Thomas Byrne (Fianna Fail)

I doubt very much that the Minister of State, Deputy Lynch, gave the speech huge thought because she is not the type of person to state such things and I acknowledge this. However, it is open to me to criticise her for past actions when she speaks on this matter because many of us would never have done what she did.

The Bill has many flaws but this side of the House is willing to support it and let it pass Second Stage. If it comes before us on Committee Stage, Fianna Fáil will suggest substantial amendments. We believe that under no circumstances should somebody contact the Garda or the DPP and in most cases contact should not be made with the courts. However, we believe circumstances do exist where private representations can be made with regard to the humane treatment of prisoners and other issues.

Many of the representations made by Oireachtas Members are subject to freedom of information legislation and it is possible to find out what representations we have made. It is likely the relevant Department or agency would hide information relating to the personal details of the person when releasing information under freedom of information legislation.

It is possible to pass Private Members' legislation, but the Government has not done so yet in the Seanad and I challenge Government Members on this. When the Minister of State, Deputy Brian Hayes, came to the house to debate the Family Home Bill he stated the Government was not responsible for Private Members' business in the Seanad and that Members could vote in accordance with what they believed. They did not do so on that occasion. I urge them to do so today. We must give the impression that we are open, transparent and above approach. As the Provost of Trinity College stated recently, point an accusing finger at me and I will answer. This is the right approach for anyone in a position of power or authority.

We should acknowledge that Senator Crown has presented the Bill with serious intent. Do not insult him for bringing forward serious work. Let the Bill pass Second Stage and bring forward amendments. If the Bill passes Second Stage, Fianna Fáil will table substantial amendments on Committee Stage. We support the Bill and urge the Government parties to do so also.