Feargal Quinn (Independent)

I declared my interest on Second Stage in that I was a member of the Ward Union Hunt 20 years ago and I have received requests from its members to make a case on their behalf. They make a strong case that the hunting lobby was consulted, including themselves, and they understood they had a commitment from the former Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Roche, and the current Minister but they now understand they have been let down.

There is concern that names and addresses of members will be published but there is a virulent anti-hunting lobby which has, in the past, behaved in a threatening and unacceptable manner and names should not be published on that basis.

The debate highlights that the Government should reconsider its proposal. Senator Norris is not enthusiastic about hunting but the issue raised by his constituent to which he referred is worthy of consideration. Kennels for hunt hounds were excluded in similar legislation in the UK and Northern Ireland. I can understand why the Government has included rather than excluded them but there is a difference between breeding dogs for hunting, which many may not approve of, and breeding puppies for sale, which is a serious problem, and that is why I support the general theme of the legislation.

There is a need for this legislation but it must go through in a way that is accepted. Anti-hunting legislation is likely to be introduced because the Green Party is determined to do so. Subsidiarity is a European Union concept. However, subsidiarity could be provided for in this legislation because decisions on such issues should be made at local level and individual county councils could make a decision for their area. If the people of Dublin do not want hunting, then there will not be hunting in Dublin. I doubt if there will be anyway but if the people of Meath or Kildare say it is a rural tradition that they would like to maintain, the local authorities can decide to ensure that happens. Hunt clubs should be excluded from the legislation and, therefore, I support the amendment.