Donie Cassidy (Fianna Fail)

The Senator asked for a debate on student charges. This could be raised during the budget debate but I have no difficulty allocating time for such a debate. She also called for a debate on mental health and prisons. Senator Corrigan asked for a similar debate and I have agreed this will take place.

Senators Leyden and Mullen called for a debate on the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. Comments were made about asylum seekers and the abuse and disrespect of the human being. I will do anything I can to help in arranging a special debate on the issue. I will liaise with colleagues to see if it can take place before the Christmas recess.

Senator Coffey called for a debate on the Government's waste management policy announced today. I will arrange for that debate to be held and hope it can take place early in the new year.

Senator Walsh called for a debate on the right to life, capital punishment and everything related to that issue. I will have no difficulty in arranging such a debate.

Senators Norris and Buttimer called for a debate on the HSE and the great work done by carers, the unsung heroes of our society. I join the call that we support them in every possible way. They provide great value for money, assist the State and show great respect to senior citizens.

Senator O'Reilly outlined to the House the fact that one in every three restaurants was in danger of closure. I understand 80% of restaurants are losing money. I hope the Minister for Finance will address this in the budget. The restaurant trade is a large employer. The Senator outlined the difficulties being experienced in his own area. I also have much experience and know the importance of competitiveness, whether in wages or the cost of food and electricity. The second largest cost item on a balance sheet used to be insurance. It is now rates. If wages and other costs are being reduced, rates must be reduced also. Everyone is playing his or her part. The issue of rates must be addressed because they are threatening the tourism, leisure and restaurant industries. I agree with the sentiments expressed by my neighbour, Senator O'Reilly.

Senator Buttimer called for a debate on the funding of roads by the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. This is timely and will present a serious and long-term challenge. There will be no difficulty in allocating time for such a debate.

Senator Cummins asked if hospital consultants were doing the job for which they were being paid. He also asked the Minister for Health and Children to come to update the House on the matter. I will have no difficulty in arranging such a debate.

Senators Cummins and Burke referred to remarks made by the Minister for Transport about county and borough councils. County and borough councils have made a tremendous contribution during the years. I do not think this is the Minister, Deputy Dempsey's area of responsibility.