Sean Barrett (Independent) | Oireachtas source

This is a very important amendment proposed by our colleagues, Senators Ó Clochartaigh and Cullinane. It is to be inserted in page 15, between lines 9 and 10, where the general heading is "Directions of Minister". I am worried about this aspect without a freedom of information context. Thus, if a Minister says "I want it built in my constituency" or "I want X,Y and Z pipes to be used in it", people should know this. That is why freedom of information is important. The Bill states: "Irish Water shall comply with a direction given to it." Are we going to allow it to respond in any way other than touching the forelock? The Bill also states: "The Minister shall not give a direction ... without first consulting the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources." I would prefer that the entire Cabinet was consulted. Incorporeal Cabinet meetings cost us a lot of money in 2008. The sort of dictatorial elements in the directions of the Minister require ventilation, and I believe freedom of information is most useful in this regard. I am happy to support the amendment.