Ms Eimear Costello:

As the only MEP present, I also want to thank Deputy Lucinda Creighton for the work she did as Minister of State with responsibility for European affairs and during the Irish Presidency. She was very highly regarded by MEPs from all political groups. She spent a lot of time travelling the length and breadth of Europe but she also spent a lot of time in the European Parliament, talking to MEPs and understanding the issues facing them. On one occasion she spent 11 hours in our hemicycle, which deserves much thanks. That was a task of endurance in itself.

I congratulate the Minister of State, Deputy Paschal Donohoe. I served with him on Dublin City Council and I know he will make an excellent Minister of State.