Written answers

Tuesday, 21 November 2006

Department of Education and Science

Schools Refurbishment

9:00 am

Photo of Richard BrutonRichard Bruton (Dublin North Central, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context

Question 540: To ask the Minister for Education and Science the criteria used for deciding on applications under the temporary accommodation scheme and the summer works scheme 2007; when she will be in a position to make a decision on an application by a school (details supplied) in Dublin 3. [38975/06]

Photo of Mary HanafinMary Hanafin (Dún Laoghaire, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I can confirm that the Department is in receipt of applications under the Summer Works Scheme 2007 and the Permanent Accommodation Scheme 2007 from the management authority of the school to which the Deputy refers. All applications under these Schemes are currently being assessed in accordance with the published prioritisation criteria. I intend to publish a list of successful applicants as soon as the assessment procedures are completed. The prioritisation criteria for the Schemes are contained in the following documents.

CIRCULAR LETTER 0064/2006

To: Primary and Post Primary School Authorities

SUMMER WORKS SCHEME 2007

Scheme of Capital Grants for Small Scale Works

School Planning Section,

Department of Education and Science,

Portlaoise Road,

Tullamore,

Co. Offaly.

Summer Works Scheme Helpline: Freephone 1800 200 955

school

www.education.ie

The Minister for Education and Science is pleased to announce details of the Summer Works Scheme for 2007 and to invite applications under the Scheme in accordance with the terms of this Circular Letter. Please read it carefully before completing an application form. (Download application form)

1. Introduction

The purpose of the Summer Works Scheme is to devolve funding to individual school authorities to undertake small scale building works which, ideally, can be carried out during the summer months or at other times that avoid disrupting the operation of the school. Under the terms of the Scheme, school authorities are empowered to manage these works with guidance from and minimal interaction with the Department.

Funding will be allocated to projects in accordance with the prioritisation criteria attaching to the Scheme which, in the normal course, includes the ability to have the works carried out during the summer. However, in certain circumstances, the Department may allocate funding to further projects later in the year where these can be carried out without disruption to the operation of the school. If this arises, the terms and conditions of the Scheme will continue to apply when allocating funding to such projects.

2. Schools covered by the Scheme

The Scheme is open to primary and post primary schools with permanent recognition and in non-rented accommodation.

3. Works covered by the Scheme

Necessary small-scale works that, ideally, can be planned and delivered during the summer months.

4. Application process

Where a school applies for more than one project, it must:

Use one application form (Download application form)

Clearly identify the projects in order of priority

Provide individual costings and fees for each project.

In all cases, post primary schools are required to provide details of any Science and Technology upgrade or refurbishment projects separate from any other projects being applied for.

School Planning Section will not be able to adjudicate on the relative priority attaching to each individual project at a particular school. In the circumstances, the responsibility for identifying and applying for the most urgently required project rests with the school authority.

5. Ineligible projects

Projects that are desirable rather than absolutely necessary.

Projects that should ordinarily be carried out as routine maintenance.

Projects that could not reasonably be expected to be carried out using other funding channels, for example, the devolved grant scheme at primary level.

Any element of a new build other than that relating to access for all or necessary toilet facilities.

Temporary accommodation projects.

Radon or asbestos remediation projects. The Department has separate processes in place for dealing with these project types.

Projects already scheduled to be carried out as part of a larger project under the School Building Programme.

Any applications for these project types will be automatically rejected.

6. Technical issues

Part 2 of the application form addresses technical issues. This must be completed by a *suitably qualified Consultant with adequate Professional Indemnity Insurance and Employer's Liability Insurance otherwise the application will be disqualified. It is important that the Consultant has the appropriate qualifications for the works being considered. The appointment of a Consultant is a matter for the school authority and any fees arising must be borne by it. Any reasonable fees incurred will be included in the overall allocation for successful applicants.

No commitment should be entered into with a Consultant beyond the work involved in completing part 2 of the application form.

The Consultant's report must comply in full with the Department's relevant Technical Guidance Documents with respect to format and content (see Department's website). It must also be accompanied by photographic evidence.

A Consultant's report is necessary:

For a professional diagnosis of the full nature and extent of the proposed project.

To verify the absolute necessity of the project.

To provide a range of cost effective solutions.

To enable the prioritisation of projects on the basis of professional objective information.

