Martin McAleese (Independent)

I want to record my support for this proposal to amend Standing Order 18, as recommended by the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. As we have heard, it entails 30 seconds of silent reflection prior to the recitation of the Christian prayer at the commencement of Seanad sittings. We know of one person - I suspect there are more - who would prefer to dispense with the Christian prayer completely on the basis that it fails to accord equality, tolerance, respect and recognition to all beliefs. However strongly felt those feelings may be, this would have been a mistake. Equality, tolerance and respect do not requires us to abandon any aspects of our identity or traditions, or even to wash out those things which make us distinct. In fact, it was that kind of either-or thinking which made it so difficult, if not impossible, to find peace on this island for so long. It was only when all traditions were guaranteed respect and felt respected that peace took root and slowly began to grow.

Looking at what happens in other parliaments, we can find examples to argue both for and against opening prayers. Therefore, we cannot really look outside own experience and judgment for guidance. We have a Christian tradition on this island that stretches back almost 1,600 years. It is part of what has defined us and it is stitched into our very language with every greeting in the Irish language, and often too in English, still referencing this Christian heritage. Similarly, placenames throughout Ireland abound with references to saints, as well as to churches and other Christian landmarks. At home and abroad the Christian faith has sustained many generations through life's capricious ups and downs.

I want to make it absolutely clear, however, that my reference to our Christian tradition embraces all the Christian denominations which have created and enriched our heritage, and not simply the majority tradition. We should always be proud and should certainly not be ashamed or afraid to express that rich Christian tradition in any place and particularly here in the national Parliament. However, in a spirit of respect and equality, I fully support the addition of 30 seconds of silent reflection prior to the prayer. While reflecting our tradition, this allows us to make space for those who are not Christians, but of other faiths or indeed of no faith. What is being proposed allows us to advance the inclusivity of this Chamber.

I agree with Senator Byrne that we could go further and indeed I think we should. We could become leaders in tolerance by, for example, as Senator Byrne suggested, exploring with generosity ways of incorporating prayers from other faith traditions from time to time, perhaps on occasions of special moment to those traditions. The prayer said here to date was never designed to offend but rather to conscientiously dedicate our best efforts each day to the service of the people. Today's proposal will enhance this Chamber simply by having more of that dedication. It offers the prospect both of respecting tradition and creating a new tradition alongside so that in the end this House is truly a place where all are respected.

Should the Cathaoirleach not be responsible for reading the prayer, as is the case in the other House where the Ceann Comhairle does so?

I commend the Committee on Procedure and Privileges on the sensitive way in which it has dealt with this issue.