Larry Butler (Fianna Fail)

I would like to make a couple of points about carer's allowance which is probably one of the payments for which we are getting real value for money. In recent years we have been very generous to carers who do a fantastic job by keeping people out of hospitals and nursing homes. When things get better, we should look after them by providing for an increase in the allowance once more.

We are in difficult economic times. Social welfare is very important, but somebody has to pay for it. It is clear that we cannot continue to borrow as we have been doing. Tax receipts have decreased and we have to shrink the economy to 2003 levels. We must consider this budget in the context of the last three, rather than in isolation. The Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, has said "the worst is over". I think he is right. I believe there will be a small upturn in the middle of next year. We will automatically pick up as soon as the US, UK and various European economies pick up. As an exporting country, that will help us. The more we can export, the better. We have to be export-led from here on. We have to drive down costs in an economical manner. Although they are being driven down, it is important for the Minister to bring the message back to the Cabinet that certain sectors of the community are not playing their part. Many doctors and dentists are continuing to charge high rates. The various charges imposed on businesses by local authorities also need to be examined. I refer, in particular, to rates and water charges, etc. Such matters will have to be addressed if the economy is to get moving again and if we are to be economically viable and able to compete. I thank the Minister and the Cathaoirleach.