Sean Barrett (Independent)

I wish to raise two issues. The comprehensive public expenditure review will only be published within two working days of the announcement of the budget. I echo what Senator Mary Ann O'Brien said that this is what should inform our discussion rather than letting it be turned into a hectoring session. The review will provide valuable information. I understand the opposition to its publication comes from people in the permanent government rather than from the Cabinet. If this vital document is available, it should be supplied to parliamentarians to allow them to have the structured debate for which Senatord Mary Ann O'Brien called.

Reports today suggest VHI which is technically bankrupt is thinking of buying one of its rivals. We need a competitive health insurance business, not one which is monopolistic. The Leader has impressed on the Minister for Health, Deputy James Reilly, the need to ensure the design and development of a health insurance business take place in a period less than the five years the Minister seems to think is appropriate. We need it now and should not make the mistake of running along monopolistic lines. Previous advice from VHI led to defeats for the Government in the Supreme Court and the European Court. It is important we have a competitive health insurance business quickly.