Frances Black (Independent) | Oireachtas source

There is no doubt that it is now more apparent than ever that we have an urgent need to introduce hate crime legislation in Ireland. I say "Well done" to Senator O'Loughlin for introducing it. We need to protect all minority groups in Ireland.It is essential that the silence is broken on these crimes and people actively report racism and other hate attacks in order to address and stop their occurrence. Freedom of expression should never extend to hate crimes and Irish people need to accept that.

It is great to see Senator O'Loughlin show an interest in the area of hate crime and share her views on the topic. Like others, I fear there are a number of gaps in the Bill in terms of affording protections to all minority groups. It does not extensively cover the proposed areas of protection included in the 2016 Bill. It is paramount we craft this Bill with everyone in mind so that nobody's existence is undermined or forgotten. Legislation, particularly where penalties are involved, must also be legally clear. For example, there is an important difference between a hate crime offence and hate as a factor in defining the crime. Different approaches to this have been taken in different legislation, including the Bill we are debating.

I am aware that my colleagues, Senators Flynn and Ruane, have been actively working in the area of hate crime legislation for a number of years and have consulted and engaged with non-governmental organisations and activists dedicated to hate crime legislation. It is great to see support on this issue among many politicians across the House, including Senator O’Loughlin. The Bill features very important points which will be considered by Senators Ruane and Flynn as they continue in their commitment to creating hate crime legislation that will afford adequate protections to every member of society.