Seanad debates

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

4:00 pm

Photo of Marie MoloneyMarie Moloney (Labour)

I welcome the Minister to the House. Given that he has a busy schedule I thank him for taking the time to attend to debate the motion.

I commend the Fine Gael Senators who have highlighted the issue and tabled the motion. Each year brings with it a new and rare disease and, unfortunately, it is impossible to have the expertise at hand to deal with each disease. While doctors specialise in a specific area of medicine it would be impossible to have a consultant for each disease.

This is why it is important to have a clinical care programme specifically for patients with rare diseases. This programme could guide and assist patients to accessing the right course of treatment and ensure a specialist is found to deal with the disease as quickly as possible, be it in or outside the country.

A very close family member was diagnosed with the rare blood disease, amyloidosis, just before Christmas 2010. There are only two places where this disease can be dealt with - the Royal Free Hampstead in London and the Mayo Clinic in the US. Until such time as an appointment could be made for him, he was advised to spend Christmas with his family and prepare them for the worst as it would be his last Christmas. He had been given six months to live. At the very first consultation in London, however, my relative was informed by the specialist that he could cure him and cure him he did. Can one imagine the agony that young man, his wife and his three school-going children went through until he saw the specialist? Had a clinical care programme been in place and the right information provided, the young man could have been spared all this agony.

Amyloidosis is a western disease with 500 cases a year diagnosed. Not everyone with the disease can be cured but there is help. Some diseases, although not really rare, often go undetected such as Lyme disease. It is prevalent in the Killarney area because of the high deer population there. Although beautiful to look at it and a great attraction to scenic routes in Kerry, deer may also pose a serious threat to human health. It is a little-known fact that one can contract Lyme disease from deer populations that harbour ticks which carry the disease. One can come into contact with ticks just about anywhere but one's chances are greater in wooded areas or places with high grass and weeds. Ticks need large mammals for hosts as they feed off their blood. Deer are one such host. Some ticks carry Lyme disease and because they have an anaesthetic property in their jaw, one might not even know one has been bitten. The symptoms of Lyme disease can be very similar to multiple sclerosis, MS, lupus or fibromyalgia. If the disease is caught an early stage, it can be treated effectively with antibiotics. However, if not, recovery, if it happens at all, can take years.

In the UK last year, there were 2,000 cases of Lyme disease. It is likely there is a large number here too. However, we are not sure because it is not a notifiable disease. Some patient advocacy groups suspect the Killarney area is particularly infected. We should be highlighting awareness, encourage quick diagnosis and treatment of this debilitating disease. Occasionally, a patient may carry Lyme disease but have no outwardly obvious symptoms. Ill health may crop up years later following an illness or period of stress. This leads to decimated or late Lyme disease where symptoms are similar to MS, chronic fatigue syndrome and Parkinson's disease.

I am delighted the Department of Health is reviewing the existing strategy of addressing patients with rare diseases and, hopefully, a new strategy will emerge. Will the Minister advise the House as to how this review is progressing? When a patient is diagnosed with a rare disease, they can be off work for some time. My family relative was off work for six months but when he tried to explain his illness to his employer and work mates, they did not know anything about it. The motion calls for a suitable information system which could assist employers and employees in knowing how rare disease patients are affected.

I recommend the motion to the House and hopefully it will be supported by all parties.

Comments

Lisa Vandegrift Davala
Posted on 27 Mar 2012 12:00 pm (Report this comment)

Thank you to all the Senators who brought Lyme and other rarer diseases to the attention of the Seanad. For the thousands of families affected by Lyme disease in Ireland, the lack of public recognition, as well as the lack of accurate testing and clinical diagnostic skills here in Ireland, has left patients with this condition unsupported and open to accusations of hypochondria by Doctors and family members alike. The disease can be fatal, but the highest number of fatalities from this disease are due to suicides, as a consequence of lack of recognition, support and medical treatment. The International Association of Lyme and Associated Diseases (ILADS) are a professional body of expert medical practitioners pro-active in helping to educate Doctors and through their educational arm are happy to consult, educate and lecture all over the world. I applaud the suggestion that patients be allowed and encouraged to consult with experts abroad with the support of our own system, as this is how positive change will happen, and those suffering today will find the competent and respectful care that is unobtainable presently in Ireland. Thank you.
Lisa Vandegrift Davala

Log in or join to post a public comment.