Enda Kenny (Mayo, Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

I thank the Deputy for raising this as it is a serious matter. It is a sensitive issue because it refers to parents and the birth of children. Yesterday the Minister publicly affirmed the absolute independence of HIQA. The letters from the HSE to which the Deputy referred have, according to Mr. Tony O'Brien, been published on its website and speak for themselves. It is regrettable that this has taken place in this fashion. It is not the first time that agencies of the State have taken legal action against each other. In the closing paragraph of the HSE letter it is stated that it will withdraw from what it calls the "extraordinary position" of having to seek advice of counsel in respect of going to court. The Minister has intervened to say it is not appropriate that taxpayers' money should be used to settle a row between two agencies of State. I am glad that, following a meeting last week, a way forward has been found. As I said, the Minister has affirmed the absolute independence of HIQA and a way has been found to deal with this matter which involves sitting down and working it out. I cannot indicate when the report will be published. It would be wrong to publish what is currently a draft report, but the matter needs to be dealt with taking into account the responsibilities of the HSE, the independence of HIQA and the requirement to send a report to the Minister which he will receive, consider and publish.

See this speech in context