Mr. John Cuddy:

I was surprised to hear there were ongoing issues regarding notice of inspections. Deputy McConalogue said farmers had not been notified of inspections and penalties had been applied. Deputy Martin Kenny mentioned the O'Connor case. Mr. Justice Michael White was critical of the Department's failure to apply the farmers' charter and said notice and inspection documentation should be provided to farmers. In our presentation we have suggested that all decision-making documentation be provided to farmers as early as possible. The reason we are seeking this is so a farmer can make an informed decision as to whether to pursue an appeal, if it is necessary. In light of the O'Connor case and the negotiations we have had with the Department, it surprises me that the Department has continued not to notify farmers of various reductions. It is worrying in the circumstances.