Joe O'Toole (Independent)

I thank the Minister for his comprehensive reply and do not doubt his commitment to his argument. I do not propose to press the amendment. However, I ask the Minister to give consideration to my argument. I will read the primary legislation before Report Stage to ascertain if it provides leeway to act in the manner he described.

Every morning the Cathaoirleach reads out a list of matters that Senators have raised for discussion on the Adjournment. Certain restrictions apply as regards what issues may be discussed, for example, a Minister must have responsibility for the matter raised. The acid test for me with regard to my amendment is that the Cathaoirleach must not be able to state the Minister does not have responsibility for a matter a Member raises in connection with a directive issued by the commission. That will answer my question because it establishes the benchmark. On that basis, I ask the Minister to give the amendment some consideration. If he concludes it is possible to provide for a degree of amelioration or softening of the text, I ask him to propose an amendment on Report Stage. In the interests of making progress, I withdraw the amendment.