Please see Appendix A of this Circular Letter for guidance on the appointment of a Consultant.

*Examples of unacceptable qualifications for the purposes of a Consultant's report are:

Diploma in Construction Studies, Architectural Assistant, Agricultural Engineer, Building Surveyor, Building Contractor, B. Sc (Environment), Estimator, Electrician, Plumber, Window Contractor, OPW architect (unless it is verified with the application that the report is carried out on the direction of the OPW acting on the instruction of the Department of Education and Science).

This list is not exhaustive. If you have any doubts in relation to the suitability of a proposed Consultant, please contact the Helpline. The Department's decision will be final as to whether or not a Consultant is appropriately qualified.

7. Proposed Timetable for 2007 Scheme

Publication of Scheme details and application form1st June 2006
Closing date for receipt of applications29th September, 2006
Publication of list of successful applicantsDecember, 2006
Confirmation of acceptance must be made to School Building Section byJanuary, 2007
The Department's Building Section will request confirmation that you are progressing the proposed works byApril, 2007
You will be required to confirm to School Building Section that the works have commenced and request draw down of 70% of the grant aid byJuly, 2007
You will be required to have requested the draw down of the final 30% of the grant aid byNovember, 2007

8. Assessment, categorisation and prioritisation of projects

Details of how projects will be assessed, categorised and prioritised are set out in Appendix B.

Commensurate with the level of funding available, demonstrably necessary projects which command the highest priority rating will be approved to proceed. It is important to understand that the assignment of a project to a particular category does not imply that it will receive funding. Only those applications satisfying the fundamental criterion of absolute need will succeed in this regard.

In allocating funding, account will be taken of Government policy in relation to urban and rural disadvantage (RAPID and CLÁR programmes) and inclusion and access for special needs pupils.

9. Grant details

Grant details, including conditions for drawing down the grant, are set out in Appendix C.

10. Local contribution

The appropriate local contribution will be required, as normal, from non-State owned schools.

Confirmation of its availability is sought in the application form.

The local contribution for small scale works is 10% of the capital cost up to a maximum contribution of €31,500 or, in the case of special/disadvantaged schools at primary level, 5% of the capital cost up to a maximum contribution of €12,500.

11. Freephone Service

A freephone service has been put in place to assist you with any queries on the Scheme including completion of the application form. This service will be available between the hours of 10am to 1pm each day from 1st June, 2006 to 29th September, 2006. The Freephone no. is 1800 200 955.

SWS calls to other lines will be automatically re-directed to this number to ensure that information given to schools is being provided by staff specifically trained in the detail of the Summer Works Scheme.

12. Freedom of Information Act

Persons signing application forms are reminded that the Department may be obliged to release any information supplied under the Freedom of Information Act, 1997 and 2003.

Tony Dalton,

Principal,

School Planning Section

May, 2006.

(Download application form)

Appendix A

Engaging Professional Advice for the Preparation of a Technical Report

Important: The cost of engaging professional advice to prepare a technical report must be met in full from a school's own resources. Failure to procure a Consultant in the appropriate discipline or the procurement of a Consultant without adequate Professional Indemnity Insurance & Employer's Liability Insurance may result in the disqualification of your application

Advice available on Freephone 1800 200 955

Before a Consultant is appointed:

Refer to the Department's Technical Guidance Document TGD 008 — Engaging Consultants for Devolved Grants Projects — Revised Edition — March 2006. This document is available on the Department's website www. education.ie.

Ensure that the Consultant is in the appropriate discipline for the works concerned. If a project relates substantially or entirely to construction works, such as refurbishment or repair works, the engagement of an Architect or a Civil/Structural Engineer is appropriate. If a project relates substantially or entirely to Building Services i.e. mechanical/electrical works, a Building Services Consulting Engineer should be engaged. The onus rests with the school authority to ensure that the appropriate level and range of service is procured.

The Consultant will have a relevant degree of qualification and in all cases will either be a member of a professional body (e.g. RIAI for Architects, IEI/ACEI for Engineers and SCS for Quantity Surveyors or Chartered Building Surveyors) or be eligible for such membership. Equivalent qualifications from another EU member state and membership of an equivalent EU professional body will also be deemed acceptable.

