Phil Prendergast (Labour)

I am concluding on this point. The long, narrow Carlow-Kilkenny-south Tipperary mental health area is geographically unsuitable. There is no allowance made for new motorway systems or thought put into patient convenience or preferences. Areas in north Tipperary very close to Clonmel – for example, Thurles and Templemore - are excluded. The road to Kilkenny is unsuitable. The hospital in Kilkenny is also not suitable for servicing the needs of the people of south Tipperary. The outlay to make St. Michael's Hospital suitable to meet modern requirements would be trivial by comparison with the ultimate dangers for patients and the difficulties faced by relatives and staff. There has been a huge outcry and people are seriously concerned. I cannot underestimate that aspect of the matter.

I ask that the Minister of State suspend any decision pending detailed consultation, costings and submissions from stakeholders in County Tipperary. I spoke to the staff. I declare an interest in that-----