David Cullinane (Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

I wish to raise with the Minister of State the issue of district metering.

In an earlier response based on information from one of his officials, the Minister of State stated there are district metering systems in the State. He is right as this is the case. While such metering does not extend across all local authorities, we do have such a system in place. As I stated previously, it is the most effective way to measure wastage and usage in the system and I would much prefer to see that than to see the introduction of domestic meters. One authority that has this system in place is Laois County Council. That model has proven itself to be a much better way to do this. Spikes in usage can be observed and can then be better rectified. This allows for the pinpointing of leaks across the system, which is important if one is trying to reduce waste in the system.

Essentially, whatever view one might have about water charges or even the setting up of Uisce Éireann, all Members desire the most efficient management of the water system. Whatever about Members' views on the charges, they all desire to have the best use made of our water, as well as water conservation. However, in respect of management, the pinpointing of leaks and ensuring the huge amount of leakage within the system is dealt with in the best way possible, I believe district metering to be better than domestic metering. Sometimes, debates like this are false because while the Minister might assert that domestic is better and I might respond by suggesting district metering was better, we often lack the requisite reports and analysis to enable us to share equally, discuss and debate the matter in the context of bringing forward this legislation. Perhaps it is a weakness within the legislative system that so doing is not part of it and that such assessments are not carried out when sought by legislators to inform them when making the decisions. Best practice should be considered, where possible, and based on the research my party and I have done and on foot of information we have received from the Oireachtas Library and Research Service, my understanding is that district metering is a very good system. I already have cited the example of Laois County Council. I will not labour the point because Members wish to deal with all the Bill's sections and amendments. In fairness, the Minister of State has been very good in responding to them. I expect the Minister of State has taken on board my comments, even if he does not agree.