Be satisfied that the Consultant is competent and qualified to carry out the work. A minimum of three suitable Consultants should be identified for consideration and the one most suitable selected on objective criteria. These criteria should include quality of previous work, the ability to perform against deadlines, and the fee for assessing the work and recommending solutions (i.e. completing Part 2 of the application form).

Address the following matters with prospective Consultants:

Experience in the preparation of reports for projects of a similar nature highlighting the scope of works and the timescale.

How the Consultant ensures accurate cost information.

A brief summary of the scope of the agreed report and a timescale for its delivery.

Confirmation of appropriate professional qualifications.

Confirmation of adequate Professional Indemnity Insurance and Employer's Liability Insurance.

VAT inclusive all-in fee (including buying-in).

Discuss a realistic scope of works to enable assessment of the amount of work necessary to prepare the technical report. Additionally, accurate professional cost advice is an essential part of the report. Accordingly, the cost of the work must be clearly identified alongside the cost of any associated planning fees and an estimate of the professional fees for managing the execution of the works should the project be approved.

Agree the level of fee payable for completion of the report only (i.e. completing Part 2 of the application form).

Be satisfied that the agreed fee is a fair reflection of the time and resources required to carry out the task.

Do not:

Enter into any commitments regarding an overall fee for the remedial works and make it clear to the Consultant that the appointment to carry out the Report does not entitle the Consultant to be appointed to carry out the works if the application is successful.

Appendix B

1. How projects will be prioritised and categorised

Priority/Category 1: Gas Works

Priority/Category 2: Electrical Works

Priority/Category 3: Mechanical works (including Dust Extraction)

Priority/Category 4: Projects to facilitate inclusion and access for special needs pupils

Priority/Category 5: Toilet facilities

Priority/Category 6: Roof works

Priority/Category 7: Window projects

Priority/Category 8: Curricular requirement projects

Priority/Category 9: Other structural improvements

Priority/Category 10: External environment projects

2. Supporting evidence required for Category 4 projects in addition to the information required in the application form (SWS1)

Confirmation of the nature and extent of the special need.

Suggestions as to how existing accommodation could be modified to accommodate the pupil or staff member.

In the case of a pupil or staff member not yet attending the school, evidence of intent to commence at the school in the school year 2007/8.

3. Summary of criteria which will be applied in assessing applications

The application has been properly completed, signed and returned within the prescribed time i.e. 29th September, 2006.

Part 2 of the form has been properly completed by a suitably qualified Consultant and a range of remediation options has been provided and costed.

The project is absolutely necessary and can, ideally, be planned and delivered during the summer months.

The project does not arise due to deficiencies in a school's maintenance programme and/ or cannot be addressed by the application of a proper maintenance programme.

The project cannot be carried out as routine maintenance and cannot be addressed under the devolved grant scheme for minor works or through other funding channels.

There is no element of a new build in the proposed project other than that relating to access for all or necessary toilet facilities.

The application does not refer to or have any element of temporary accommodation / radon or asbestos remediation.

There are no plans to carry out the project as part of a larger project under the Capital Programme.

Priorities have been clearly identified.

Confirmation has been given that the local contribution, where applicable, will be available.

Please note that a school may apply under the Scheme in successive years for additional projects.

Appendix C

Grant details

1. Amount which will be approved

The grant payable by the Department (inclusive of VAT and fees) will be whichever is the lesser of the following:

The amount of grant-aid approved by the Department in its letter of approval

or

The lowest valid tender amount for the proposed project plus fees (and less the local contribution where applicable).

2. Local contribution

Grant aid will be net of the local contribution where such a contribution applies.

3. Funding shortfall

If there is a shortfall in funding, the options open to school managerial authorities are to:

Reduce the scope of the works to stay within the limit of the grant.

In the case of primary schools, use funds allocated by the Department under the terms of the Grant Scheme for Minor Works to supplement the SWS grant provided such funds are not required for more urgent and immediate works.

Fund the balance of the works from own resources.

4. What the grant covers

The grant is intended to cover the capital cost of the project including associated planning charges, all consultants' fees incurred in the design and construction of the project, all fees for the Project Supervisor Design Stage (PSDS) and all fees for the Project Supervisor Construction Stage (PSCS).

5. Payment of grant

The first payment will be for 70% of the grant amount and this will be paid on receipt, through the school authority, of the following confirmation from the Consultant:

That the works undertaken are in accordance with the scope of works for which the grant was approved.

