Alan Kelly (Tipperary, Labour) | Oireachtas source

Let me finish my question. I am asking the Department here and now to provide that information to the Charlton tribunal and I cannot understand why it would not do it anyway because the terms of reference, which were read out by Deputy Clare Daly or others, actually require this and the request from Mr. Justice Charlton requests this information as well. I disagree with Ms McPhillips shaking her head. Mr. Justice Charlton made a fairly blunt statement asking anyone who had any information to provide it. It makes me very nervous - extremely nervous - that representatives from the Department are sitting here today and are still blanking and saying the Department will not provide that information voluntarily.