John Paul Phelan (Fine Gael)

If we are to believe what we read in the newspapers, his reward is coming soon in Luxembourg. I am sure that he would agree that an appointment to such a position should be subject to scrutiny. I could think of nobody who would be better to fill that position than Senator Boyle, even though I have had my differences with him over the years. However, it does not mean we should not be in a position to question him on it.

Deputy Cuffe stated that:

This Bill is about merit rather than patronage. There are still too many village chieftains in politics. There are too many pork barrel politicians who dispense the spoils of office to those who have helped them along the way.

He went on to state that even when Fianna Fáil was out of government, it was effectively in government because of the amount of people the party had appointed to State boards. Perhaps Senator Boyle will be able to enlighten us on his current thinking on this issue when he gets a chance to contribute.

In his response, can the Minister of State deal briefly with the Employment Appeals Tribunal? He might be able to enlighten me about the criteria for the appointment of people to that tribunal. What experience levels are required for such appointment? I have been informed that one of those appointed is usually a solicitor, although he or she does not require any particular employment law expertise. Are the appointments renewed every three years? What is the term of office of appointees to the tribunal?

I commend Senator Ross on his introduction of this thoughtful Bill. We will support it on Second Stage.