That the tender process was carried out in accordance with the terms outlined in the letter of grant sanction.

That the management authority has placed a contract for the proposed works with the successful contractor and the contractor is on site and has commenced the works.

The Department, in compliance with public procurement, places a requirement on school authorities to use the standard (GDLA) form of contract for all school building projects. The "employer" of contractors on school building projects is in virtually all cases the school authority except for state owned schools where it is the Minister for Education and Science.

Under Clause 39 of this contract, contractors are obliged to pay rates of wages and observe hours of labour and conditions of employment that are not less favourable than those laid down by the National Joint Industrial Council for the Construction Industry. The contractor is also responsible for the due observance by all sub-contractors of the provisions of this clause.

It will, therefore, be necessary for the Consultant to inform the Department, through a school's management authority, of the tender amount for the proposed works, plus fees, before any payments can be made.

The second and final payment will be for the remaining 30% of the grant amount. This will be paid on receipt from the school authority of:

A copy of the certificate of practical completion from the Consultant.

Written confirmation that a minimum of half of the agreed percentage retention rate of the overall contract sum will be retained for a period of 12 months following completion of the works and that this sum shall not be expended for any other purpose. The reason for this retention is to ensure that any building defects which may become apparent during that period will be rectified by the contractor.

The Consultant's Opinion of Compliance of the relevant development with planning permission and or exemption from planning control.

The Consultant's Opinion of Compliance of the relevant development with the building regulations including the fire safety certificate.

Confirmation from the Consultant(s) that a safety file has been prepared and issued to the school managerial authority.

Confirmation that the school authority has received from its Consultant copies of all relevant drawings and documents, if possible in an appropriate electronic format, together with the Consultant's confirmation that the completed works are in accordance with these drawings and documents.

Circular Letter 0098/2006

To: Primary and Post Primary School Authorities

School Building Programme : 2007

Permanent Accommodation Scheme 2007

Classroom Accommodation

Please return completed forms no later than 27th October, 2006 to:

School Planning Section,

Department of Education and Science,

Portlaoise Road,

Tullamore,

Co. Offaly.

Helpline: Freephone 1800 200 955

school

www.education.ie

1. Introduction

The purpose of the Permanent Accommodation Scheme 2007 (PAS) is to provide a classroom accommodation solution to schools for the 2007/08 school year, where an absolute need is demonstrated.

This scheme is focused on schools which are not in need of an immediate major extension or building project but which require additional classroom accommodation.

If ancillary accommodation and/ or a major extension is required in addition to classroom accommodation, school authorities should consider, if not already done, submitting a completed FLE or SLE application form (available on the website www.education.ie download here FLE SLE) to be considered for delivery by the traditional method, in the context of the School Building and Modernisation Programme.

Applicants should note that this scheme does not cover accommodation required for decanting purposes during a building project. Further details in relation to Accommodation Solution falling within the scope of this grant scheme are set out in Sections 6-8.

2. Schools covered by the Scheme

The Scheme is open to primary and post primary schools.

3. Scope of Scheme

Primary Schools

Primary School authorities are aware from October each year of the expected mainstream staffing allocation for the forthcoming year, if there is no change in the staffing schedule.

School authorities should, therefore, assess their accommodation needs on that basis and only make application for additional accommodation under this scheme, if it is clear that there will be an immediate urgent deficit of classroom accommodation.

Approval for additional accommodation under this scheme will not be given where there is no overall increased enrolment in the catchment area.

It is acknowledged that in rapidly developing areas and/or in recently recognised schools it can be difficult to plan accurately for the required additional accommodation. However, such schools should make an application for additional accommodation through this scheme based on their best estimate of emerging requirements.

Post Primary Schools

Post primary Schools are better placed to deal with an increase in pupil numbers, as the pattern should be obvious from enrolment figures in feeder national schools and the configuration of schools.

Accordingly, post primary applicants are advised that only in exceptional circumstances will applications under this scheme be considered.

4. How to apply for accommodation under this scheme

Permanent Accommodation Scheme (PAS) applications forms are now available on the Department's website www.education.ie and may be downloaded here. Copies of same are also attached for ease of reference.

Completed forms can be submitted by post or by e-mail and must be fully signed off by the relevant representatives of the school authority.

