Joe Costello (Dublin Central, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context

It is extraordinary that the State Pathologist, Dr. Marie Cassidy's entitlement to a Garda-driven car has been withdrawn due to cutbacks in the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform. The State Pathologist is the most important person involved in the investigation of crimes of homicide. She is the forensic scientist who must examine the body and the scene of the crime before it is disturbed by the elements or other interference. It is essential that she can reach the scene in the shortest possible time to conduct a thorough examination.

A successful criminal prosecution often depends on the State Pathologist's report. It is unconscionable that the Government would compel her to drive hundreds of miles to the four corners of the country, night or day to conduct a detailed, complex examination of the crime scene which must stand up in court, and then drive home again. She might need to drive a considerable distance again the following day.

There are 73 gardaí attached to the ministerial driving pool at a cost of €5 million. Although that number of gardaí is available to Ministers, some judges, the Government Chief Whip, the Ceann Comhairle, the Attorney General, the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Chief Justice and former Taoisigh and Presidents, the Government cannot find the funds to provide one extra driver for the State Pathologist.

The investigation of the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier was severely damaged and probably completely stymied because of a 24-hour delay in examining the crime scene. This Government always gets its priorities wrong but to implement this planned cutback from tomorrow, Friday 29 April, would be disastrous. It would be disastrous in the investigation of a murder, the most serious crime. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform must reverse this decision and ensure the necessary funding is made available to provide the State Pathologist with the necessary transport to carry out her duties efficiently.

Our society has changed dramatically in recent years. It is almost impossible to travel even a short distance because of the number of cars and other vehicles on the roads. To expect that the State Pathologist could conduct her business properly without access to a Garda driver is unimaginable. It is gross negligence on the part of the Government if it does not ensure that the funds are made available to enable her to perform her duties properly.

Brian Lenihan Jnr (Dublin West, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I am replying on behalf of my colleague, the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, Deputy McDowell. I thank Deputy Costello for raising the matter and for giving the Minister the opportunity to clarify the position on this issue.

The Minister is fully aware of the demanding and complex work carried out by the State pathologists and pays a special tribute to their professionalism and dedication. Much of our attention is drawn to high profile murder cases but pathologists are also involved on a daily basis in sensitive situations which are of great significance for next of kin but which rarely come into focus. They also fulfil an advisory and educational role which is of considerable value to key parties in the criminal justice and medical areas.

The Minister is well aware that the role of forensic pathology in criminal investigations has become more significant but also more onerous over time as the medical, procedural and legal issues arising have developed. It is precisely against this background that the position of deputy State pathologist was established and, as the Deputy is aware, the current State pathologist was the first holder of that post.

The Deputy may not, however, be aware that it had never been the practice to provide Garda transport to the State pathologist on a full-time basis. As a wholly exceptional measure during the recent period when the State pathologist did not have a deputy to assist her, Garda transport was made available in recognition of the additional demands placed on her as a result of the deputy vacancy.

Other arrangements were also put in place to assist her at that time, in particular the provision of relief cover whereby two pathologists were retained on a fee per case basis. These pathologists, who were based in the south and midlands of the country, were able to reduce the burden on the main office-holder, especially in cases outside the Dublin area. The Minister understands that this facility is still available today should it be of assistance in managing the overall caseload or in minimising the impact of travelling. The Minister is pleased to say that a new deputy pathologist was appointed last November and, as such, the workload and travel can once again be shared.

It is against this background, the Minister understands, that the Garda authorities reviewed the need to provide an on-demand Garda transport facility. This appears to him not to be a question of cutbacks, as has been widely reported, but rather a return to the long-standing position in recognition of the fact that the circumstances which gave rise to the need for special transport arrangements no longer apply. The House will be aware that the Garda is better resourced in terms of financial and personnel resources than ever before. In so far as the separate financial provision for the State pathology service is concerned, this has been increased by 5% in 2005 over 2004.

The Minister further understands that the Garda authorities have indicated a willingness to assist the pathologists in cases of special need and have no reason to believe that this will not meet future requirements. The Garda authorities are well placed to assess when a potential investigation would justify making such special arrangements. The Minister intends to keep this matter, as well as all aspects of the State pathology service, under ongoing review.

Joe Costello (Dublin Central, Labour)
Link to this: Individually | In context

That is not very helpful.