Michael McDowell (Independent) | Oireachtas source

The problem is that the Minister does this by statutory instrument. Frequently these Houses are not in a position to adequately understand the rationale behind a statutory instrument before it is made. Having an annual report is a good idea and should be acceptable to the Minister. If she has made changes to the list of safe countries, we should have an annual report on Ireland's approach and why particular decisions have been made. If, for example, Senator Higgins disagreed with a particular designation, she would need to table a motion to reverse the statutory instrument and negative the Minister's decision. This proposal simply asks for an annual explanation of any changes that have occurred in the designation of safe countries during that period. As it does not apply to EU countries, there is no embarrassment there. The rule of law issues that are now arising within the EU are another day's work. I still think the amendment is reasonable.