Successful applications will be selected, inter alia, on the basis that

the school submits a fully completed application form to the Planning and Building Unit (application forms are attached and/or can be downloaded from www.education.ie).

the Department is satisfied that no alternative suitable accommodation is available within the school or the catchment area.

the long-term projected enrolments (post-primary) / long term projected staffing (primary), as assessed by the Department, indicate that participation in this scheme at this time will address the classroom accommodation issues of the school and there is not a requirement for further additional accommodation in the foreseeable future.

architectural planning has not already been approved by the Department for a large-scale building project at the school.

5. Timetable for 2007 Scheme

Publication of Scheme details and application formAugust 2006
Closing date for receipt of applications27th October, 2006
Publication of list of successful applicantsEnd of 2006
Information Sessions for successful applicants *1st Quarter 2007
*The Department will be holding an information session for successful applicants at which the terms of the scheme will be outlined in more detail. Schools will be requested to confirm their acceptance to these terms and conditions.

6. Criteria Specific to Primary Schools

Applications will be subdivided into the following categories:

Category 1 — Mainstream classroom accommodation / DEIS—School Support Programme

Category 2 — Special Education Tuition (SET) support / Language Support Teacher etc

Category 1 (Mainstream / DEIS—School Support Programme) will be assessed using the following criteria:

Schools in developing areas where there is no alternative accommodation

Recently recognised schools, allowing for incremental growth

Schools with additional teacher appointments where no other accommodation is available in the school or the area

Category 2 (Special Education Tuition ( SET) support / Language Support Teacher etc. will be assessed using the following criteria

Confirmed specific need which did not exist in previous school years

All other available accommodation at the school is in use

7. Criteria Specific to Post Primary Schools

Applications will be subdivided into the following categories:

Category 1 — Mainstream classroom accommodation

Category 2 — Special Education Tuition (SET) etc.

Category 1 (Mainstream) will be assessed using the following criteria:

Schools having an urgent deficit of mainstream accommodation as a result of increasing enrolments in the catchment area

Recently recognised schools, allowing for incremental growth

Category 2 (Special Education Tuition) etc will be assessed using the following criteria

Confirmed specific need which did not exist in previous school years

All other available accommodation at the school is in use

8. Accommodation Solutions

Consideration will be given to the school's preferred solution. However, the final decision on the appropriate solution will be made by the Department.

It is the policy of the Department to provide a permanent accommodation solution insofar as possible. Commensurate with the level of funding available, applications which have been assessed as appropriate to the scheme, where the school's accommodation requirement is recognised as permanent, will be given approval for funding to enable the school to provide the accommodation required under this grant scheme.

Successful applications for which a permanent solution is not the appropriate response e.g. where a major building project is in the pipeline, will have their immediate accommodation requirement dealt with by way of either relocation of existing prefabricated accommodation or by way of rental of prefabricated accommodation / premises.

Further details in relation to rental accommodation will be published shortly.

9. Level of Grant Assistance

Primary

Mainstream Classroom: €120,000

SET/other: €60,000

Post Primary

Mainstream Classroom: €85,000

SET/other: €42,500

10. Frequently Asked Questions

Attached for information of applicants, are a set of Questions and Answers to the most frequent queries received in relation to this scheme.

Any further queries in relation to the scheme should be made directly to the Helpline or put in writing to the Planning and Building Unit.

11. Freedom of Information Act

Applicants are reminded that the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act, 1997 and 2003 apply. As such it should be noted that the Department may be obliged to release information submitted to the Department under the Freedom of Information Act, 1997 and 2003.

Jason Kearney

Principal

School Planning Section

August, 2006

APPENDIX 1 — LEVEL OF GRANT-AID

&

DRAW-DOWN CONDITIONS

1. What is the amount of the grant?

The up to date amount of grant payable

Primary

Mainstream Classroom : €120,000

SET/other: €60,000

Post Primary

Mainstream Classroom: €85,000

SET/other: €42,500

2. Is the school guaranteed this amount?

Yes provided the terms of the scheme are complied with. Once selected the grant payable by the Department (inclusive of Value Added Tax and all fees) will be the lower of:

the amount of grant-aid approved by the Department in its letter of approval,

or

the lowest valid tender amount for the proposed works plus reasonable fees.

