Phil Hogan (Carlow-Kilkenny, Fine Gael)

Fianna Fáil is also against the introduction of provisions to protect groundwater, public health and the environment. That is the implication of what the Senators propose. They have a brass neck to even raise the issue. To be fair to Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, he accepted on Committee Stage in the Dáil that it was necessary to provide for offences. I, therefore, suggest the Senators speak to him in order that they will be consistent about Fianna Fáil party policy in this regard.

In response to Senator Trevor Ó Clochartaigh, while the legislation will introduce offences where a person fails to meet its requirements, a request to provide a valid certificate of registration or contravenes the requirements of an advisory notice, I am satisfied that the proposed penalties are proportionate and fair. There has been scaremongering in recent months about the legislation, including in the Senator's own area. It has been suggested armies of inspectors will descend on the countryside, even though I have already stated local authority staff will be the inspectors. The Bill and the new inspection system will not alleviate or deal with any of the scenarios trotted out. I know it makes a good political story, but I ask what system is in place in Northern Ireland, in which Sinn Féin is involved. What system has been introduced and what is it costing each householder? The cost is €150 and one gets one free desludge. Fianna Fáil say we should not bother to do this.