Hildegarde Naughton (Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

I welcome this well-intentioned amendment. There is genuine concern among citizens about the effects of fluoridation of water. While the amendment it is well-intentioned, it is not appropriate that a non-scientific body assess scientific cases. I agree with Senator Leyden's suggestion that an expert group be set up, but I understood - the Minister might be able to clarify this - that an expert group had already been established and is considering this issue. We must wait for recommendations to emerge from that scientific expert group so we can make more informed decisions as to how to proceed.

The preponderance of scientific research, the World Health Organization and the Irish Medicines Board have found there is no link between fluoridation and adverse health effects. However, a large amount of contradictory evidence is coming forward, so it is important that this expert group be established, if it is not already in place, and that it report back to both Houses. It is also a matter for the Oireachtas health committee. We must have expert scientific opinion. I accept that the amendment is tabled in good faith, but it is important that a scientific body research this and report back to the Oireachtas with its recommendations.