David Norris (Independent)

I had not intended to take part in this debate because I must go to a lecture on the erosion of human rights inside America by the US Government of President Bush. That lecture is not until 7 p.m. so I have time to say a few words and to vote.

This is a very important debate. It is a little dreary when people read prepared statements supplied by Departments. There is some slight evidence that may have been happening in the House today. Important issues are involved. I am somewhat divided between the two sides of the argument. I see merits in the motion itself because the abolition of the first-time buyer's grant is something that worries young people coming into the market. On the other hand this cushioned developers. When they saw it they snaffled it and – I am rather fond of this word so I will use it for the second time today in the House – trousered it themselves. There may be an argument for removing the grant.