3. If this amount is not enough, what can the school do?

The choices to be made within this devolved scheme rest with the school and that is the cornerstone of any policy of devolution. The school authority knows the budget and must decide what it is capable of building with that budget. The time to identify a funding problem is at the outset before entering any contract. Schools should raise with the Department any site specific problems or unusual planning stipulations that impose additional costs and these will be examined provided the Department is notified of them in advance of contracts being signed.

Setting the scope of works is the critical first step. Clearly where a school has a known level of resources apart from the Department funding or knows its capacity to raise additional resources it is open to that school to extend the scope of works to include additional facilities. However if the scope of works is not set appropriately from the outset based on the budget available there is a risk that the school will be faced with a funding gap when the project is at construction.

If there is a shortfall in funding, the options open to the school authority are to:

a.Reduce the scale of the works to stay within the limit of the grant

b.Use funds allocated by the Department under the terms of the Grant Scheme for Minor Works to supplement the grant, provided such funds are not required for more urgent and immediate works

c.Apply separately under the Department's Summer Works Scheme (that is currently advertised on its website) for additional funding to deal with exceptional additional refurbishment costs in their existing school buildings.

d.Fund the balance of the works from its own resources.

4. Will the school authority be required to make a local contribution towards the project?

The Scheme is not structured on the basis that the Department funding must be supplemented by local fundraising. It does however allow a school to supplement the funding from local resources if it so decides. The critical element is that with devolved authority the school must set the scope of works to match the funding allocated. The Department does not define the precise works to be carried out other than it must be in accordance with the terms of the scheme. A school can make choices within the budget allocated.

5. Who pays for consultants' fees and planning charges?

The grant is intended to cover the capital cost of the project including associated planning charges and all consultants' fees incurred in the design and construction of the project, all fees for the Project Supervisor Design Stage (PSDS) and all fees for the Project Supervisor Construction Stage (PSCS).

6. Can the Department withdraw an offer of grant-aid?

Yes, the grant sanction will automatically lapse if construction work does not commence within 12 months of the date of approval. The Department retains the option of altering/withdrawing the offer of grant aid if it is considered by the Department that a change in the local circumstances is sufficient to warrant this.

7. At what point will the grant be paid?

The school authority must notify the Department of the tender amount for the proposed works plus fees before any payments can be made.

First payment

The first payment will be for 70% of the Department's liability and this will be paid on receipt, through the school authority, of the following confirmation from your architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor that:

the works are in accordance with terms of the scheme

tenders were sought in accordance with a competitive tendering process as set out in Appendix 3

a Safety Plan was completed and presented to the successful contractor

the lowest valid tender was accepted by the Board and the successful contractor fulfilled the criteria set out at Appendix 3

the Board fulfilled its obligation under the Health and Safety regulations, in particular, the appointment of a competent person to fulfil the role of Project Supervisor Construction Stage ( PSCS)

the successful contractor has produced a safety statement

the Board has placed a contract for the proposed works with the successful contractor and the contractor is on site and has commenced building works.

Second and final payment

The second and final payment will be for the remaining 30% of the Department's liability and this will be paid on receipt of the following documentation:

copy of the certificate of practical completion from your architect/engineer / chartered buildings surveyor.

your consultant's Opinion of Compliance of the relevant development with planning permission and or exemption from planning control

your consultant's Opinion of Compliance of the relevant development with the building regulations including the fire safety certificate

confirmation from your consultant(s) that a safety file has been prepared by the PS(C)S and issued to the Board of Management.

copies of all relevant drawings, if possible in an appropriate electronic format, and your consultant's confirmation that the completed works are in accordance with these drawings.

Confirmation from the Board of Management that 50% of the agreed retention % rate of the contract sum will be retained for a period of 12 months following the completion of the works and pending the rectification of any building defects which may become apparent during that period.

During the Defects Liability period your architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor must prepare the final account for the project to determine the exact final payment due to the contractor. The school authority is advised to retain the final portion of the architect/engineer / chartered building surveyor's fee until the final account has been completed. The school authority must satisfy itself as to the correctness of the final account before making final payments to the contractor

APPENDIX 2 — TECHNICAL ISSUES

1. Is written Guidance on Technical Issues available?

Yes. Schools should consult Technical Guidance Document TGD007 "Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants", and also TGD008 "Engaging Professional Consultants" available on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

2. Is a consultant architect / engineer / chartered building surveyor required?

Yes. The school authority must employ a suitably qualified consultant architect , engineer or chartered building surveyor [member of Royal Institute of Architects (RIAI), Institute of engineers of Ireland (IEI), Society of Chartered Surveyors or equivalent] Refer to TGD008 "Engaging Professional Consultants" for guidance available on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

The school authority must also satisfy itself that the consultant architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor will be able to provide satisfactory evidence of tax clearance and adequate professional indemnity insurance cover in advance of engagement.

