Holly Cairns (Cork South West, Social Democrats) | Oireachtas source

I am still unaware of what information the Minister has had since being in opposition that explains the change of heart on this issue. Convergence is just one issue that represents the lack of clarity that farmers are facing. Those on small farms in the west are concerned that the new CAP will threaten the agricultural status of their land. The Minister says this gives flexibility but farmers do not want flexibility regarding the status of their land; they want certainty. The Irish Cattle And Sheep Farmers' Association, ICSA, is calling for all farmers to be treated equally concerning land eligibility and conditionality, and the IFA is having regional meetings this week to inform its members. The dissatisfaction with REAP and the limited places are also symptomatic of this issue.

The new CAP will affect not only the lives of thousands of farming families but will also shape our landscape over the next decade. It is essential that the Minister presents his position to the House throughout the negotiations. I do not understand why we do not vote on the positions the Minister takes to Europe. I am new to this House but these are very important decisions and there is no scrutiny. It is disgraceful that so little time has been given to these issues. Farmers in rural areas deserve more respect. I ask that the Minister would give a real answer in regard to his change of heart.

See this speech in context