Michael Finneran (Roscommon-South Leitrim, Fianna Fail)

I very much appreciate the heartfelt contributions made by Senator Ryan and the difficulties he and perhaps other Senators have encountered. I do not support the creation of an appeals mechanism, as proposed, because of the workload it would add to An Bord Pleanála. I am conscious of the contributions the Senator has made in this regard not only on this Stage but on Committee Stage. I know they are based on good solid cases. I will try to ascertain, through the Parliamentary Counsel and the Attorney General, if it possible for me to enhance the provisions on the enforcement side. I am not closing the door on anything here. I do not support the proposal on the basis of how it would affect the workload of An Bord Pleanála, but that does not exclude the Parliamentary Counsel from coming up with some solution, if they can, on this matter. Senators will have an opportunity to consider the legislation again in this House and it is possible matter will be teased out in the meantime on Committee Stage in the Dáil. I have been involved in planning for almost 30 years, including 23 years in a local authority and as part of my work in the Department at present. I am conscious of the points made by the Senator of the difficulties that arise and what determines a minor infringement. I take the point also that a planning officer may make a decision which may be considered a delegated responsibility but it may go no further. I will give this matter attention and request that it be examined to determine if a solution is possible without piling a good deal of extra work on An Bord Pleanála. As I remarked earlier, there was 23% efficiency in 2008 and with these revisions I am attempting to reach 50% efficiency by 2010. However, I will consider if we can address this issue one way or another but I am in the hands of the Attorney General and the Parliamentary Counsel.