Dr. Andrew Cromie:

That is a concern and it is very justified. The view we are taking is that we will communicate constantly with farmers on their standing under the scheme. It may require some interaction with Teagasc or advisers so additional advice for the farmer may be provided. Our goal is not only to ensure every farmer reaches the targets of 20% and 50% but also to ensure farmers have as many four-star and five-star animals as possible as they work their way through the scheme.

Ultimately, this is what will drive profitability and sustainability on farms. It is certainly a process of constant communication throughout the scheme and our goal is that farmers will meet and exceed the requirements. The specific point on artificial insemination is very relevant. Can we indicate that a bull is proven? We publish an active beef bull list which indicates only proven maternal artificial insemination bulls, those which have daughters with milk and fertility evaluations. The suggestion that it be clearly stamped or indicated on an artificial insemination catalogue has been considered and discussed, and it has much merit.