Timmy Dooley (Clare, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I will get into the generality of it. I thank the committee for giving me an opportunity to discuss with it the opportunities that exist based on the sustainability impact assessment that is being carried out by ICES. Over the coming month to month and a half, I, together with departmental officials, will engage with the Commission and other member states to address the challenges set out therein.

Since we are going to stick to the narrow focus, the issue of greatest concern for the year ahead is the significant advice we have received regarding a number of species within what might be termed pelagic stock. The scientific advice that would indicate the necessity of having a reduction in the total allowable catch of mackerel of over 70%, of 42% of blue whiting and around 20% of boarfish sends shockwaves and shivers through the industry, particularly in pelagic stock - not just the fleet owners or those involved in the catching sector but in the processing sector as well. When I appeared before this committee previously, we discussed the challenges the industry faces. I have used every opportunity available to me since appointment to challenge the orthodoxy that has existed heretofore. It is clear that the unilateral setting of quota by certain coastal states, particularly Norway, the Faroes and Iceland, is unsustainable. We are sadly reaping the reward for a laissez-faireapproach to that particular practice. We have seen a very significant reduction in biomass with the impact this will have on our industry. I have called out Norway in the past and will continue to do so.

On 3 November 2025, the Commission on behalf of the EU will begin negotiations with Norway. The mandate for the Commission in these discussions is being discussed by member states at the Council working party. I have taken a very strong line on this and have instructed our officials to make it clear that Ireland cannot accept a business as usual approach with Norway. The actions of Norway as well as those of the Faroes and Iceland have contributed to the situation in which we find ourselves with regard to mackerel. The EU must take that into account in any fisheries agreement with Norway and we must take a very strong and stern approach.

There are other advices that will come towards the end of this month that will have an impact on nephrops or prawns. Our whitefish stocks have also seen reductions. The very significant negative advice on the pelagic stocks that are most important to Ireland will have a very significant impact on the industry and is one I cannot underestimate. I am happy to engage with members regarding that.