Seanad debates

Wednesday, 17 April 2024

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters

Schools Building Projects

10:30 am

Photo of Lorraine Clifford-LeeLorraine Clifford-Lee (Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I am sorry to have to raise this Commencement matter because the issue is an ongoing one. Rush National School is a school in north County Dublin that was built in 1953 and now has 700 pupils. Morgan Doran is the principal and runs an excellent school. It has served untold numbers of people from Rush and it is an excellent school. Plans have been afoot to build a new school on the site for in excess of 17 years. This would be a 32-classroom school with two autism classrooms and all the ancillary rooms needed for a modern fit-for-purpose school.

The campaign was started by the former principal Margaret Dobinson and the board of management 17 years ago. When Morgan Doran took over as principal, the chairman of the board of management, Peter Conway, continued this campaign. Approval was obtained for this building development in 2010 and planning permission was granted in 2013. It has been renewed in the interim but, unfortunately, planning permission expired on 8 December 2023. There has been no correspondence from the Department of Education for more than a year. The last piece of correspondence was dated 14 April 2023. The board of management has made numerous attempts to engage the Department to see what steps it should take next. The expiring of planning permission was looming. The board of management had no correspondence. Nobody from the Department would engage.

It is very frustrating given this has been an ongoing issue for 17 years. The school is way oversubscribed with a very long waiting list. The building dates from 1953 and is damp, cold and not fit for purpose. The teachers are working and children are being educated in appalling conditions and they all deserve better. The children are getting a very good education there. There is great community spirit, the people of Rush are very invested in the school and school staff are excellent and dedicated, but it is not acceptable that such conditions are continuing and the Department is not engaging.

I held off raising this Commencement matter because the school wants to engage in a constructive way and move the project on but we feel there is no other solution. The school must re-apply for planning permission. It needs direction from the Department regarding the termination of the current tender procedure, but it is not getting that from the Department. The board of management under the stewardship of Peter Conway is very frustrated and does not know what steps it needs to take next. Local authority planning guidelines have changed since the date the school first got planning permission, so it has to change the design but it cannot proceed with that either until it gets engagement from the Department. Meanwhile the years fly by. The school cannot put any autism classes in place, which is a source of great frustration to the school management because it wants to serve everybody in the community. Unfortunately, it cannot offer school places to some members of families because they need special autism education. This is not an acceptable position to be in. The population of Rush is in excess of 11,000 and is expanding rapidly. There are many large-scale building projects in the town. The school cannot facilitate it. There are not enough school places. North County Dublin is absorbing the housing needs of Dublin, and Rush is no exception. We are getting thousands of houses. We have no problem with that. We are not objecting to housing because we all know we need it, but we need the public infrastructure to go along with housing. Schools are the top priority. We need buses. We need the metro. We need services delivered for north County Dublin and for Rush. Planning approval for the St. Maur's site next to the school as a temporary play site while construction takes place expires in March 2026, so this really needs to get moving. I appeal to the Minister of State to get the Department to engage with the board of management and get this project going.

Photo of Malcolm NoonanMalcolm Noonan (Carlow-Kilkenny, Green Party)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I thank Senator Clifford-Lee for putting it so well regarding the challenges faced by a strong and growing community in Rush in north County Dublin and the challenges faced by the school. Seventeen years is a long time to wait for this school to be developed.Members of the board have had great patience and tenacity. The school is watching in on this Commencement matter today. For the principal, Mr. Morgan Doran, managing a school of 700 pupils with growing demand in this area, it is vital that the project now proceeds.

The major building project for Rush National School is included in the Department of Education's construction programme which is being delivered under the national development plan. The project brief includes the demolition of the existing single-storey Rush National School building and removal of existing temporary accommodation and construction of a new two-storey building on the same site. The project brief includes 32 classrooms, two classrooms for children with special educational needs, a general purpose hall and ancillary accommodation. External works include a new boundary treatment, landscaping, staff car parking area, ball courts, play areas, bicycle storage, bin storage and ancillary work. This is a very exciting project for this important school.

A tender report was received from the design team in 2023 and was reviewed by the Department. In the course of this review it was noted that the planning permission was due to expire in December 2023 and a new planning permission application would be required. The Department is liaising with the design team in relation to the requirements of the new planning permission and the design team held a pre-planning meeting with Fingal County Council very recently in March 2024. The due diligence by the Department of Education is a critical part of the overall completion of the stage 3 process and is critical to ensuring quality and value for money. The projects are progressed within the overall programme parameters. In response to the Senator, progress may feel slow but it is progressing. There is hope for optimism that it will progress given the most recent meeting in March. I hope it will go to planning and construction as soon as possible.

Photo of Lorraine Clifford-LeeLorraine Clifford-Lee (Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context

I thank the Minister of State for that update. Can we get somebody within the Department actually to liaise with the school? That information was not communicated to the board of management. It is operating in a vacuum and obviously has to report back to the parents and the whole community as to what is going on. However, when no communication is going back that is a frustrating situation for the board.

There is a bit of progress but this school project needs to be put on a fast track. It is unacceptable to wait for 17 years, considering the population demands. All schools have difficulties in retaining staff, particularly in Dublin. The Department expects staff to work in a building that is crumbling around them and is cold and damp in the winter. They patch up windows before they can teach a class in the morning. The Minister of State will understand the challenges that the principal is dealing with. We need to have somebody in the Department who will stay in contact. I realise they are busy people but this school and this community have waited long enough and they deserve better.

Photo of Malcolm NoonanMalcolm Noonan (Carlow-Kilkenny, Green Party)
Link to this: Individually | In context

Since 2020 the Department of Education has invested in the region of €4.3 billion in our schools throughout the country, involving the completion of more than 800 school building projects with construction currently under way at approximately 300 other projects including 34 new school buildings. These 300 projects currently under construction involve a total State investment of €1.2 billion. More than 90 projects are currently at tender stage including a further 28 new school buildings. All of these new school buildings are flagship projects in their area and transform the educational infrastructure of their communities.

I agree wholeheartedly with the Senator. I will ask the Minister to have direct engagement between the school and Department officials, because 17 years is far too long to wait. Great credit is due to the principal, Mr. Morgan Doran, to his staff and the board for their tenacity. It is important that this project proceeds as soon as is practical once all elements of the design process have been completed.

I will certainly take this to the Minister.