The school authority should ensure that the fee is agreed with the architect/engineer /chartered building surveyor before the Consultant is appointed and that it covers ALL necessary professional and technical services (including buying-in other services as required) and all expenses.

3. Who is responsible for ensuring compliance with statutory regulations?

The school authority is the client for the project and, in consultation with the architect/engineer / chartered building surveyor, is responsible for ensuring compliance with all statutory regulations which, with most projects, will require obtaining planning permission and a fire safety certificate. The building project must comply in all respect with building regulations. The consultant architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor will be able to advise the Board on these matters.

Refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 "Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants" on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

4. Who is responsible for ensuring compliance with Health and Safety Regulations?

The school authority, as client, is responsible for the implementation of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Construction) Regulations 2001 and subsequent H&S legislation scheduled for implementation in 2006. Under these regulations the appointment of a competent person to act as Project Supervisor (Design) stage PS(D)S is a legal obligation. Guidance on how to do this can be found in TGD008 "Engaging Professional Consultants" on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

At construction stage the school authority as client, is also responsible for the appointment of a competent person to act as Project Supervisor Construction Stage. The PS(D)S will advise on this and his/her fee should include for the assessment of contractors' competence to carry out this role.

Refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 Design Team Procedures Protocol for Devolved Grants on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance for H&S information documentation required at Tender and Completion stages, including the safety file which should be retained by the school authority.

5. What should be done if the school is known to contain asbestos?

If your school has not already been surveyed for the presence of asbestos or you are unsure whether or not it has been surveyed, you or the architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor should contact the Health and Safety Unit, Office of Public Works, 51 St. Stephen's Green, Dublin 2 — Tel. 01/6476198. In this context, please refer to circular letter 37/99 issued by the Building Unit in December, 1999.

6. How are tenders to be sought for this proposed building project?

Tenders must be sought on a fixed price basis (i.e. Clause 36 of the GDLA form of contract should be deleted). Refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 Design Team Procedures Protocol for Devolved Grants on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

7. What criteria must the successful contractor fulfil?

Refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 "Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants", and also TGD014 "Guidance on Pre-Selection of Contractors" on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

8. Logo on site

Projects must display an acknowledgement sign that they are being funded by the National Development Plan (NDP) 2002 — 2006. Guidance on this matter is available on www.ndp.ie.

9. Reminder of penalty for non compliance with terms of scheme

The Department reserves the right to withhold payment of the grant to schools for non-compliance with any terms of the scheme.

10. What other guidance is available to the Board?

Guidance on technical issues is available on Departments Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

APPENDIX 3 — LEGAL ISSUES

1. Is a Lease/Declaration of Trust required?

It is a condition of funding that the school site including school building(s) are the subject of a Lease/Declaration of Trust that is valid for a minimum period of 35 years from a current date. The lease simply guarantees that the school property is retained for educational use. The lease must be amended to reflect the level of capital investment. The school authority is advised to seek the advice of legal representative in this and all legal matters.

A grant awarded under the provisions of this scheme does not/should not of itself confer a particular tenure on a building as the terms of the Rules for National Schools and the Education Act apply. The school authority must have the approval of the patron/trustee before application is made for capital works and have this reaffirmed prior to a contract being placed.

2. Who is responsible for the proposed building project?

This scheme devolves authority and responsibility to the school authority for the execution of the works. The school authority is responsible for all interactions with the consultant architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor and for ensuring that the proposed works are in accordance with the conditions set out in this scheme.

3. What records must be kept?

All expenditure in connection with the scheme must be vouched and all documentation must be retained by the school authority for a minimum period of seven years in the event of an audit inspection by the Department and/or Comptroller and Auditor General.

Please note that the Department will be undertaking random audits and inspections of schools participating in this scheme.

