Pearse Doherty (Sinn Fein)

I may not have indicated properly that I wished to contribute earlier. Unlike Senator O'Toole in his comments that he had a good guess as to the Minister's reply, I did not. This amendment makes sense. Having listened to the full debate it is clear that as far back as 2002 the Government wanted to see it happen. I agree that the Minister's argument makes sense as to bringing in the tax exemption after the legislation. However, there is no reason this could not work in reverse. The amendment could be introduced so that everything is done when the legislation comes forward and we are not waiting until this time next year to introduce a new finance Bill to amend legislation introduced this year. I agree with Senator O'Toole. We should show courage and leadership. It is also very frustrating when people see the wheels of Government turning so slowly. I refer to the high costs of motor insurance which is an issue close to my heart. This is a sensible solution and I ask the Minister to consider supporting Senator O'Toole's amendment.