Thomas Byrne (Fianna Fail) | Oireachtas source

If my amendment were not within the scope of the Bill, it would have been disallowed by the Cathaoirleach.

I reject the argument that it is not relevant because it is not strictly a valuation issue. It is very relevant. The connection between valuation and payment, and the operation of businesses and the ability to make payments based on the valuation is entirely connected. We are proposing a reasonable provision to include some sort of ability to pay clause. I understand that such a provision exists in the United Kingdom. Why can we not have one here? Has the Department considered this issue? On the last occasion we discussed it with either the former Minister of State at the Department of Finance, Brian Hayes, MEP, or the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Howlin, there was an indication that the issue would be investigated. I understand that the revenue implications need to be carefully considered but this is a serious issue. Rates create a significant cost for businesses and are probably the highest fixed cost after rent. It is possible to renegotiate the rent and reduce staffing and pay costs but businesses cannot change their rates bill. The reality is that many county councils are not collecting rates because people simply cannot pay them. One might think the country is coming out of recession but the unemployment rate is still over 11%. A considerable number of people are struggling and the Government should give serious consideration to this amendment because it responds to a need that I am sure has been expressed to the Minister of State in his constituency clinics.