David Cullinane (Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

We had a good decision on section 8 which dealt with the amalgamation of Waterford City and County Councils. I thank Senators Cummins and Landy for their positive contributions on Waterford city.

I wish to comment on the Minister's one line response to the question on the core issue of whether a plebiscite was considered. He said that all things had been considered but I am being constructive when I say that we deserve more of an answer. He must accept that there are some concerns. It would have been wiser to let the people decide.

I ask him to explain why a decision was taken to amalgamate some cities and counties but not others. Let me take Galway and Waterford as an example. Why was Waterford not considered for amalgamation? Why was Galway considered for amalgamation? What criteria was used to judge whether an amalgamation was in the best interest of the people of Waterford city and county but not in the best interest of the people of Galway city and county? What principle, logic and criteria were applied? I would like to hear his views on the matter because it might explain his decision to amalgamate some local authorities and not others.