David Norris (Independent)

I share the concerns expressed about the operation of the guillotine. This is not the first time we have had a guillotine in this Parliament. Historically, the Leader of the House, Senator Cummins, has shared those concerns. I assume that proper and sufficient reason will be given for the use of the guillotine and that it will not become a practice.

A couple of people described each other as excitable today. I do not think I am excitable today, but I am a little disappointed that there is so much political point-scoring going on. That is unhelpful. We need the Government to come up with constructive proposals. It is important that we have a clear, strong and constructive Opposition. That is how Parliament works. In the situation this House is in, it is important that we maintain its dignity. We should make our points appropriately and in a restrained way. I have not always held to this maxim myself, but I will certainly do my best. The fate of this House hangs in the balance.