Billy Kelleher (Cork North Central, Fianna Fail)

For that reason, I believe one should try to put forward a view of confidence and optimism, even in these challenging times. One should state quite clearly to the small and medium-sized business sector, the trade union movement and all the country's stakeholders that it is possible to get through these challenging times by pulling together as well as addressing and facing up to the reality of our present position. Moreover, political parties also have an obligation in this regard. There is no painless way out of the present difficulties and everyone must shoulder a certain element of the burden. Obviously, a political party or a Government would wish to ensure those who can carry the most will do so and the most vulnerable will be protected as best as possible. Those who spread myths and fantasy to the effect that there is an easy or painless way to address our problems do a disservice to themselves and, more importantly, do a great disservice to the people and to the honesty of a debate that is required on how we should face up to challenges and obligations as a Government, as a Parliament, as political parties and as a people. I commend the amendment tabled by Senator Carty. I take into account the views expressed by Opposition Members. As the Minister, Deputy Batt O'Keeffe, stated last week, this proposal has not been dismissed but is being analysed and examined. Other issues must be taken into account, however, to ensure we do not simply replace one form of credit with another, thereby simply putting the burden back on the taxpayer.