Alex White (Labour)

The issue in this case is not the separation of powers but the right of citizens to representation. Senator Fitzgerald is absolutely correct that it is extraordinary that people must go to the High Court. Members constantly argue in the House that the power of the courts is too great, but citizens are being forced to go to the courts to have their right to representation vindicated. That is extraordinary. One could not reasonably disagree with a single point Senator Fitzgerald made in this regard.

With regard to the debate that took place last night which is relevant as the House looks to its future, the question of reform of the Seanad, as opposed to its abolition, has been debated here and in the media. After the debate last night, there is no question but that the reform option is rapidly running out of road.