Eugene Regan (Fine Gael)

The Minister's reply is predictable, particularly in the context of our previous discussion on the matter. There is no question that the victims' charter is comprehensive. If its provisions are implemented in an effective manner, the charter can go a long way towards meeting the needs of victims in being provided with information and involved in the criminal prosecution process.

I welcome the fact the Minister has indicated the victims' charter will be reviewed in 2010 because, in many cases, we have a voluntary code and a voluntary system of implementing policy but ultimately, it requires legislation in order that the provisions and policies are effectively implemented. This may come to that.

In regard to the EU Commission and the point about the commitment to implement the provisions of the framework decision, that is the basis on which the amendments tabled by Fine Gael are premised. I do not suggest in tabling these amendments, nor does the framework decision suggest, that information is forced on victims. In all cases, it is premised on the victim wishing to receive and requesting the information, which is the subject matter of the proposed amendments. This would only arise in the case of serious crime. I stand by the amendments and believe we need victims' rights established in legislation. These amendments are designed to do that. That procedure is more in conformity with the requirements of EU legislation than the purely voluntary code the Minister proposes. A review of that code is welcome and we will see at that stage whether victims of crime are satisfied that it is proving effective. I stand by the amendments tabled.