foundation Ireland (SFI) Value for Money Review | 3,630 |
Carr Communications | Communications Advice for the Companies Registration Office (CRO) | 25,593 |
Open Interface | Website accessibility advice for the CRO | 3,993 |
Grant Thornton | Procurement and business solution advice for the CRO | 71,874 |
Millward Brown/IMS | Market Research for ODCE | 15,898 |
Mathias Kelly QC | Legal advice | 167,171 |
Experian Ireland | Provision of statistical analysis of returns to the CRO | 182 |
PricewaterhouseCoopers | Media Research for the Advisory Group on Media Mergers | 26,965 |
Emily Gibson BL | Legal Services for the Advisory Group on Media Mergers | 5,596 |
Form Creative Ltd | Advertising campaign for Work Life Balance Day 2008 | €4,994 |
Form Creative Ltd | Advertising campaign for Work Life Balance Day 2008 | 120,000 |
Arthur Cox | Prioritising Information Obligations in Company Law Legislation | 2,226 |
Scannell Solutions | Prioritising Health and Safety Obligations — Additional Review | 605 |
IQ Content Ltd | Review of Department's Website | 41,261 |
Indecon Economic Consultants | Value for Money Review of SFI | 74,163 |
No comments