Joe O'Reilly (Fine Gael)

It is not in conflict with the Minister of State's ambition to see An Post compete and adapt to the market place; there is no incompatibility here. The amendments enshrine in this legislation that whoever delivers the service, private or public, there is a legislative imperative to do so with regard to cost, efficiency, universal delivery and low pricing. I do not see the difficulty; surely putting that prerequisite in the legislation will enhance the possibility that all service providers will do it. Extending the term would make it viable for An Post to plan and adapt. As Senator Hanafin said, the profit margin would suggest that such an extension is necessary.

I cannot see how our position is incompatible; all we want to do is give legislative effect to the stated objective of the Minister. If the Minister is truly committed to the stated objective, he should accept these amendments or bring in alternative amendments to achieve the same objectives on Report Stage.