4. Why are random audits done?

In accordance with standard practice, payment of capital grants is conditional on the Department being satisfied that the school has followed proper procedures and retained appropriate records. In addition it is essential that a proper maintenance programme is in place to protect the school. Guidelines as to how to address this matter were outlined in the "Maintenance Matters" manual issued to all schools in 1998. An electronic version of "Maintenance Matters" can be downloaded

APPENDIX 4 — GUIDE TO THE BUILDING PROCESS

Introduction

This guide is issued by the Department of Education and Science for general guidance purposes only. For more detailed information refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance

Building Projects

There are a number of stages to a Building Project, which are summarised below. The consultant employed by the school authority must be competent in all of these areas and the purpose of this document is to describe those processes in brief to persons not normally involved in the building procurement process.

Setting of Brief

This is the establishment of clear accommodation requirements; refurbishment requirements etc. coupled with the setting of cost parameters and any other relevant job specific objectives. The role of the Client (which is the school authority) assisted by the architect/engineer / chartered building surveyor, is to set the brief within the constraints of the amount of the grant and the priority areas outlined Paragraph 3 of the Scheme.

Design

The preparation by the architect/engineer/chartered building surveyor of initial sketch drawings which properly describe the proposed works for approval by the school authority and which are also consistent with the established brief and cost parameters.

Planning Permission

The statutory process as required under the Planning and Development Act 2000. This involves the preparation and submission of a planning application to the relevant local authority to obtain planning permission and other necessary statutory consents to carry out development work.

Fire Safety Certificate

The statutory process as required under the Building Control Regulations 1991 — 1994 which involves the preparation and submission of a fire safety certificate application to the relevant Building Control for certification to carry out certain development work.

Tendering Process

The process of obtaining competitive tenders (prices) from a selected number of building contractors (a minimum of five). (Refer to Technical Guidance Document TGD-007 Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance)

Tender analysis and Start-up

The Building Contractor is selected following analysis of the tenders and submission of all necessary documentation). (Refer to TGD-007 Design Team Procedures: Protocol for Devolved Grants on the Department Web-Site under School Building/Technical Guidance)

Contract Stage

This is the period during which the work actually takes place on site.

Post Contract Stage/Defects Liability Period

A period of time (normally twelve months) following the completion of the works during which a percentage of the monies due to the building contractor is withheld pending the rectification of any building defects which become apparent during that period

Explanation of job functions and other common terms

Architect — The person responsible for the design of the building

Quantity Surveyor — The person responsible for the cost control of the project and the Bill of Quantities

Structural Engineer — The person responsible for the structural design of the building

Mechanical and Electrical Engineer — The person responsible for the design of the electrical and mechanical aspects of the project (lighting, heating, air extraction etc.)

PSDSProject Supervisor Design Stage — The person who assesses Health & Safety during the course of the project design, and whose task is to ensure safety both during the construction stage and in use thereafter. (this does not relieve the other Designers of similar responsibilities.)

PSCSProject Supervisor Construction Stage — the PSCS is usually the main building contractor whose job it is to ensure that the works undertaken on site are done so in a safe manner without risk to the workers involved.

Bill of Quantities — A complete elemental breakdown of the scope of the works including quantification for pricing purposes

GDLA Form of Contract — Government Department and Local Authorities contract document. This is the standard form of contract for construction work being paid for from public funds.

Timescale of work

The following table illustrates the approximate time frame on a month by month basis for all of the processes described in the previous pages. The contract stage will vary from project to project with the following table illustrating a typical three month building programme:

ProcessAverage time of Process in Months
12345678910111213
Setting of Brief
Design
Planning Preparation
Planning Process
Fire Safety Certification
Tender Preparation
Tender Process
Tender analysis + Start-up
Contract Stage
Post Contract Stage

Photo of Paul Connaughton  SnrPaul Connaughton Snr (Galway East, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context

Question 541: To ask the Minister for Education and Science the position regarding an application by a school (details supplied) in County Galway for funding for replacement windows and internal piping as part of the 2007 summer works scheme; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [38976/06]

Photo of Mary HanafinMary Hanafin (Dún Laoghaire, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

School Planning Section of my Department is in receipt of an application for the Summer Works Scheme 2007 from the management authority of the school to which the Deputy refers. Applications for the Summer Works Scheme are currently being assessed and the list of successful applicants will be published as soon as possible.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.